Counterfactual analysis

反事实分析
  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    COVID-19疫苗在减少严重症状和死亡方面表现出显著疗效,尽管它们在预防传播方面的有效性因人口的年龄特征和主要变体而异。这项研究评估了COVID-19疫苗接种运动在西班牙巴斯克地区的影响,在全球老年人中比例第四高。使用住院的流行病学数据,ICU入院,死亡人数,和疫苗接种覆盖率,我们校准了四个版本的常微分方程模型,并对年龄结构和传递函数进行了不同的假设。通过将疫苗接种率设置为零而所有其他参数保持恒定来模拟反事实无疫苗情况。最初的疫苗接种计划估计已阻止了46,000至75,000例住院,6,000至11,000ICU入院,15,000至24,000人死亡,将这些结果减少73-86%。最显著的影响发生在2021年第三季度,与Delta变种的主导地位和疫苗接种率超过60%相吻合。敏感性分析显示,疫苗接种覆盖率对避免结果的影响比疫苗效力更大。总的来说,巴斯克地区的疫苗接种运动显著降低了严重的COVID-19结局,与全球估计保持一致,并展示不同建模方法的稳健性。
    COVID-19 vaccines have demonstrated significant efficacy in reducing severe symptoms and fatalities, although their effectiveness in preventing transmission varies depending on the population\'s age profile and the dominant variant. This study evaluates the impact of the COVID-19 vaccination campaign in the Basque Country region of Spain, which has the fourth highest proportion of elderly individuals worldwide. Using epidemiological data on hospitalizations, ICU admissions, fatalities, and vaccination coverage, we calibrated four versions of an ordinary differential equations model with varying assumptions on the age structure and transmission function. Counterfactual no-vaccine scenarios were simulated by setting the vaccination rate to zero while all other parameters were held constant. The initial vaccination rollout is estimated to have prevented 46,000 to 75,000 hospitalizations, 6,000 to 11,000 ICU admissions, and 15,000 to 24,000 deaths, reducing these outcomes by 73-86%. The most significant impact occurred during the third quarter of 2021, coinciding with the Delta variant\'s dominance and a vaccination rate exceeding 60%. Sensitivity analysis revealed that vaccination coverage had a more substantial effect on averted outcomes than vaccine efficacy. Overall, the vaccination campaign in the Basque Country significantly reduced severe COVID-19 outcomes, aligning with global estimates and demonstrating robustness across different modeling approaches.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

    求助全文

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    尽管对环境和人类健康具有负外部性,今天的经济仍然产生过量的二氧化碳排放。因此,各国政府正试图将生产和消费转向更可持续的模式,以减少二氧化碳排放对环境的影响。欧洲联盟,特别是,实施了一项创新政策,通过建立排放权市场来减少二氧化碳排放,排放交易系统。本文的目的是进行反事实分析,以衡量排放权交易体系对减少二氧化碳排放的影响。为此,使用了一种最近开发的统计机器学习方法,称为具有固定效应估计的矩阵完成,并与传统的计量经济学技术进行了比较。我们将具有固定效应估计的矩阵完成应用于二氧化碳排放矩阵的缺失反事实条目的预测,该二氧化碳排放矩阵的元素(按国家逐行索引,按年份逐列索引)表示排放量,而没有国家-年份对的排放交易系统。获得的结果,通过可靠的诊断测试证实,显示排放交易体系对减少二氧化碳排放的显着影响:我们分析中包括的大多数欧盟国家在排放交易体系处理期间将其二氧化碳总排放量(与选定行业相关)减少了约15.4%2005-2020年,与没有排放交易体系政策的情况下实现的二氧化碳总排放量(与相同行业相关)相比。最后,讨论了这项研究的几个管理/实际意义,以及它可能的扩展。
    Despite the negative externalities on the environment and human health, today\'s economies still produce excessive carbon dioxide emissions. As a result, governments are trying to shift production and consumption to more sustainable models that reduce the environmental impact of carbon dioxide emissions. The European Union, in particular, has implemented an innovative policy to reduce carbon dioxide emissions by creating a market for emission rights, the emissions trading system. The objective of this paper is to perform a counterfactual analysis to measure the impact of the emissions trading system on the reduction of carbon dioxide emissions. For this purpose, a recently-developed statistical machine learning method called matrix completion with fixed effects estimation is used and compared to traditional econometric techniques. We apply matrix completion with fixed effects estimation to the prediction of missing counterfactual entries of a carbon dioxide emissions matrix whose elements (indexed row-wise by country and column-wise by year) represent emissions without the emissions trading system for country-year pairs. The results obtained, confirmed by robust diagnostic tests, show a significant effect of the emissions trading system on the reduction of carbon dioxide emissions: the majority of European Union countries included in our analysis reduced their total carbon dioxide emissions (associated with selected industries) by about 15.4% during the emissions trading system treatment period 2005-2020, compared to the total carbon dioxide emissions (associated with the same industries) that would have been achieved in the absence of the emissions trading system policy. Finally, several managerial/practical implications of the study are discussed, together with its possible extensions.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    将代谢组学纳入公共卫生实践的兴趣日益浓厚。然而,黑人女性在许多代谢组学研究中的代表性不足。如果黑人和白人女性的代谢组学特征不同,这种代表性不足可能会加剧现有的黑白健康差距。因此,我们旨在估计美国黑人和白人女性之间的代谢差异我们利用来自两个前瞻性队列的数据:护士健康研究(NHS;n=2077)和妇女健康倡议(WHI;n=2128)。WHI用作复制队列。通过液相色谱-串联质谱法测量血浆代谢物(n=334)。使用线性回归和代谢物集富集分析估计观察到的代谢组学差异。使用逆比值比加权估计了假设人群中14个危险因素在种族群体中的分布相等的残余代谢组学差异。在NHS中,对于大多数代谢物观察到黑白差异(75种代谢物,观察到差异≥|0.50|标准偏差)。黑人女性在大多数代谢物方面的平均水平低于白人女性(例如,对于N6,N6-二甲基赖氨酸,平均黑白差=-0.98标准偏差;95%CI:-1.11,-0.84)。在代谢物集富集分析中,黑人妇女的甘油三酯水平较低,磷脂酰胆碱,溶血磷脂酰乙醇胺,磷脂酰乙醇胺,和有机杂环化合物,但是磷脂酰乙醇胺的含量更高,磷脂酰胆碱,胆固醇酯,和肉碱。在一个假设的人群中,14个危险因素的分布是相等的,黑白代谢组学差异持续存在。大多数结果在WHI中复制(88%的272个代谢物可用于复制)。黑人和白人女性之间存在代谢组学特征的实质性差异。未来的研究应该优先考虑种族代表性。
    There is growing interest in incorporating metabolomics into public health practice. However, Black women are under-represented in many metabolomics studies. If metabolomic profiles differ between Black and White women, this under-representation may exacerbate existing Black-White health disparities. We therefore aimed to estimate metabolomic differences between Black and White women in the U.S. We leveraged data from two prospective cohorts: the Nurses\' Health Study (NHS; n = 2077) and Women\'s Health Initiative (WHI; n = 2128). The WHI served as the replication cohort. Plasma metabolites (n = 334) were measured via liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry. Observed metabolomic differences were estimated using linear regression and metabolite set enrichment analyses. Residual metabolomic differences in a hypothetical population in which the distributions of 14 risk factors were equalized across racial groups were estimated using inverse odds ratio weighting. In the NHS, Black-White differences were observed for most metabolites (75 metabolites with observed differences ≥ |0.50| standard deviations). Black women had lower average levels than White women for most metabolites (e.g., for N6, N6-dimethlylysine, mean Black-White difference = - 0.98 standard deviations; 95% CI: - 1.11, - 0.84). In metabolite set enrichment analyses, Black women had lower levels of triglycerides, phosphatidylcholines, lysophosphatidylethanolamines, phosphatidylethanolamines, and organoheterocyclic compounds, but higher levels of phosphatidylethanolamine plasmalogens, phosphatidylcholine plasmalogens, cholesteryl esters, and carnitines. In a hypothetical population in which distributions of 14 risk factors were equalized, Black-White metabolomic differences persisted. Most results replicated in the WHI (88% of 272 metabolites available for replication). Substantial differences in metabolomic profiles exist between Black and White women. Future studies should prioritize racial representation.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

    求助全文

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    COVID-19对全球卫生和世界经济构成了前所未有的挑战。大流行两年后,COVID-19的广泛影响继续加深,影响汽车行业及其供应链等不同行业。本研究提出了一种结合仿真建模和基于树的监督机器学习技术的混合方法,以探索终端市场需求中断的影响。具体来说,我们应用重生树合奏的概念,它们很强大,同时,易于解释的分类器,以半导体行业为例。首先,我们展示了如何使用重生树集合来探索由供应链仿真模型生成的数据。为此,我们展示了不同的行为和结构参数的影响,并显示了它们的变化对特定关键绩效指标的影响,例如,库存水平。最后,我们利用反事实分析来确定半导体公司的详细管理见解,以减轻对一个梯队或整个供应链的不利影响。我们的混合方法提供了一个仿真模型,该模型由基于树的监督机器学习模型增强,公司可以使用该模型来确定最佳措施,以减轻终端市场需求中断的不利影响。我们通过将反事实分析的结果向后集成到仿真模型中,以了解多级供应链中的整体动态,从而关闭了分析的循环。
    COVID-19 has posed unprecedented challenges to global health and the world economy. Two years into the pandemic, the widespread impact of COVID-19 continues to deepen, impacting different industries such as the automotive industry and its supply chain. This study presents a hybrid approach combining simulation modeling and tree-based supervised machine learning techniques to explore the implications of end-market demand disruptions. Specifically, we apply the concept of born-again tree ensembles, which are powerful and, at the same time, easily interpretable classifiers, to the case of the semiconductor industry. First, we show how to use born-again tree ensembles to explore data generated by a supply chain simulation model. To this end, we demonstrate the influence of varying behavioral and structural parameters and show the impact of their variation on specific key performance indicators, e.g., the inventory level. Finally, we leverage a counterfactual analysis to identify detailed managerial insights for semiconductor companies to mitigate adverse impacts on one echelon or the entire supply chain. Our hybrid approach provides a simulation model enhanced by a tree-based supervised machine learning model that companies can use to determine optimal measures for mitigating the adverse effects of end-market demand disruptions. We close the loop of our analysis by integrating the findings of the counterfactual analysis backward into the simulation model to understand the overall dynamics within the multi-echelon supply chain.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    新冠肺炎研究议程的经验教训提供了一个结构,可以从全球灾难性风险(GCR)的角度研究新冠肺炎大流行和大流行应对措施。议程列出了我们研究的目标,调查重大改变大流行进程的关键决定和行动(或未能决定或采取行动),旨在改善未来的备灾和响应。它还询问我们如何将这些经验教训转移到(潜在的)全球灾难性风险管理的其他领域,例如极端气候变化,生物多样性的彻底丧失和新技术带来的极端风险的治理。我们的研究旨在确定关键时刻-“拐点”-显著塑造了COVID-19的灾难性轨迹。为此,本研究议程确定了可能存在这种拐点的四个大集群:大流行准备,早期行动,疫苗和非药物干预。目的是深入研究这些集群中的每一个,以确定大流行的进程是否以及如何变化,在国家和全球层面,使用反事实分析。使用四个方面来评估每个聚类内的候选拐点:1.当时可用的信息;2.所使用的决策过程;3.实施不同行动方案的能力和能力,和4。向不同公众传达信息和决策。研究议程确定了每个分组中所有四个方面的关键问题,这些问题应该能够确定COVID-19和大流行应对措施的关键经验教训。
    The Lessons from Covid-19 Research Agenda offers a structure to study the COVID-19 pandemic and the pandemic response from a Global Catastrophic Risk (GCR) perspective. The agenda sets out the aims of our study, which is to investigate the key decisions and actions (or failures to decide or to act) that significantly altered the course of the pandemic, with the aim of improving disaster preparedness and response in the future. It also asks how we can transfer these lessons to other areas of (potential) global catastrophic risk management such as extreme climate change, radical loss of biodiversity and the governance of extreme risks posed by new technologies. Our study aims to identify key moments- \'inflection points\'- that significantly shaped the catastrophic trajectory of COVID-19. To that end this Research Agenda has identified four broad clusters where such inflection points are likely to exist: pandemic preparedness, early action, vaccines and non-pharmaceutical interventions. The aim is to drill down into each of these clusters to ascertain whether and how the course of the pandemic might have gone differently, both at the national and the global level, using counterfactual analysis. Four aspects are used to assess candidate inflection points within each cluster: 1. the information available at the time; 2. the decision-making processes used; 3. the capacity and ability to implement different courses of action, and 4. the communication of information and decisions to different publics. The Research Agenda identifies crucial questions in each cluster for all four aspects that should enable the identification of the key lessons from COVID-19 and the pandemic response.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    Inspection,代表自上而下的环境管理实践,也被称为竞选式治理,被中央政府用来减轻地方环境污染。然而,碳减排没有因果关系。采用交错差异(DiD),我发现被检查的城市减少了3.72%和2.34%的碳强度和碳排放,分别,具有经济意义。实行三重差异战略,我建议渠道是地方人大和政治协商会议的提案,政府关注,环境法规,产业结构,绿色创新。此外,异质效应表明,市委书记被分配到他们的出生地,党的地位和年龄越大,那些有自然科学专业的人,更有利于检查实现碳减排。替代的DID规范表明,“回顾”检查可实现持续的碳减排。我支持自上而下的检查有助于实现应对气候变化和减少温室气体排放的论点。
    Inspection, standing for top-down environmental management practices, also known as campaign-style governance, is used by central governments to lessen local environmental pollution. However, there is no causal evidence for carbon abatement. Employing staggered difference-in-differences (DiD), I find that inspected cities mitigate carbon intensity and carbon emissions by 3.72% and 2.34%, respectively, with economic significance. Conducting a triple difference strategy, I suggest the channels are the local people\'s congresses and political consultative conferences\' proposals, government attention, environmental regulation, industrial structure, and green innovation. Also, the heterogeneous effects suggest that municipal party secretaries assigned to their birthplace, the older the party standing and age, and those with natural sciences majors, are more conducive to the inspection achieving carbon mitigation. An alternative DiD specification shows that the \"look-back\" inspection achieves sustained carbon reduction. I support the argument that top-down inspection helps achieve resilience to climate change and reduce greenhouse gas emissions.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

    求助全文

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    社交软技能对于工人执行任务至关重要,然而,很难对人们进行培训,并在需要时重新调整他们的技能。在目前的工作中,我们分析了在意大利与88个经济部门和14个年龄组相关的职业中,COVID-19大流行对社会软技能的可能影响.我们利用来自ICP的详细信息(即意大利相当于O*Net),由意大利国家公共政策分析研究所提供,从微观数据中研究劳动力的连续检测,由意大利国家统计局(ISTAT)提供,以及ISTAT关于意大利人口的数据。基于这些数据,我们模拟了COVID-19对工作场所特征和工作方式的影响,这些特征和工作方式受到大流行期间封锁措施和卫生倾向的更严重影响(例如,身体接近,面对面的讨论,远程工作)。然后,我们应用矩阵完成-一种常用于推荐系统的机器学习技术-来预测工作条件变化时每个职业所需的社会软技能重要性水平的平均变化。因为一些变化可能会在不久的将来持续存在。专业,部门,显示负平均变化的年龄组面临着社会软技能禀赋的不足,这最终可能会导致生产率下降。
    Social soft skills are crucial for workers to perform their tasks, yet it is hard to train people on them and to readapt their skill set when needed. In the present work, we analyze the possible effects of the COVID-19 pandemic on social soft skills in the context of Italian occupations related to 88 economic sectors and 14 age groups. We leverage detailed information coming from ICP (i.e. the Italian equivalent of O*Net), provided by the Italian National Institute for the Analysis of Public Policy, from the microdata for research on the continuous detection of labor force, provided by the Italian National Institute of Statistics (ISTAT), and from ISTAT data on the Italian population. Based on these data, we simulate the impact of COVID-19 on workplace characteristics and working styles that were more severely affected by the lockdown measures and the sanitary dispositions during the pandemic (e.g. physical proximity, face-to-face discussions, working remotely). We then apply matrix completion-a machine-learning technique often used in the context of recommender systems-to predict the average variation in the social soft skills importance levels required for each occupation when working conditions change, as some changes might be persistent in the near future. Professions, sectors, and age groups showing negative average variations are exposed to a deficit in their social soft-skills endowment, which might ultimately lead to lower productivity.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    生物多样性补偿是一种具有全球影响力的政策机制,用于协调发展与生物多样性丧失之间的权衡。然而,几乎没有有力的证据证明它的有效性。我们评估了管辖权抵消政策的结果(维多利亚,澳大利亚)。根据维多利亚州的本地植被框架(2002-2013)的偏移,旨在防止残留植被的损失和退化,并在植被范围和质量上产生收益。我们将偏移量归类为具有接近完整基准木本植被覆盖的偏移量(“避免损失”,2702公顷)且覆盖不完整(“再生”,501公顷),并评估了2008年至2018年对木本植被范围的影响。我们使用了两种方法来估计反事实。首先,我们在生物物理协变量上使用了统计匹配:保护影响评估中的一种常用方法,但有可能忽视潜在的重要的心理社会混杂因素。第二,我们将偏移的变化与研究期间未偏移但后来作为偏移登记的部位的变化进行了比较。部分考虑到自我选择偏差(土地所有者登记土地可能具有影响他们如何管理土地的共同特征)。匹配生物物理协变量,我们估计,再生补偿增加了1.9%-3.6%/年比非补偿场地(从2008年到2018年为138-180公顷),但这种影响在第二种方法中减弱(0.3%-1.9%/年比非补偿场地多;从2008年到2018年为19-97公顷),当单个异常地块被移除时消失。两种方法都没有检测到避免的损失补偿的任何影响。由于数据限制,我们无法最终证明是否实现了“净收益”(NG)的政策目标。然而,鉴于我们的证据表明,木本植被的大部分增加并不是额外的(如果没有该计划,就会发生),NG结果似乎不太可能。结果突出了在监管生物多样性抵消政策的设计和评估中考虑自我选择偏差的重要性,以及对管辖权的生物多样性抵消政策进行强有力的影响评估的挑战。
    Biodiversity offsetting is a globally influential policy mechanism for reconciling trade-offs between development and biodiversity loss. However, there is little robust evidence of its effectiveness. We evaluated the outcomes of a jurisdictional offsetting policy (Victoria, Australia). Offsets under Victoria\'s Native Vegetation Framework (2002-2013) aimed to prevent loss and degradation of remnant vegetation, and generate gains in vegetation extent and quality. We categorised offsets into those with near-complete baseline woody vegetation cover (\"avoided loss\", 2702 ha) and with incomplete cover (\"regeneration\", 501 ha), and evaluated impacts on woody vegetation extent from 2008 to 2018. We used two approaches to estimate the counterfactual. First, we used statistical matching on biophysical covariates: a common approach in conservation impact evaluation, but which risks ignoring potentially important psychosocial confounders. Second, we compared changes in offsets with changes in sites that were not offsets for the study duration but were later enrolled as offsets, to partially account for self-selection bias (where landholders enrolling land may have shared characteristics affecting how they manage land). Matching on biophysical covariates, we estimated that regeneration offsets increased woody vegetation extent by 1.9%-3.6%/year more than non-offset sites (138-180 ha from 2008 to 2018) but this effect weakened with the second approach (0.3%-1.9%/year more than non-offset sites; 19-97 ha from 2008 to 2018) and disappeared when a single outlier land parcel was removed. Neither approach detected any impact of avoided loss offsets. We cannot conclusively demonstrate whether the policy goal of \'net gain\' (NG) was achieved because of data limitations. However, given our evidence that the majority of increases in woody vegetation extent were not additional (would have happened without the scheme), a NG outcome seems unlikely. The results highlight the importance of considering self-selection bias in the design and evaluation of regulatory biodiversity offsetting policy, and the challenges of conducting robust impact evaluations of jurisdictional biodiversity offsetting policies.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    本文分析了工资自动指数化对就业的影响。为了提高竞争力,增加就业,比利时于2015年暂停了自动工资指数化系统。这导致所有工人的实际工资下降了2%。在没有合适的对照组的情况下,我们使用机器学习进行反事实分析。我们根据被治疗公司的治疗前演变,人为地构建了对照组,以进行差异分析。我们发现对就业的积极影响为1.2%,对应的劳动力需求弹性为-0.6。这种影响对制造企业来说更为明显,其中弹性达到-1。这些结果表明,自动工资指数化机制的暂停可以有效地维护就业。
    This paper analyzes the impact of automatic wage indexation on employment. To boost competitiveness and increase employment, Belgium suspended its automatic wage indexation system in 2015. This resulted in a 2% fall in real wages for all workers. In the absence of a suitable control group, we use machine learning for the counterfactual analysis. We artificially construct the control group for a difference-in-difference analysis based on the pre-treatment evolution of treated firms. We find a positive impact on employment of 1.2%, which corresponds to a labor demand elasticity of - 0.6. This effect is more pronounced for manufacturing firms, where the elasticity reaches - 1. These results show that a suspension of the automatic wage indexation mechanism can be effective in preserving employment.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    SARS-CoV-2(COVID-19)的全球大流行与美国阿片类药物使用障碍患者的负面影响有关。这项研究的重点是从地理空间角度分析美国COVID-19背景下阿片类药物参与的死亡率。我们调查了2020年阿片类药物相关死亡的时空模式,并将这些死亡的时空模式与前三年(2017-2019年)的模式进行了比较,以了解COVID-19大流行背景下的变化。使用反事实分析框架和时空随机森林(STRF)模型来估计与大流行有关的阿片类药物相关死亡人数的增加。为了进一步了解阿片类药物死亡与COVID-19相关因素之间的关系,我们为芝加哥市建立了一个时空随机森林模型,在2020年期间,与阿片类药物相关的死亡人数急剧增加。该模型确定的高级指标,如按人群调整的阳性COVID-19病例数和大流行期间在家居住时间的变化,用于生成芝加哥COVID-19大流行期间阿片类药物过量的脆弱性指数。
    The global pandemic of SARS-CoV-2 (COVID-19) has been linked to adversely impacting individuals with opioid use disorder in the United States. This study focuses on analyzing opioid-involved mortality in the context of COVID-19 in the U.S. from a geospatial perspective. We investigated spatiotemporal patterns of opioid-involved deaths during 2020 and compared the spatiotemporal pattern of these deaths with patterns for the previous three years (2017-2019) to understand changes in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic. A counterfactual analysis framework together with a space-time random forest (STRF) model were used to estimate the increase in opioid-involved deaths related to the pandemic. To gain further insight into the relationship between opioid deaths and COVID-19-related factors, we built a space-time random forest model for the City of Chicago, that experienced a steep increase in opioid-related deaths during 2020. High ranking indicators identified by the model such as the number of positive COVID-19 cases adjusted by population and the change in stay-at-home dwell time during the pandemic were used to generate a vulnerability index for opioid overdoses during the COVID-19 pandemic in Chicago.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

    求助全文

公众号