目的:有效的视觉感知处理是外科手术能力的许多组成部分之一。当直立观看时,人脸识别是最有效的。然而,目前尚不清楚这种感知敏感性如何影响眼睑对称性。这项研究调查了外科医生和外行人从不同空间角度感知眼睑不对称性的准确性和效率。
方法:进行了一项前瞻性心理测量实验,其中从美国眼科整形和重建外科学会和巴西眼科整形外科学会招募了眼整形外科医生,和对照参与者是通过众包(亚马逊的机械土耳其人)招募的。不同程度眼睑异常的人脸标准插图,偏侧性,我们向参与者介绍性别和旋转情况,要求他们判断眼睑是对称还是不对称.
结果:调查由75名眼整形外科医生(男性占49.33%;平均年龄为46.9±10.7)和192名非专业人员(男性占54.6%;平均年龄34.6±11.3岁)完成。在眼整形外科医生中,与直立偏差与反应时间增加和比例正确降低显著相关(对于峰值0.68,95%CI0.60~0.77,p<0.001;对于峰值0.52,95%CI0.32~0.87,p=0.012;对于聚集反应0.56,95%CI0.51~0.61,p<0.001,OR/180).眼整形外科医生对峰值和下垂进行了额外的试验,证明了准确性的提高和反应时间的减少。
结论:眼整形外科医生更准确地感知眼睑不对称性,并能更好地补偿倒置的感觉信息。然而,随着额外的试验,准确性增加,反应时间减少,提示可训练性和改善倒置残疾的潜力。
OBJECTIVE: Effective visual perceptual processing is one of the many components of surgical competence. Human face identification is most efficient when viewed upright. However, it is not yet clear how this perception sensitivity impacts eyelid symmetry. This study investigates surgeons\' and laypeople\'s accuracy and efficiency in perceiving eyelid asymmetry from different spatial perspectives.
METHODS: A prospective psychometric experiment was conducted where oculoplastic surgeons were recruited from the American Society of Ophthalmic Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery and the Brazilian Oculoplastic Surgery Society, and control participants were recruited via crowdsourcing (Amazon\'s Mechanical Turk). Standard illustrations of the human face with varying degrees of eyelid abnormality, laterality, gender and rotation were presented to participants who were asked to judge whether the eyelids were symmetric or asymmetric.
RESULTS: The survey was completed by 75 oculoplastic surgeons (49.33% male; mean age of 46.9±10.7) and 192 lay individuals (54.6% male; mean age 34.6±11.3 years). Among oculoplastic surgeons, deviation from upright was significantly associated with increased reaction time and decreased proportion correct (OR per 45° for peak 0.68, 95% CI 0.60 to 0.77, p<0.001; OR per 45° for ptosis 0.52, 95% CI 0.32 to 0.87, p=0.012; OR per 180° for aggregate responses 0.56, 95% CI 0.51 to 0.61, p<0.001). Oculoplastic surgeons demonstrated increasing accuracy and decreasing reaction time with additional trials for both peak and ptosis.
CONCLUSIONS: Oculoplastic surgeons perceive eyelid asymmetries more accurately and can better compensate for inverted sensory information. However, accuracy increases and reaction time decreases with additional trials, suggesting trainability and potential for improvement in inversion disability.