目标:在帕金森病患者中,添加外部提示的效果是什么(即,视觉,听觉或躯体感觉提示)步行训练与仅步行训练相比,移动性,balance,对跌倒和冻结的恐惧?参与干预后是否有任何益处延续或维持?
方法:采用荟萃分析对随机试验进行系统评价。
方法:患有帕金森病的非卧床成年人。
方法:带外部提示的步行训练与不带外部提示的步行训练相比。
方法:步行(即,速度,步幅长度和节奏),移动性,balance,害怕跌倒,冻结和参与。
结果:纳入10项试验,共涉及309名参与者。纳入试验的平均PEDro评分为5分(范围4至8分)。带听觉提示的步行训练比单独的步行训练提高了0.09m/s(95%CI0.02至0.15)的步行速度。尽管最好的估计是听觉提示也可以将步幅提高5厘米,这一估计不精确(95%CI-2~11).在步行训练中增加视觉提示并不能提高步行速度或步幅。关于节奏的结果,移动性,balance,害怕跌倒,干预期之后的福利冻结和维持仍然不确定。
结论:本系统综述提供了低质量的证据,证明在改善帕金森病患者的步行速度方面,带听觉提示的步行训练比单独的步行训练更有效。提示是一种廉价且易于实施的干预措施,所以平均估计可能被认为是临床上有价值的,尽管置信区间跨越临床上微不足道和值得的影响。
背景:PROSPEROCRD42021255065。
OBJECTIVE: In people with Parkinson\'s disease, what is the effect of adding external cueing (ie, visual, auditory or somatosensorial cueing) to walking training compared with walking training alone in terms of walking, mobility, balance, fear of falling and freezing? Are any benefits carried over to participation or maintained beyond the intervention period?
METHODS: Systematic
review of randomised trials with meta-analysis.
METHODS: Ambulatory adults with Parkinson\'s disease.
METHODS: Walking training with external cueing compared with walking training without external cueing.
METHODS: Walking (ie, speed, stride length and cadence), mobility, balance, fear of falling, freezing and participation.
RESULTS: Ten trials involving a total of 309 participants were included. The mean PEDro score of the included trials was 5 (range 4 to 8). Walking training with auditory cueing improved walking speed by 0.09 m/s (95% CI 0.02 to 0.15) more than walking training alone. Although the best estimate was that auditory cueing may also improve stride length by 5 cm, this estimate was imprecise (95% CI -2 to 11). The addition of visual cueing to walking training did not improve walking speed or stride length. Results regarding cadence, mobility, balance, fear of falling, and freezing and maintenance of benefits beyond the intervention period remain uncertain.
CONCLUSIONS: This systematic
review provided low-quality evidence that walking training with auditory cueing is more effective than walking training alone for improving walking speed in Parkinson\'s disease. Cueing is an inexpensive and easy to implement intervention, so the mean estimate might be considered clinically worthwhile, although the confidence interval spans clinically trivial and worthwhile effects.
BACKGROUND: PROSPERO CRD42021255065.