背景:以前没有研究报道过智障成年人(IDs)经历抑郁症的心理治疗结果的预测因素和调节因素。我们根据一项随机对照试验调查了基线变量作为结果预测因子和调节因子,该试验将行为激活与指导自助进行了比较。
方法:本研究是对随机临床试验期间收集的数据进行的探索性二次数据分析。参与者(n=161)随机接受行为激活或指导自助,并随访12个月。如果先前已证明治疗前变量与患有ID的成年人患抑郁症的风险增加有关,或者已被报道为心理治疗抑郁症的潜在预测因子或调节因子,则将其包括在内。主要结果衡量标准,格拉斯哥抑郁量表(GDS-LD),在混合效应回归分析中用作因变量,测试结果的预测因子和调节因子,与基线GDS-LD,治疗组,研究中心和抗抑郁药的使用作为固定效应,和治疗师作为随机效应。
结果:较高的基线焦虑(与焦虑增加1分相关的结果平均差0.164,95%置信区间[CI]0.031,0.297;P=0.016),较低的表现智商(IQ)(与IQ增加1分相关的结果平均差异0.145,95%CI0.009,0.280;P=0.037)和听力障碍(平均差异3.449,95%CI0.466,6.432;P=0.024)是较差结果的预测因素,而基线时抑郁症状的严重程度更高(与抑郁症增加1分相关的结局的平均差异-0.160,95%CI-0.806,-0.414;P<0.001),更高的变化预期(与变化预期增加1分相关的平均结局差异-1.013,95%CI-1.711,-0.314;p0.005)和更高的治疗疗程百分比(治疗疗程百分比增加1分的平均结局差异-0.058,95%CI-0.099,-0.016;P=0.007)是校正随机分组后治疗结果更积极的预测因素.最终模型包括抑郁和焦虑症状的严重程度,较低的WASI性能IQ子量表,听力障碍,12个月时GDS-LD总评分差异的35.3%(R2=0.353,F4,128=17.24,P<0.001).没有证据表明基线变量对行为激活或指导自助治疗的结果有调节作用。
结论:我们的结果表明,基线变量可能是成人ID患者心理治疗结果的有用预测因子。需要进一步的研究来检查这些潜在预测因子的价值。然而,我们的研究结果表明,在使用心理疗法治疗患有IDs的成年人所经历的抑郁症时,治疗师会考虑基线变量如何使他们能够调整治疗方法.
No previous studies have reported predictors and moderators of outcome of psychological therapies for depression experienced by adults with intellectual disabilities (IDs). We investigated baseline variables as outcome predictors and moderators based on a randomised controlled trial where behavioural activation was compared with guided self-help.
This study was an exploratory secondary data analysis of data collected during a randomised clinical trial. Participants (n = 161) were randomised to behavioural activation or guided self-help and followed up for 12 months. Pre-treatment variables were included if they have previously been shown to be associated with an increased risk of having depression in adults with IDs or have been reported as a potential predictor or moderator of outcome of treatment for depression with psychological therapies. The primary outcome measure, the Glasgow Depression Scale for Adults with Learning Disabilities (GDS-LD), was used as the dependant variable in mixed effects regression analyses testing for predictors and moderators of outcome, with baseline GDS-LD, treatment group, study centre and antidepressant use as fixed effects, and therapist as a random effect.
Higher baseline anxiety (mean difference in outcome associated with a 1 point increase in anxiety 0.164, 95% confidence interval [CI] 0.031, 0.297; P = 0.016), lower performance intelligence quotient (IQ) (mean difference in outcome associated with a 1 point increase in IQ 0.145, 95% CI 0.009, 0.280; P = 0.037) and hearing impairment (mean difference 3.449, 95% CI 0.466, 6.432; P = 0.024) were predictors of poorer outcomes, whilst greater severity of depressive symptoms at baseline (mean difference in outcome associated with 1 point increase in depression -0.160, 95% CI -0.806, -0.414; P < 0.001), higher expectation of change (mean difference in outcome associated with a 1 point increase in expectation of change -1.013, 95% CI -1.711, -0.314; p 0.005) and greater percentage of therapy sessions attended (mean difference in outcome with 1 point increase in percentage of sessions attended -0.058, 95% CI -0.099, -0.016; P = 0.007) were predictors of more positive outcomes for treatment after adjusting for randomised group allocation. The final model included severity of depressive and anxiety symptoms, lower WASI performance IQ subscale, hearing impairment, higher expectation of change and percentage of therapy sessions attended and explained 35.3% of the variance in the total GDS-LD score at 12 months (R2 = 0.353, F4, 128 = 17.24, P < 0.001). There is no evidence that baseline variables had a moderating effect on outcome for treatment with behavioural activation or guided self-help.
Our results suggest that baseline variables may be useful predictors of outcomes of psychological therapies for adults with IDs. Further research is required to examine the value of these potential predictors. However, our findings suggest that therapists consider how baseline variables may enable them to tailor their therapeutic approach when using psychological therapies to treat depression experienced by adults with IDs.