间接互惠模型研究社会规范如何促进合作。在这些模型中,合作的个人建立了积极的声誉,这反过来又有助于他们未来的互动。合作的确切声誉利益取决于现有的规范,这可能会随着时间的推移而改变。以往的研究主要集中在社会规范的稳定性上。人们对与许多其他人竞争时社会规范最初是如何演变的知之甚少。全面的进化分析,然而,一直很难。即使在所谓的三阶规范的相对简单的空间中,有成千上万的可能性,每个人都诱导自己的声誉动态。为了应对这一挑战,我们使用大规模的计算机模拟。我们研究了每个三阶范数的声誉动态以及它们之间的所有进化过渡。与只有少数规范的既定工作相反,我们发现,在混合良好的人群中,合作很难维持。然而,在群体结构的人群中,合作可以出现。在我们的模拟中最成功的规范是特别简单的。它认为合作是普遍积极的,叛逃通常是消极的,除非叛逃采取合理的惩罚形式。这项研究揭示了社会规范的复杂相互作用,他们诱导的声誉动态,和人口结构。
Models of indirect reciprocity study how social norms promote cooperation. In these models, cooperative individuals build up a positive reputation, which in turn helps them in their future interactions. The exact reputational benefits of cooperation depend on the norm in place, which may change over time. Previous research focused on the stability of social norms. Much less is known about how social norms initially evolve when competing with many others. A comprehensive evolutionary analysis, however, has been difficult. Even among the comparably simple space of so-called third-order norms, there are thousands of possibilities, each one inducing its own reputation dynamics. To address this challenge, we use large-scale computer simulations. We study the reputation dynamics of each third-order norm and all evolutionary transitions between them. In contrast to established work with only a handful of norms, we find that cooperation is hard to maintain in well-mixed populations. However, within group-structured populations, cooperation can emerge. The most successful norm in our simulations is particularly simple. It regards cooperation as universally positive, and defection as usually negative-unless defection takes the form of justified punishment. This research sheds light on the complex interplay of social norms, their induced reputation dynamics, and population structure.