Criminal responsibility

刑事责任
  • 文章类型: Case Reports
    额颞叶痴呆(FTD)影响大脑的额叶和颞叶,导致人格改变,语言障碍,和行为障碍,包括冲动和抑制。由于FTD的不断发展,在法医评估中评估责任和累犯风险具有挑战性。尽管文献有限,我们介绍了一个45岁的男性,没有法律或病史,由于与额颞叶痴呆(bvFTD)的行为变异相关的行为变化而实施犯罪行为。初步评估发现他不负责任,具有不可评估的累犯风险。随后的评估显示,基于临床演变,累犯风险较低。我们将考虑现有文献和瑞士法学来讨论这些发现。
    Frontotemporal dementia (FTD) affects the frontal and temporal lobes of the brain, leading to personality changes, language impairments, and behavioral disturbances, including impulsivity and disinhibition. Assessing responsibility and recidivism risk in forensic evaluations is challenging due to the evolving nature of FTD. Despite limited literature, we present a case of a 45-year-old man with no prior legal or medical history, who committed criminal acts due to behavioral changes linked to the behavioral variant of frontotemporal dementia (bvFTD). Initial assessment found him irresponsible, with a non-evaluable risk of recidivism. Subsequent evaluation showed a low recidivism risk based on clinical evolution. We discuss these findings considering existing literature and Swiss jurisprudence.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    许多国家的刑事立法中隐藏着一个共识,即未成年犯的刑事责任能力与同龄人没有显着差异。本文的目的是检验这一假设。本文的研究对象是J省187名未成年犯,中国,被拘留的人,和2449名初中学生,以S省的高中和大学为比较对象。我们对收集的材料进行独立样本t检验和单向方差分析(ANOVA)。
    (1)少年犯的自我控制能力(109.30,123.59)和移情能力(63.86,72.45)与普通未成年人有显著差异,辩证思维能力差异无统计学意义;(2)除了母亲的文化程度和家庭收入对辩证思维能力的影响,其他变量对三种能力无统计学意义。因此,有人建议,少年犯的矫正计划和手段应侧重于自我控制能力和移情能力的提高。
    UNASSIGNED: There is a consensus hidden in the criminal legislation of many countries that the criminal responsibility capacity of juvenile offenders is not significantly different from that of their peers. The purpose of this paper was to test this hypothesis. The research objects of this paper were 187 juvenile offenders in J Province, China, who are under detention measures, and 2,449 students from junior high school, senior high school and university in S Province as comparison objects. We subjected the gathered materials to independent-samples t-tests and one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA).
    UNASSIGNED: (1) The self-control ability (109.30, 123.59) and empathy ability (63.86, 72.45) of juvenile offenders were significantly different from those of ordinary minors, but the difference of dialectical thinking ability was not statistically significant; (2) Except for the influence of mother\'s education level and family income on dialectical thinking ability, the other variables had no statistical significance on the three kinds of ability. Therefore, it was suggested that the correction plan and means for juvenile offenders should focus on the improvement of self-control ability and empathy ability.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    目的:本研究旨在比较罪犯,社会人口统计学和临床特征,亲热行为,性态度,性别观念,以及被评估犯有强奸成人和儿童刑事责任的人的与强奸有关的信念。
    方法:该研究比较了40名成年人因强奸罪(RAA)被调查的刑事责任和40名儿童强奸罪(RAC)被调查的刑事责任,43岁,使用DSM-5障碍的结构化临床访谈表格,性别和教育匹配没有任何性犯罪史的个体,亨德里克简短性态度量表,性别感知量表,伊利诺伊州强奸神话接受量表,和Barratt冲动性量表-11。
    结果:所有参与者均为男性。在终生或现有的精神疾病方面,两组之间没有差异。所有参与者在犯罪期间都负有全部刑事责任。任何一组的参与者都没有被诊断出患有亲合性障碍。确定RAC和RAA组的人都倾向于使用性行为作为工具,对节育方法的关注较少,对性别的平等主义认识要少得多,与对照组相比,他们对强奸的误解明显更高。对照组比性犯罪者更冲动。
    结论:我们的研究结果表明,性侵犯的行为不应仅由冲动性或精神疾病来解释,性别观念和性神话也可能有影响力。所有个人都负有全部刑事责任这一事实强调,需要对性暴力的社会和文化根源进行更多研究。
    OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to compare the criminal, sociodemographic and clinical characteristics, paraphilic behaviors, sexual attitudes, gender perceptions, and rape-related beliefs of people assessed for criminal liability for rape against adults and children.
    METHODS: The study compared 40 people investigated for criminal liability for rape against an adult (RAA) with 40 individuals investigated for criminal liability for crime of rape against a child (RAC), and 43 age, sex and education matched individuals without any sexual crime history using the Structured Clinical Interview form for DSM-5 disorders, Hendrick Brief Sexual Attitude Scale, Gender Perception Scale, Illinois Rape Myth Acceptance Scale, and Barratt Impulsiveness Scale-11.
    RESULTS: All participants were male. There was no difference between the groups in terms of lifelong or existing psychiatric diseases. All participants had full criminal responsibility during the crime. No participant in any group was diagnosed with a paraphilic disorder. It was determined that people in both RAC and RAA groups tended to use sexuality as a tool, paid less attention to birth control methods, had a far less egalitarian perception of gender, and their myths about rape were significantly higher compared to the control group. The control group was much more impulsive than the sex offenders.
    CONCLUSIONS: Our results show that the act of sexual assault should not be explained only by impulsivity or psychiatric disorders, and that gender perception and sexual myths may also be influential. The fact that all individuals had full criminal responsibility emphasizes the need for more research on the social and cultural origins of sexual violence.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    关于自闭症谱系障碍(ASD)的个体是否或多或少地犯罪,存在矛盾的研究结果。本研究的目的是:(1)描述一大群接受法医精神病学调查(FPI)的ASD罪犯的精神病学和犯罪相关特征。(2)确定这组罪犯中的临床亚组。(3)调查已确定的临床亚组与(a)精神病合并症(b)犯罪类型和(c)刑事责任之间的关联。
    该研究队列由2002年至2018年在瑞典的FPI中接受ASD诊断的所有受试者(n=831)组成。描述性和临床,以及与犯罪相关的变量都是从FPI获得的。非参数(Pearsonχ2,Fisher精确和Mann-WhitneyU检验)推断统计学用于分析组间差异,并报告效应大小。潜在类别分析用于从分类特征中识别同质子组(或类)。
    该队列由708名男性和123名女性组成,18至74岁。该队列中有三分之二(66.7%)至少有一个其他精神病诊断,最普遍的是物质使用障碍(SUD).严重的精神障碍,相当于缺乏刑事责任,在患有精神分裂症谱系障碍的共病诊断的罪犯中最常见。最常见的犯罪类型是暴力犯罪。确定了三个以人为导向的临床亚组;(1)ASD,其他诊断很少;(2)ASD和极高水平的SUD,加上中等水平的其他外化障碍和精神病性精神病理学和(3)ASD和中度至高度的人格障碍(ASPD除外)和SUD。
    我们的结果强调了CJS所有部分准备处理ASD罪犯的重要性,经常有高水平的额外精神病。ASD的传统治疗方法或其他心理社会干预措施可能需要适应至少三种一般临床分析-一种主要是神经发育问题。一个有一系列外部化问题,一个有复杂的人格相关困难。
    UNASSIGNED: There are contradictory research findings regarding whether individuals with Autism Spectrum Disorders (ASDs) are more or less likely to commit crimes. The aims of the current study were to: (1) Describe psychiatric and crime-related characteristics of a large group of offenders with ASD who had undergone a Forensic Psychiatric Investigation (FPI). (2) Identify clinical subgroups among this group of offenders. (3) Investigate associations between the identified clinical subgroups and (a) psychiatric comorbidity (b) types of crimes and (c) criminal responsibility.
    UNASSIGNED: The study cohort consists of all subjects (n = 831) who received an ASD-diagnosis at an FPI between 2002 and 2018 in Sweden. Descriptive and clinical, as well as crime related variables were obtained from the FPIs. Non-parametric (Pearson χ2, Fisher\'s exact and Mann-Whitney U-test) inferential statistics were used for analyses of between-group differences and effect sizes were reported. A Latent Class Analysis was used to identify homogeneous subgroups (or classes) from categorical characteristics.
    UNASSIGNED: The cohort consisted of 708 men and 123 women, aged 18 to 74 yrs. Two-thirds (66.7%) of the cohort had at least one other psychiatric diagnosis, the most prevalent was substance use disorder (SUD). A severe mental disorder, equivalent to lack of criminal responsibility, was most often reported among offenders with a comorbid diagnosis of schizophrenia spectrum disorder. The most common type of crime was violent crime. Three person-oriented clinical subgroups were identified; (1) ASD with few other diagnoses; (2) ASD and very high levels of SUDs, plus moderate levels of other externalizing disorders and psychotic psychopathology and (3) ASD and moderate to high levels of personality disorders (other than ASPD) and SUDs.
    UNASSIGNED: Our results highlight the importance of all parts of the CJS to be prepared to handle offenders with ASD, often with high levels of additional psychiatric problems. Traditional approaches in treatment or other psychosocial interventions for ASD may need to be adapted to at least three general clinical profiles- one with mainly neurodevelopmental problems, one with a spectrum of externalizing problems and one with complex personality related difficulties.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    为了避免公共卫生风险,所有政府确保监测和治疗精神病患者,如果他们冒犯并评估他们的刑事责任水平。《中华人民共和国刑事诉讼法》(2013)规定了特别程序。然而,很少有英文文章解释强制性处理程序在中国的实施。
    从2013年到2021年,我们从中国在线判决文件中收集了5262份合格文件。我们分析了社会人口特征,试验相关信息以及强制性治疗相关内容,对我国无刑事责任的精神病患者进行强制治疗,从2013年到2021年。使用简单的描述性统计和卡方检验来比较几种类型文档之间的差异。
    文件数量出现了总体变化趋势:新法实施后,从2013年到2019年逐年增加,但在2020年和2021年新冠肺炎大流行期间大幅下降。从2013年到2021年,共有3,854人申请强制治疗,其中3747人(97.2%)接受强制治疗,107(2.8%)的申请被拒绝。“精神分裂症和其他精神障碍”是两组中最常见的诊断,所有接受强制治疗的罪犯(3,747,100.0%)被认为没有刑事责任。共有1,294名病人申请解除强制治疗,其中827人(63.9%)其后获批准纾困,467(36.1%)被拒绝。共有118名病人申请救济两次或两次以上,56人(47.5%)最终松了一口气。
    我们的研究向国际社会介绍了自新法实施以来一直在运作的刑事强制处理制度的中国模式。立法变化和covid-19大流行可能会影响强制治疗病例的数量。患者,其近亲属和强制治疗机构有权申请强制治疗救济,但中国的最终裁决是由法院做出的。
    UNASSIGNED: To avoid public health risks, all governments ensure monitoring and treatment of mentally ill persons if they offend and assess their level of criminal responsibility. The Criminal Procedure Law of the People\'s Republic of China (2013) instituted special procedures. However, there are few articles in English which explain the implementation of mandatory treatment procedures in China.
    UNASSIGNED: We collected 5,262 qualified documents from 2013 to 2021 from the China Judgments Documents Online. We analyzed social demographic characteristics, trial-related information as well as the mandatory treatment-related content, to investigate the mandatory treatment of China\'s mentally ill offenders without criminal responsibility, from 2013 to 2021. Simple descriptive statistics and chi-square tests were used to compare differences among several types of documents.
    UNASSIGNED: There was an overall change trend of the number of documents: increasing year by year from 2013 to 2019 after the implementation of the new law, but with sharp decrease in 2020 and 2021 during covid-19 pandemic. From 2013 to 2021, a total of 3,854 people had applications made for mandatory treatment, of whom 3,747 (97.2%) were given mandatory treatment, 107 (2.8%) had applications rejected. \"Schizophrenia and other psychotic disorders\" was the most common diagnosis in both groups and all offenders receiving mandatory treatment (3,747, 100.0%) were considered to have no criminal responsibility. A total of 1,294 patients had applications made for relief of mandatory treatment, of whom 827 (63.9%) were subsequently approved for relief, 467 (36.1%) were rejected. A total of 118 patients had applications for relief two or more times, and 56 (47.5%) were finally relieved.
    UNASSIGNED: Our study presents the Chinese model of a criminal mandatory treatment system to the international community which has been in operation since the implementation of the new law. Legislatory changes and covid-19 pandemic can have effect on the number of mandatory treatment cases. Patients, their close relatives and mandatory treatment institutions have the right to apply for relief from mandatory treatment, but the final decision in China is taken by the court.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Case Reports
    Doppelgänger现象是指与自我直接相遇的经验,特征是:(i)对具有自己相同身体特征的人物的感知;或(ii)对感知到的人物具有相同的个性和身份的理解。Doppelgänger不仅看起来像同一个人,这是他/她的两倍。感知元素通常是幻觉,尽管有时可能涉及对实际数字的错误感知。这种现象已经在遭受压倒性恐惧的个体中描述过,严重的焦虑或中毒,癫痫,以及在睡眠-觉醒的过渡中。在主要精神病中也有报道。对即将死亡的恐惧通常先于Doppelgänger的经历。这份报告介绍了一名30岁男子的案例,Y先生,被X先生刺死,他的“双”。侵略者和他的受害者,虽然不相关,是真正的两倍;值得注意的是,他们有相同的名字和姓氏,年龄,专业活动和工作地点。此外,他们参加了同一个体育中心,但彼此几乎不认识。X先生的法医精神病学评估,在犯罪之后,都暗示了精神病.这种情况在科学文献中是独一无二的。在最严重的精神病形式中,“双重”的问题不仅质疑该疾病的病因中涉及的分离过程,还有生物心理社会因素,以及这种情况下的个人数据,这使得受害者和侵略者“完全相同”。在精神病理学功能的背景下,在谵妄发展之前的妄想情绪(Wahnstimung)是一种即将到来的精神病的门户,涉及妄想意识或情绪(气氛)。在精神病中,分裂是主要问题,这种影响被视为邪恶,外国,即使在物理意义上,世界末日和未知的一面也不再被认为属于自我。在这种情况下,人们认为,生存的唯一途径是压制自己的双重防御,以防止自我的混乱。
    The Doppelgänger phenomenon refers to the experience of a direct encounter with one\'s self, characteriswed by: (i) the perception of a figure with one\'s own identical physical features; or (ii) the apprehension that the perceived figure shares the same personality and identity. The Doppelgänger does not only look like the same person, it is his/her double. The perceptual element is usually a hallucination, although occasionally a false perception of an actual figure may be involved. This phenomenon has been described in individuals suffering from overwhelming fear, severe anxiety or intoxication, epilepsy, as well as in the sleep-wakefulness transition. It has also been reported in major psychoses. The fear of imminent death often precedes the Doppelgänger experience. This report presents the case of a 30-year-old man, Mr. Y, who was stabbed to death by Mr. X, his \"double\". The aggressor and his victim, although not related, were truly doubles; remarkably, they shared the same name and surname, age, professional activity and place of work. Moreover, they attended the same sports center but barely knew each other. The forensic psychiatric evaluations in Mr. X, subsequent to the crime committed, were suggestive of a psychotic condition. This case is unique in the scientific literature. In the most serious psychotic forms, the issue of the \"double\" calls into question not only the dissociative processes involved in the etiopathogenesis of the disorder, but also bio-psycho-social elements, as well as personal data in this case, which made the victim and the aggressor \"identical\". In the context of psychopathological functioning, the delusional mood (Wahnstimmung) that precedes the development of delirium is a sort of gateway to an impending psychotic illness, involving delusional awareness or mood (atmosphere). In psychosis, splitting is the main issue and this influence is seen as an evil, foreign, apocalyptic and unknown side no longer recognised as belonging to the self even in a physical sense. In such a situation, it is felt that the only way to survive is by suppressing one\'s double as a defense against disorganisation of the self.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    澳大利亚的最低刑事责任年龄为10岁。提高刑事责任年龄的话题仍然是一个充满挑战的研究和思想领域。尽管有大量证据支持提高最低刑事责任年龄,澳大利亚大多数州仍然坚决反对提高这个年龄。然而,重新考虑当前立场的理由确实令人信服。本文通过对当前科学证据和观点的考察,阐述了提高最低刑事责任年龄的说服力论点。考虑探讨和相关文献检查使用作者的框架,决策应该是公正的,科学,不是种族主义者,人道的,成本效益高,通常不可笑。然后提出了刑事定罪的替代方法和管理儿童有害行为的原则。
    The minimum age of criminal responsibility in Australia is 10 years. The topic of raising the age of criminal responsibility remains a fraught and challenging field of both study and thought. Despite overwhelming evidence to support an increase in the minimum age of criminal responsibility, there remains a resolute opposition in the majority of States in Australia that this age should be raised. However, the grounds for reconsidering the current position are indeed compelling. This paper expounds the persuasive arguments for raising the minimum age of criminal responsibility by examining the current scientific evidence and opinion. Considerations are explored and the relevant literature examined using the author\'s framework that decisions should be just, scientific, not racist, humane, cost-effective and generally not ludicrous. Principles for an alternative approach to criminalisation and for managing the harmful behaviour of children are then offered.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    本文总结了废除精神损害防御的论点,以维多利亚的辩护为例,采取历史和比较的方法。它认为在实践中的辩护,它的起源和停滞在中世纪和维多利亚时代的英格兰,基于英国和欧洲现代发展的更好方法,它抵制有意义的改革,以及它未能实现值得称赞的目标,人道和有原则的目标是让有严重心理健康问题的弱势群体免受惩罚。我们得出的结论是,真正实现这一目标的唯一方法是废除精神损害防御,取而代之的是一种方法,该方法允许根据临床需要对精神错乱的罪犯进行灵活的精神健康处置,如有必要,需要遏制,纳入并符合精神卫生立法,不管罪责,以及现代系统和服务使维多利亚脱离了19世纪。
    This article summarises arguments for abolishing the mental impairment defence, using the example of the defence in Victoria, taking a historical and comparative approach. It considers the defence in practice, its origins and stagnation in medieval and Victorian England, a better approach based on modern developments in the UK and Europe, its resistance to meaningful reform, and its failure to achieve its laudable, humane and principled aim of sparing vulnerable people with severe mental health problems from punishment. We conclude that the only way to actually achieve this aim is to abolish the mental impairment defence and replace it with an approach that allows for flexible mental health disposals for mentally disordered offenders based on clinical needs and, where necessary, the need for containment, incorporated in and aligned with mental health legislation, regardless of culpability, and with modern systems and services that bring Victoria out of the nineteenth century.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    本文总结了2021年8月举行的在线辩论中提出的保留精神障碍防御的主要论点。它为辩护辩护辩护,驳斥了废除人权的论点,并概述了为什么缺乏可行的替代办法。它的结论是,知识的进步应该导致国防的改革,而不是废除国防。
    This article summarises the main arguments for the retention of the defence of mental impairment presented in an online debate that took place in August 2021. It canvases the justifications for the defence, rebuts human rights arguments for its abolition and outlines why there is a lack of viable alternatives. It concludes that advances in knowledge should lead to the reform of the defence rather than its abolition.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    近年来,很明显,专家意见可能有偏见。有人认为,法医心理学家也可能容易受到偏见的影响。在本研究中,对犯罪嫌疑人心理健康的法医心理评估对语境效应(即无关信息对专家意见的影响)的脆弱性进行了测试。法医心理学硕士学生被要求解释一个虚构的双重谋杀案中嫌疑人的考试成绩。一些参与者收到了案件的一个版本,其中对谋杀案的描述是中立的。其他人收到了更明确的版本。而显性不应影响法医心理评估,研究发现,后一种情况的参与者似乎比前者更关心嫌疑人的心理健康。结论是,法医心理评估培训计划应注意偏见。
    In recent years, it has become clear that expert opinion can be biased. It has been argued that forensic psychologists may also be susceptible to bias. In the present study, the vulnerability of forensic psychological evaluation of the suspect\'s mental health to the context effect (i.e. the influencing of the expert opinion by irrelevant information) was tested. Master students in forensic psychology were asked to interpret test scores of a suspect in a fictitious double murder case. Some participants received a version of the case in which the description of the murders was neutral. Others received a more explicit version. Whereas the explicitness should not affect the forensic psychological evaluation, it was found that participants in the latter condition seemed more concerned about the suspect\'s mental health than those in the former. It is concluded that training programmes in forensic psychological assessment should devote attention to bias.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Sci-hub)

       PDF(Pubmed)

公众号