背景:弥漫性腱膜巨细胞瘤(D-TGCT),以前被称为色素沉着绒毛结节性滑膜炎,是一种罕见的,当地的侵略性,主要发生在膝关节的侵袭性软组织肿瘤。手术切除是主要的治疗选择,但是复发率很高。强调关节镜手术技术,因为它们创伤较小,术后恢复更快,但仍缺乏关于大型队列中D-TGCT的关节镜技术和结局的详细报告.
目的:(1)膝关节D-TGCT在多门关节镜滑膜切除术后的复发率是多少?(2)有哪些并发症,膝盖ROM,疼痛评分,以及患者报告的结果,有复发和无复发的患者之间存在差异吗?(3)什么因素与D-TGCT患者关节镜治疗后复发相关?
方法:在这个单中心,2010年1月至2021年4月进行了回顾性研究,我们对295例膝关节D-TGCT患者进行了治疗.我们认为接受多门关节镜滑膜切除术的初始手术治疗的患者可能符合条件。基于此,27%(295例中的81例)的患者由于在另一机构进行滑膜切除术后复发而被排除。在符合纳入标准的214名患者中,17%(214人中的36人)失去随访,在分析中留下83%(214个中的178个)的患者。28%(178人中有50人)的患者是男性,72%(178人中有128人)是女性,中位(范围)年龄为36岁(7至69岁)。中位随访时间为80个月(26~149)。所有患者均接受多门(前后入路)关节镜滑膜切除术,所有手术方案均由4名外科医生在术前MRI后讨论确定.对于侵犯或包围血管和神经或侵犯关节外肌肉间隙的患者,使用组合式开放后切口。所有D-TGCT患者均有关节外及后室侵犯,推荐标准术后辅助放疗;对于仅有前室侵犯的患者,根据外科医师和放射科医师根据术前MRI和术中描述评估,对于重症病例,建议进行放疗.使用Kaplan-Meier生存率估算器计算术后5年复发。WOMAC评分(0至96,较高的评分代表较差的结果;最小临床重要差异[MCID]8.5),Lysholm膝关节评分(0至100,评分越高,膝关节功能越好;MCID25.4),疼痛的VAS(0到10,分数越高表示疼痛越多;MCID2.46),和膝关节ROM用于评估功能结局。因为我们没有术前患者报告的结果评分,我们提供了每个结果指标达到患者可接受症状状态(PASS)的患者比例的数据,在WOMAC的96分中有14.6分,Lysholm上100分中的52.5分,和VAS上10个点中的2.32个。
结果:使用Kaplan-Meier估计,5年有症状或影像学记录的复发率为12%(95%置信区间[CI]7%至17%),平均复发时间33±19个月。其中,三例是在常规MRI检查中发现的无症状复发,其余19例接受了重复手术。术中并发症(血管损伤)1例,对术后肢体功能无影响,术后关节僵硬8例,其中7人因长期康复而有所改善,1人在麻醉下进行了操作。未发现放疗后并发症。对于VAS疼痛评分,达到预先建立的PASS的患者比例为99%(178个中的176个),WOMAC评分为97%(178个中的173个),和100%(178个中的178个)的Lysholm得分。与未复发的患者相比,复发的患者达到WOMAC的PASS评分的百分比较低(86%[19]对99%[154],OR0.08[95%CI0.01至0.52];p=0.01),而VAS评分的百分比没有差异(95%[21]对99%[155],或0.14[95%CI0.01至2.25];p=0.23)或Lysholm评分(100%[22]对100%[156],OR1[95%CI1至1];p=0.99)。此外,复发组患者的膝关节屈曲较差(中位数135°[100°至135°]与中位数135°[80°至135°];中位数差异为0°;p=0.03),WOMAC评分较差(中位数3.5[0至19]与中位数1[0至29];中位数差异2.5;p=0.01),与未复发组相比,VAS疼痛评分更高(中位数1[0至4]与中位数0[0至4];中位数差异1;p<0.01),虽然没有差异达到MCID。没有因素与D-TGCT复发相关,包括术后放疗,外科技术,和入侵程度。
结论:这种单中心,大型队列回顾性研究证实,多门关节镜手术可用于治疗低复发率的膝关节D-TGCT,并发症少,和令人满意的术后结果。外科医生应该进行彻底的术前评估,细致的关节镜滑膜切除术,术后定期随访,减少D-TGCT术后复发。因为现有的证据似乎并不完全支持在所有D-TGCT患者中使用术后辅助放疗,而且我们的研究设计不足以解决这个有争议的问题,未来的研究应该寻找更合适的放疗适应症,例如基于更精确的病变侵袭分类的计划。
方法:三级,治疗性研究。
BACKGROUND: Diffuse-type tenosynovial giant-cell tumor (D-TGCT), formerly known as pigmented villonodular synovitis, is a rare, locally aggressive, invasive soft tissue tumor that primarily occurs in the knee. Surgical excision is the main treatment option, but there is a high recurrence rate. Arthroscopic surgical techniques are emphasized because they are less traumatic and offer faster postoperative recovery, but detailed reports on arthroscopic techniques and outcomes of D-TGCT in large cohorts are still lacking.
OBJECTIVE: (1) What is the recurrence rate of knee D-TGCT after multiportal arthroscopic synovectomy? (2) What are the complications, knee ROM, pain score, and patient-reported outcomes for patients, and do they differ between patients with and without recurrence? (3) What factors are associated with recurrence after arthroscopic treatment in patients with D-TGCT?
METHODS: In this single-center, retrospective study conducted between January 2010 and April 2021, we treated 295 patients with knee D-TGCTs. We considered patients undergoing initial surgical treatment with multiportal arthroscopic synovectomy as potentially eligible. Based on that, 27% (81 of 295) of patients were excluded because of recurrence after synovectomy performed at another institution. Of the 214 patients who met the inclusion criteria, 17% (36 of 214) were lost to follow-up, leaving 83% (178 of 214) of patients in the analysis. Twenty-eight percent (50 of 178) of patients were men and 72% (128 of 178) were women, with a median (range) age of 36 years (7 to 69). The median follow-up duration was 80 months (26 to 149). All patients underwent multiportal (anterior and posterior approaches) arthroscopic synovectomy, and all surgical protocols were determined by discussion among four surgeons after preoperative MRI. A combined open posterior incision was used for patients with lesions that invaded or surrounded the blood vessels and nerves or invaded the muscle space extraarticularly. Standard postoperative adjuvant radiotherapy was recommended for all patients with D-TGCT who had extraarticular and posterior compartment invasion; for patients with only anterior compartment invasion, radiotherapy was recommended for severe cases as assessed by the surgeons and radiologists based on preoperative MRI and intraoperative descriptions. Postoperative recurrence at 5 years was calculated using a Kaplan-Meier survivorship estimator. The WOMAC score (0 to 96, with higher scores representing a worse outcome; minimum clinically important difference [MCID] 8.5), the Lysholm knee score (0 to 100, with higher scores being better knee function; MCID 25.4), the VAS for pain (0 to 10, with higher scores representing more pain; MCID 2.46), and knee ROM were used to evaluate functional outcomes. Because we did not have preoperative patient-reported outcomes scores, we present data on the proportion of patients who achieved the patient-acceptable symptom state (PASS) for each of those outcome metrics, which were 14.6 of 96 points on the WOMAC, 52.5 of 100 points on the Lysholm, and 2.32 of 10 points on the VAS.
RESULTS: The symptomatic or radiographically documented recurrence at 5 years was 12% (95% confidence interval [CI] 7% to 17%) using the Kaplan-Meier estimator, with a mean recurrence time of 33 ± 19 months. Of these, three were asymptomatic recurrences found during regular MRI reviews, and the remaining 19 underwent repeat surgery. There was one intraoperative complication (vascular injury) with no effect on postoperative limb function and eight patients with postoperative joint stiffness, seven of whom improved with prolonged rehabilitation and one with manipulation under anesthesia. No postradiotherapy complications were found. The proportion of patients who achieved the preestablished PASS was 99% (176 of 178) for the VAS pain score, 97% (173 of 178) for the WOMAC score, and 100% (178 of 178) for the Lysholm score. A lower percentage of patients with recurrence achieved the PASS for WOMAC score than patients without recurrence (86% [19] versus 99% [154], OR 0.08 [95% CI 0.01 to 0.52]; p = 0.01), whereas no difference was found in the percentage of VAS score (95% [21] versus 99% [155], OR 0.14 [95% CI 0.01 to 2.25]; p = 0.23) or Lysholm score (100% [22] versus 100% [156], OR 1 [95% CI 1 to 1]; p = 0.99). Moreover, patients in the recurrence group showed worse knee flexion (median 135° [100° to 135°] versus median 135° [80° to 135°]; difference of medians 0°; p = 0.03), worse WOMAC score (median 3.5 [0 to 19] versus median 1 [0 to 29]; difference of medians 2.5; p = 0.01), and higher VAS pain score (median 1 [0 to 4] versus median 0 [0 to 4]; difference of medians 1; p < 0.01) than those in the nonrecurrence group, although no differences reached the MCID. No factors were associated with D-TGCT recurrence, including the use of postoperative radiotherapy, surgical technique, and invasion extent.
CONCLUSIONS: This single-center, large-cohort retrospective study confirmed that multiportal arthroscopic surgery can be used to treat knee D-TGCTs with a low recurrence rate, few complications, and satisfactory postoperative outcomes. Surgeons should conduct a thorough preoperative evaluation, meticulous arthroscopic synovectomy, and regular postoperative follow-up when treating patients with D-TGCT to reduce postoperative recurrence. Because the available evidence does not appear to fully support the use of postoperative adjuvant radiotherapy in all patients with D-TGCTs and our study design is inadequate to resolve this controversial issue, future studies should look for more appropriate indications for radiotherapy, such as planning based on a more precise classification of lesion invasion.
METHODS: Level III, therapeutic study.