medical training

医学培训
  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    在过去的几十年中,机器人系统在手术领域的使用已成为患者和外科医生的开创性。虽然每年机器人外科手术的数量继续快速增长,为外科医生提供创新的培训课程以及标准的专业化路径至关重要。为此,模拟器起着基础性的作用。目前,领先的VR模拟器的高成本限制了它们对教育机构的可及性。挑战在于平衡高保真仿真与成本效益;然而,很少有成本效益的选择存在机器人手术训练。
    本文提出了设计,开发和以用户为中心的可用性研究一个负担得起的用户界面来控制一个手术机器人模拟器。它由配备有两个触觉接口的推车组成,一个VR遮阳板和两个踏板。模拟是使用Unity创建的,它提供了将模拟器扩展到更复杂场景的多功能性。通过高级控制策略实现了对模拟机器人仪器的直观远程操作控制。
    它的可负担性和与真正的外科医生控制台的相似性使其成为在医学院实施机器人手术培训计划的理想选择,增强更广泛受众的可访问性。一项可用性研究的结果证明了这一点,该研究涉及定期使用手术机器人的专家外科医生,没有机器人手术经验的专家外科医生,和一个对照组。研究结果,这是基于传统的钉板练习和相机控制任务,演示模拟器的高可用性和跨不同用户组的直观控制,包括那些经验有限的人。这提供了证据,证明这种负担得起的系统是扩展机器人手术培训的有前途的解决方案。
    UNASSIGNED: The use of robotic systems in the surgical domain has become groundbreaking for patients and surgeons in the last decades. While the annual number of robotic surgical procedures continues to increase rapidly, it is essential to provide the surgeon with innovative training courses along with the standard specialization path. To this end, simulators play a fundamental role. Currently, the high cost of the leading VR simulators limits their accessibility to educational institutions. The challenge lies in balancing high-fidelity simulation with cost-effectiveness; however, few cost-effective options exist for robotic surgery training.
    UNASSIGNED: This paper proposes the design, development and user-centered usability study of an affordable user interface to control a surgical robot simulator. It consists of a cart equipped with two haptic interfaces, a VR visor and two pedals. The simulations were created using Unity, which offers versatility for expanding the simulator to more complex scenes. An intuitive teleoperation control of the simulated robotic instruments is achieved through a high-level control strategy.
    UNASSIGNED: Its affordability and resemblance to real surgeon consoles make it ideal for implementing robotic surgery training programs in medical schools, enhancing accessibility to a broader audience. This is demonstrated by the results of an usability study involving expert surgeons who use surgical robots regularly, expert surgeons without robotic surgery experience, and a control group. The results of the study, which was based on a traditional Peg-board exercise and Camera Control task, demonstrate the simulator\'s high usability and intuitive control across diverse user groups, including those with limited experience. This offers evidence that this affordable system is a promising solution for expanding robotic surgery training.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    背景:与普通人群和其他学生群体相比,医学基础年(FY)医生表现出更大的心理困扰。这项可行性研究调查了FY医生对正念的看法以及正念韧性和有效性训练(MRET)计划对压力的影响,幸福,和性能。
    方法:混合方法研究使用问卷调查(研究1,N=144)和MRET计划的pre-post分析设计(研究2,N=13),以及焦点小组(N=7)。
    结果:在研究1中,有28.5%的FY报告使用正念。所有五个正念方面都很重要,积极的,与心理健康相关(p<0.05)。意识(AA)和非反应性(NR)显著,与对压力的挑战反应呈正相关(p<0.05)。威胁和损失评估与AA呈负相关,NR,和非判断性(p<0.01)。感知生产力与正念方面呈正相关:描述,AA,和NR(p<0.001)。在研究2中,健康和正念方面的观察显着增加,描述,AA,NR,威胁评估下降(p<0.05)。焦点小组确定的主要主题包括重塑心态,基于价值观的行动,体现领导力和教育学。
    结论:正念之间存在关系,心理健康,和在财政年度的表现。MRETprorgamme改善了心理健康并减少了威胁评估。未来的工作可以集中资源来提高AA和NR的技能,因为这可能足以带来有意义的福祉改善,压力生活事件的生产力和认知重估。
    BACKGROUND: Medical Foundation Year (FY) doctors demonstrate greater psychological distress compared with the general population and other student groups. This feasibility study investigated FY doctors\' perceptions of mindfulness and the impact of a mindful resilience and effectiveness training (MRET) programme on stress, wellbeing, and performance.
    METHODS: Mixed-methods study utilising a questionnaire (study 1, N = 144) and a pre-post analysis design of MRET programme (study 2, N = 13), along with focus groups (N = 7).
    RESULTS: In study 1 28.5% of FY\'s reported using mindfulness. All five mindfulness facets were significantly, and positively, associated with mental wellbeing (p < 0.05). Acting with awareness (AA) and non-reactivity (NR) were significantly, positively associated with a challenge responses to stress (p < 0.05). Threat and loss appraisals were negatively associated with AA, NR, and non-judging (p < 0.01). Perceived productivity was positively associated with mindfulness facets: describing, AA, and NR (p < 0.001). In study 2, there were significant increases in wellbeing and mindfulness facets observing, describing, AA, and NR, and threat appraisals decreased (p < 0.05). The main themes identified across the focus group included Reframed Mindset, Values-Based Action, Embodied Leadership and Pedagogy.
    CONCLUSIONS: There exists a relationship between mindfulness, psychological wellbeing, and performance in FYs. The MRET prorgamme improved psychological wellbeing and reduced threat appraisals. Future work could focus resources on enhancing the skills of AA and NR, as this may be sufficient to bring about meaningful improvements in wellbeing, percieved productivity and cognitive reappraisal of stressful life events.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    背景技术在当代医疗保健中使用远程医疗已经变得至关重要。提供一种提供护理的新方法,特别是在农村和欠发达地区。这项研究评估了远程医疗意识,知识,态度,技能,以及在三级保健医院工作的医生面临的挑战。方法在三级医疗机构对来自不同专业的100名医生进行了横断面研究。问卷评估了五个领域:远程医疗意识和知识,远程医疗的态度,远程医疗技术技能,远程医疗利用模式,感知的障碍和教育需求。结果研究表明,95%的参与者了解远程医疗。然而,知识差距仍然存在,特别是在法律和道德问题(50%)和国际规则(40%)。百分之八十的受访者对远程医疗有好感,85%的人认为这可能会改善农村地区的病人护理。远程医疗用户的熟练程度是可变的:其中60%有以前的经验,70%的人认为他们的熟练程度是中级或更高。根据使用模式,50%的远程医疗用户每周至少使用一次,主要用于远程监控(30%)和视频咨询(60%)。研究发现,90%的受访者对培训和教育机会有很高的需求。缺乏基础设施(65%)对数据安全的担忧(55%),患者可接受性(30%)是发现的主要障碍。它还强调了制定政策和跨学科合作的重要性。结论该研究确定了医生对远程医疗的良好态度以及对改进培训和基础设施的需求。为了成功地将远程医疗纳入医疗保健系统,必须解决这些要求和障碍。
    Background The use of telemedicine in contemporary healthcare has become essential, providing a novel method of delivering care, particularly in rural and underdeveloped areas. This study assesses the telemedicine awareness, knowledge, attitude, skills, and challenges among physicians working in tertiary care hospitals. Methods A cross-sectional study was carried out with 100 doctors from diverse specialties at a tertiary care institution. The questionnaire evaluated five domains: telemedicine awareness and knowledge, telemedicine attitude, telemedicine technology skills, telemedicine utilization patterns, and perceived barriers and educational needs. Results The study indicated that 95% of participants were aware of telemedicine. However, knowledge gaps remained, particularly in legal and ethical concerns (50%) and international rules (40%). Eighty percent of respondents had a favorable opinion of telemedicine, and 85% thought it might improve patient care in rural regions. The proficiency level of telemedicine users was variable: 60% of them had previous experience, and 70% of them rated their proficiency as intermediate or better. According to utilization patterns, 50% of telemedicine users used it at least once a week, primarily for remote monitoring (30%) and video consultations (60%). The study found that 90% of respondents had a high demand for training and educational opportunities. The absence of infrastructure (65%), worries about data security (55%), and patient acceptability (30%) were the main obstacles found. It also highlighted how important it is to have defined policies and collaborate across disciplines. Conclusion The study identifies a good attitude toward telemedicine among doctors as well as a need for improved training and infrastructure. It is essential to tackle these requirements and obstacles in order to successfully incorporate telemedicine into healthcare systems.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Letter
    暂无摘要。
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

    求助全文

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    在医院出院沟通不畅的背景下,本研究从医师的角度探讨出院访谈的目的及其面临的挑战。作为出院管理的一部分,在德国法律上要求出院面谈。在病房医生的带领下,出院访谈应总结住院时间的相关信息,药物,生活方式干预和后续治疗。
    2020年2月至4月在海德堡大学医院对n=12名医生进行了半结构化访谈。使用MAXQDA进行定性内容分析。
    医生报告获得信息,提供信息,并回答开放式问题作为出院面试的目的。进行出院面谈的挑战与寻找通用语言有关,与患者相关的挑战,病房日常生活的条件,缺乏训练。医生报告没有接受出院访谈的明确培训。虽然专业经验似乎减轻了培训的缺乏,一些医生表达了一种普遍的不安全感。
    医学院的出院面试缺乏准备,这使得医生将其理论知识转化为以患者为中心的出院沟通尤其具有挑战性。出院访谈的医学培训应在理想内容的理论投入方面进行扩展,其目的和潜力(例如,在减少再入院方面),以及实践练习。
    UNASSIGNED: Against the backdrop of poor discharge communication in hospitals, this study explores the purpose of discharge interviews from the physicians\' perspective and the challenges they are confronted with. Discharge interviews are legally required in Germany as part of the discharge management. Led by the ward physician, the discharge interview should summarize relevant information about the hospital stay, medication, lifestyle interventions and follow-up treatment.
    UNASSIGNED: Semi-structured interviews with n = 12 physicians were conducted at Heidelberg University Hospital between February and April 2020. Qualitative content analysis was carried out using MAXQDA.
    UNASSIGNED: Physicians reported gaining information, providing information, and answering open-ended questions as the purpose of the discharge interview. Challenges in conducting discharge interviews were related to finding a common language, patient-related challenges, conditions of everyday ward life, and lack of training. Physicians reported receiving no explicit training on discharge interviews. While professional experience seems to mitigate the lack of training, some physicians expressed a prevailing sense of insecurity.
    UNASSIGNED: The lack of preparation for discharge interviews in medical school makes it particularly challenging for physicians to translate their theoretical knowledge into patient-centered discharge communication. Medical training on discharge interviews should be expanded in terms of theoretical input on the ideal content, its purpose and potential (e.g. in reducing readmissions), as well as practical exercises.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

    求助全文

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    背景:患有罕见和复杂疾病的患者通常会出现诊断延迟和误诊,因为有关这些疾病的全面知识仅限于少数医学专家。在这种情况下,大型语言模型(LLM)已成为强大的知识聚合工具,在临床决策支持和教育领域具有应用。
    目的:本研究旨在探索3种流行的LLM的潜力,即巴德(谷歌有限责任公司),ChatGPT-3.5(OpenAI),和GPT-4(OpenAI),在医学教育中加强对罕见和复杂疾病的诊断,同时研究及时工程对其性能的影响。
    方法:我们对公开的复杂和罕见病例进行了实验,以实现这些目标。我们实施了各种提示策略,以使用开放式和多项选择提示来评估这些模型的性能。此外,我们使用了多数投票策略来利用语言模型中不同的推理路径,旨在提高其可靠性。此外,我们将他们的表现与人类受访者和MedAlpaca的表现进行了比较,专门为医疗任务设计的生成LLM。
    结果:值得注意的是,所有LLM的表现都优于平均人类共识和MedAlpaca,最低利润率为5%和13%,分别,在诊断病例挑战收集的所有30例病例中。在经常误诊的病例类别上,吟游诗人与MedAlpaca并列,但超过人类平均共识14%,而GPT-4和ChatGPT-3.5在中度误诊病例类别中的表现优于MedAlpaca和人类受访者,其最低准确度得分分别为28%和11%,分别。多数投票策略,特别是GPT-4,在诊断复杂病例收集的所有病例中,总体得分最高,超越其他LLM。在重症监护III数据集的医疗信息集市上,Bard和GPT-4获得了最高的诊断准确性评分,多项选择提示得分93%,而ChatGPT-3.5和MedAlpaca得分分别为73%和47%,分别。此外,我们的研究结果表明,对于提高LLM的性能,并不存在一刀切的提示方法,而且单一的策略并不普遍适用于所有LLM。
    结论:我们的研究结果揭示了LLM的诊断能力,以及与确定符合每种语言模型特征和特定任务要求的最佳提示策略相关的挑战。强调了提示工程的意义,为使用这些语言模型进行医学培训的研究人员和从业人员提供有价值的见解。此外,这项研究代表了了解LLM如何在罕见和复杂的医学病例中增强诊断推理的关键一步,为开发有效的教育工具和准确的诊断工具铺平道路,以改善患者护理和结果。
    BACKGROUND: Patients with rare and complex diseases often experience delayed diagnoses and misdiagnoses because comprehensive knowledge about these diseases is limited to only a few medical experts. In this context, large language models (LLMs) have emerged as powerful knowledge aggregation tools with applications in clinical decision support and education domains.
    OBJECTIVE: This study aims to explore the potential of 3 popular LLMs, namely Bard (Google LLC), ChatGPT-3.5 (OpenAI), and GPT-4 (OpenAI), in medical education to enhance the diagnosis of rare and complex diseases while investigating the impact of prompt engineering on their performance.
    METHODS: We conducted experiments on publicly available complex and rare cases to achieve these objectives. We implemented various prompt strategies to evaluate the performance of these models using both open-ended and multiple-choice prompts. In addition, we used a majority voting strategy to leverage diverse reasoning paths within language models, aiming to enhance their reliability. Furthermore, we compared their performance with the performance of human respondents and MedAlpaca, a generative LLM specifically designed for medical tasks.
    RESULTS: Notably, all LLMs outperformed the average human consensus and MedAlpaca, with a minimum margin of 5% and 13%, respectively, across all 30 cases from the diagnostic case challenge collection. On the frequently misdiagnosed cases category, Bard tied with MedAlpaca but surpassed the human average consensus by 14%, whereas GPT-4 and ChatGPT-3.5 outperformed MedAlpaca and the human respondents on the moderately often misdiagnosed cases category with minimum accuracy scores of 28% and 11%, respectively. The majority voting strategy, particularly with GPT-4, demonstrated the highest overall score across all cases from the diagnostic complex case collection, surpassing that of other LLMs. On the Medical Information Mart for Intensive Care-III data sets, Bard and GPT-4 achieved the highest diagnostic accuracy scores, with multiple-choice prompts scoring 93%, whereas ChatGPT-3.5 and MedAlpaca scored 73% and 47%, respectively. Furthermore, our results demonstrate that there is no one-size-fits-all prompting approach for improving the performance of LLMs and that a single strategy does not universally apply to all LLMs.
    CONCLUSIONS: Our findings shed light on the diagnostic capabilities of LLMs and the challenges associated with identifying an optimal prompting strategy that aligns with each language model\'s characteristics and specific task requirements. The significance of prompt engineering is highlighted, providing valuable insights for researchers and practitioners who use these language models for medical training. Furthermore, this study represents a crucial step toward understanding how LLMs can enhance diagnostic reasoning in rare and complex medical cases, paving the way for developing effective educational tools and accurate diagnostic aids to improve patient care and outcomes.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    背景:交互式期刊俱乐部旨在利用一种新的方法来评估研究,以最大程度地提高传统期刊俱乐部的收益。在这种新方法中,参与者积极参与关键数据评估的结构化过程,而不仅仅是被动的听众。在这个案例研究中,我们应用了互动式期刊俱乐部形式,并评估了其对内分泌学受训研究员的影响.方法:我们在四周的时间内进行了四次互动期刊俱乐部会议,通过虚拟平台每周一次。在所有会议期间,12名参与者都是相同的。在知情同意后记录每个疗程。在所有会议结束时,获得了反馈,列表和比较。结果:会话持续59到83分钟(平均,67.75分钟)。随着会议的进行,参与者变得更加活跃和自发。所有参与者发现格式更有趣和主动。这种方法允许更多的批判性思维和信息处理。显著的特征包括增强自尊和自信,其他参与者的额外学习,更好地保留信息,以及在未来实践中的应用。结论:传统方法从医学最新发展的被动介绍转变为互动讨论,同时保留了传统期刊俱乐部的精神和精髓。以及在临床培训和教育中探索新的和改进的方法。
    Background: The interactive journal club is designed to utilize a new approach in appraising research in order to maximize the benefits of the traditional journal club. In this new approach, the participants are actively involved in a structured process of critical data appraisal rather than just being passive listeners. In this case study, we applied the interactive journal club format and assessed its impact among our endocrinology fellows-in-training. Methods: We conducted four interactive journal club sessions within a four-week span, one per each week via a virtual platform. The 12 participants were the same throughout all sessions. Each session was recorded following informed consent. At the end of all sessions, feedback was obtained, tabulated and compared. Results: Sessions lasted from 59 to 83 minutes (mean, 67.75 minutes). Participants became more active and spontaneous as the sessions progressed. All participants found the format more fun and proactive. This approach allowed more critical thinking and processing of information. Salient features include increased self-esteem and confidence, additional learning from other participants, better retention of information, and utilization in future practice. Conclusions: Traditional approaches are transformed from passive presentations of recent developments in medicine into an interactive discussion while allowing the retention of the spirit and essence of a traditional journal club, as well as exploring new and improved approaches in clinical training and education.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    要获得与真实骨骼相似的触觉感觉的3D打印骨骼模型,这将有助于外科医生在实践的基础上学习和改进。
    来自计算机断层扫描,创建了3个人体股骨近端数字解剖模型,通过修改打印参数,皮质和小梁组织都被模拟,根据骨节段在不同的皮质-松质界面中组合。将获得的3个等效模型与商业Sawbone合成模型进行比较,并接受了由5名来自医院的TOC专家进行的一系列盲目手术实践试验,他们每个人都有不同程度的专业知识。基于Wilcoxon检验对收集的定性数据进行统计分析,斯皮尔曼相关矩阵,并进行有效性比系数。
    在尺寸研究中观察到的偏差小于0.2毫米,这证实了3DP-FFF技术在几何上重建具有高解剖精度的个性化生物模型的有效性。
    所获得的复制品产生了一种可靠的方法,专业人员可以改进计划手术,从而减少患者的时间和风险,以及医疗培训。
    UNASSIGNED: To obtain 3D printed bone models with a haptic sensation similar to that of the real bone, which will help the surgeon to learn and improve based on practice.
    UNASSIGNED: From computed tomography, 3 digital anatomical models of the human proximal femur were created and, by modifying the printing parameters, both cortical and trabecular tissues were simulated, which were combined in a different cortico-cancellous interface depending on the bone segment. The 3 equivalent models obtained were compared with a commercial Sawbone synthetic model and subjected to a series of blind surgical practice trials performed by 5 TOC specialists from a hospital, each of them with different degrees of expertise. A statistical analysis of the qualitative data collected based on the Wilcoxon test, the Spearman correlation matrix, and the Validity Ratio Coefficient was performed.
    UNASSIGNED: The deviations observed in the dimensional study are less than 0.2 millimeter, which confirms the validity of the 3DP-FFF technology to geometrically recreate personalized biomodels with high anatomical precision.
    UNASSIGNED: The reproductions obtained have given rise to a reliable method that professionals can refine to plan operations with the consequent reduction of time and risks for the patient, as well as for medical training.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

    求助全文

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    胃肠镜检查是一项复杂的实践技能,需要培训和经验,以确保程序的准确性和安全性。因此,需要适当的内窥镜培训,以提供高技能的内窥镜医师。本研究从内窥镜培训生的角度探讨了学习经验,并评估了印度尼西亚内窥镜培训的需求。当前培训模式的局限性和学员的建议有望成为印度尼西亚未来内窥镜培训模式的基础。
    共有132名来自印度尼西亚各个中心的内窥镜检查学员和内窥镜检查培训毕业生完成了有关其内窥镜检查培训经验的在线定性调查,他们对当前培训方法的满意度,实现能力的障碍,以及他们对未来培训的建议。使用内容分析对数据进行描述性和定性分析。
    我们发现受训者在培训监督方面的学习经验有所不同,反馈,和评估方法。最常见的内窥镜检查培训方法是观察和在监督下直接练习。模拟器的使用比例很低(25%)。在实现能力障碍方面发现最多的概念是“患者数量不足”。\"同时,在对未来培训方法的建议中,发现最多的概念是“增加案例和程序的多样性”。
    我们的研究结果表明,印度尼西亚的内窥镜检查训练方法仍然存在差异。因此,我们建议设计一个标准化的内窥镜培训计划,以确保内窥镜学员的能力,并更好地照顾内镜患者。模拟器可用于在患者或病例数量较少的情况下提高学员的能力。
    UNASSIGNED: Gastointestinal endoscopy is a complex practical skill, and training and experience are required to ensure the accuracy and safety of the procedures. Therefore, proper endoscopy training is needed to provide highly skilled endoscopists. This study explores the learning experience and assesses the need for endoscopy training in Indonesia from an endoscopy trainee\'s point of view. Limitations from the current training model and the trainees\' suggestions hopefully will become a foundation for the future endoscopy training model in Indonesia.
    UNASSIGNED: A total of 132 current endoscopy trainees and graduates of endoscopy training from various centers in Indonesia completed an online qualitative survey regarding their endoscopy training experience, their satisfaction with the current training method, barriers to achieving competency, and their suggestions for future training. Data were subjected to descriptive and qualitative analysis using content analysis.
    UNASSIGNED: We found variations in the trainee\'s learning experience regarding the training supervision, feedback, and assessment methods. The most common endoscopy training methods were observation and direct practice with supervision. There was only a low proportion of simulator use (25%). The most found concept in barriers to achieving competency was \"insufficient number of patients.\" Meanwhile, the most found concept in suggestions for future training methods was \"increasing the variety of cases and procedures.\"
    UNASSIGNED: Our findings suggest that there are still variations in endoscopy training methods in Indonesia. Therefore, we propose to design a standardized endoscopy training program to ensure the competence of endoscopy trainees and better care for endoscopic patients. Simulators might be used to increase the trainees\' competence in settings with low numbers of patients or cases.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    背景:人工智能(AI)是一个快速发展的领域,具有改变医疗保健和公共卫生各个方面的潜力,包括医学培训。在为五年级医学生开设的“卫生与公共卫生”课程期间,使用AI聊天机器人作为教育支持工具,进行了有关疫苗接种的实用培训课程。在接受疫苗接种的特定培训之前,对学生进行了基于网络的测试,该测试是从意大利国家医学住院医师测试中提取的。完成测试后,AI聊天机器人协助对每个问题进行了严格的更正。
    目的:这项研究的主要目的是确定AI聊天机器人是否可以被视为公共卫生培训的教育支持工具。次要目标是评估不同AI聊天机器人在意大利语复杂的多项选择医学问题上的表现。
    方法:从意大利国家医疗居住权测试中提取了由15个关于疫苗接种的多项选择题组成的测试,使用有针对性的关键词,并通过GoogleForms和不同的AI聊天机器人模型(BingChat,ChatGPT,Chatsonic,谷歌吟游诗人,和YouChat)。考试的纠正是在教室里进行的,专注于对聊天机器人提供的解释进行批判性评估。进行了Mann-WhitneyU测试,以比较医学生和AI聊天机器人的表现。在培训体验结束时匿名收集学生反馈。
    结果:总计,36名医学生和5个AI聊天机器人模型完成了测试。学生在15分中的平均得分为8.22(SD2.65),而AI聊天机器人的平均得分为12.22(SD2.77)。结果表明,两组之间的性能差异具有统计学意义(U=49.5,P<.001),具有较大的效应大小(r=0.69)。当按问题类型划分时(直接,基于场景的,和否定),在直接(P<.001)和基于情景(P<.001)的问题上观察到显著差异,但不是在否定的问题(P=.48)。学生报告对教育经历的满意度很高(7.9/10),表达强烈的重复体验的愿望(7.6/10)。
    结论:这项研究证明了AI聊天机器人在回答与疫苗接种相关的复杂医学问题和提供有价值的教育支持方面的有效性。在直接和基于情景的问题上,他们的表现大大超过了医学生。负责任和批判性地使用人工智能聊天机器人可以增强医学教育,使其成为融入教育系统的一个重要方面。
    BACKGROUND: Artificial intelligence (AI) is a rapidly developing field with the potential to transform various aspects of health care and public health, including medical training. During the \"Hygiene and Public Health\" course for fifth-year medical students, a practical training session was conducted on vaccination using AI chatbots as an educational supportive tool. Before receiving specific training on vaccination, the students were given a web-based test extracted from the Italian National Medical Residency Test. After completing the test, a critical correction of each question was performed assisted by AI chatbots.
    OBJECTIVE: The main aim of this study was to identify whether AI chatbots can be considered educational support tools for training in public health. The secondary objective was to assess the performance of different AI chatbots on complex multiple-choice medical questions in the Italian language.
    METHODS: A test composed of 15 multiple-choice questions on vaccination was extracted from the Italian National Medical Residency Test using targeted keywords and administered to medical students via Google Forms and to different AI chatbot models (Bing Chat, ChatGPT, Chatsonic, Google Bard, and YouChat). The correction of the test was conducted in the classroom, focusing on the critical evaluation of the explanations provided by the chatbot. A Mann-Whitney U test was conducted to compare the performances of medical students and AI chatbots. Student feedback was collected anonymously at the end of the training experience.
    RESULTS: In total, 36 medical students and 5 AI chatbot models completed the test. The students achieved an average score of 8.22 (SD 2.65) out of 15, while the AI chatbots scored an average of 12.22 (SD 2.77). The results indicated a statistically significant difference in performance between the 2 groups (U=49.5, P<.001), with a large effect size (r=0.69). When divided by question type (direct, scenario-based, and negative), significant differences were observed in direct (P<.001) and scenario-based (P<.001) questions, but not in negative questions (P=.48). The students reported a high level of satisfaction (7.9/10) with the educational experience, expressing a strong desire to repeat the experience (7.6/10).
    CONCLUSIONS: This study demonstrated the efficacy of AI chatbots in answering complex medical questions related to vaccination and providing valuable educational support. Their performance significantly surpassed that of medical students in direct and scenario-based questions. The responsible and critical use of AI chatbots can enhance medical education, making it an essential aspect to integrate into the educational system.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

公众号