越来越多的人关注医生的健康和行为,包括医疗服务提供者的心理健康问题和倦怠的发生,医师损害,以及医生所谓的破坏性行为。在这些领域中的任何一个,医生可能成为调查的对象。研究被调查医生的经验对于识别和减轻任何潜在的不利个人和实践影响非常重要。这反过来又会阻碍病人的护理。这篇综述的目的是(1)总结迄今为止发表的关于被调查的医生的经验的科学文献,和(2)基于这些发现考虑策略,以减轻对医生的调查过程的任何不利影响.2023年6月,使用相关搜索词对数据库PubMed和OvidMEDLINE进行了搜索。审查标题后,摘要,全长文章,和参考列表,对16篇文章进行了鉴定和审查。在多个国家接受过调查的医生通常描述为短期(愤怒的感觉,抑郁症,焦虑,羞耻,无能为力,隔离,被背叛,对临床决策的信心降低)和长期(防御性实践的增加,提前退休)对调查过程的影响。医生发现调查过程中最困难的方面是涉及的时间长短,缺乏透明度/沟通的过程,孤立的感觉,处理无理取闹的投诉。虽然对医生的抱怨有可能预示着建设性的个人实践和系统性变化,研究表明,医生的调查过程与短期和长期的负面情绪和实践影响有关。提出了减轻调查过程意外不利影响的策略。需要进一步的研究来澄清医生的调查经验,包括在医学中代表性不足的医生,并系统地评估减轻调查过程中不健康或破坏性成分的策略的有效性。
Growing attention is being paid to physician health and behavior, including the occurrence of mental health issues and burnout in medical providers, physician impairment, and alleged disruptive behavior in physicians. In any of these areas, a physician may become the subject of an
investigation. Studying the experience of investigated physicians is important to identify and mitigate any potential adverse personal and practice impacts, which in turn can hinder patient care. The purpose of this
review is to (1) summarize the published scientific literature to date regarding the experiences of physicians who have been investigated, and (2) based on these findings consider strategies to mitigate any adverse effects of the investigatory process for physicians. A search of the databases PubMed and Ovid MEDLINE was conducted in June 2023 using relevant search terms. After reviewing titles, abstracts, full-length articles, and reference lists, 16 articles were identified and reviewed. Physicians in multiple countries who had been investigated commonly described short-term (feelings of anger, depression, anxiety, shame, powerlessness, isolation, being betrayed, less confidence in clinical decision-making) and long-term (increase in defensive practice, retiring early) impacts of the investigatory process. Physicians found the most difficult aspects of the
investigation process to be the length of time involved, lack of transparency/communication regarding the process, feelings of isolation, and dealing with vexatious complaints. While complaints about physicians have the potential to portend constructive individual practice and systemic changes, research suggests that the investigatory process for physicians is associated with negative short- and long-term emotional and practice impacts. Strategies to mitigate the unintended adverse effects of investigatory processes are proposed. Further research is warranted to clarify the
investigation experience for physicians, including physicians underrepresented in medicine, and to systematically assess the effectiveness of strategies to mitigate unhealthy or disruptive components of the investigatory process.