cultural humility

文化谦逊
  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    尽管全国少女怀孕率下降,与白人青少年相比,拉丁裔和黑人的青少年出生率仍然更高。在美国,与非拉丁裔白人青少年相比,拉丁裔女性(15-19岁)生育少女的可能性是其两倍多。随着一个日益多样化的国家,转向具有文化包容性的护理方法对于实现公平的患者结局至关重要.改善获得预防性护理的机会,劳动力多样性,和保险范围将导致节省成本,也有助于恢复对过去几代人失败的系统的信任。在这篇评论中,将提供专门针对拉丁裔妇女的有针对性的建议,包括具有文化能力的节育咨询,关注生殖正义。不会说英语,社会经济地位低下,文化适应,法律地位,没有保险都是拉丁裔妇女特有的少女怀孕风险因素。还必须考虑文化偏好和对避孕的态度。进一步扩大医疗补助保险覆盖面也是必要的,以增加弱势群体的生殖机会。建议采用文化谦卑的框架来提供生殖健康咨询和服务。在这一框架内,鼓励家庭参与,妇女免受生殖胁迫;她们有获得非处方避孕的自由,并得到认识文化和传统的提供者和社区卫生工作者的指导和支持。为了降低少女怀孕率和实现生殖正义,必须采取一种对文化敏感并与拉丁裔异质性保持一致的基于社区的综合方法。
    Despite a national decline in teenage pregnancy rates, Latinxs and Black individuals continue to have higher teenage birth rates compared to white teens. In the United States, Latinx females (ages 15-19) are more than twice as likely to have a teenage birth compared to non-Latinx white teens. With an increasingly diverse nation, a shift towards culturally inclusive approaches to care is critical to achieving equitable patient outcomes. Improving access to preventative care, workforce diversity, and insurance coverage will lead to cost-savings and also help restore trust in a system that has failed past generations. In this commentary, targeted recommendations tailored specifically towards Latinx women will be provided including culturally competent birth control counseling, and a focus on reproductive justice. Not speaking English, low socioeconomic status, acculturation, legal status, and being uninsured are all teenage pregnancy risk factors unique to Latinx women. Cultural preferences and attitudes towards contraception must also be considered. Further expansion of Medicaid insurance coverage is also necessary to increase reproductive access among vulnerable populations. A cultural humility framework to reproductive health counseling and services is recommended. Within this framework family engagement is encouraged and women are free from reproductive coercion; they have the freedom to access over-the-counter contraception and receive guidance and support from providers and community health workers who are cognizant of culture and heritage. An integrated community-based approach that is culturally sensitive and in tune with Latinx heterogenicity is necessary to lower teenage pregnancy rates and achieve reproductive justice.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

    求助全文

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    经常使用“文化谦逊”一词,但是无论是社会还是专业人士,包括护士,缺乏对其含义的清晰理解。这项研究检查了这些关系,预测因子,以及护士领导者在护理实践中的文化谦逊差异,医院护士认为。
    对350名约旦注册护士(RNs)进行了定量横向和相关研究。
    护士“同意”护士领导在护理实践中的文化谦逊,但很低.工作轮班,持有护理或更少学士学位,从一所私立大学毕业后,预测了护士领导者在护理实践中的文化谦逊。在护理实践中,护士领导者的文化谦逊性的大多数差异来自与轮班工作的护士相比轮班工作的护士。
    护士领导者必须练习开放的沟通和接受的心态,因为这将有助于消除护士领导者相信他们知道“无所不知”的倾向。\"
    UNASSIGNED: The term \"cultural humility\" is often used, but both society and professionals, including nurses, lack a clear understanding of its meaning. This study examined the relationships, predictors, and differences of nurse leaders\' cultural humility in nursing practice, as perceived by hospital nurses.
    UNASSIGNED: A quantitative transverse and correlational study was implemented with a convenience sample of 350 Jordanian registered nurses (RNs).
    UNASSIGNED: Nurses \"agreed\" on the presence of nurse leaders\' cultural humility in nursing practice, but it was low. Working rotating shifts, holding a Baccalaureate degree in nursing or less, and having graduated from a private university predicted the perceived nurse leaders\' cultural humility in nursing practice. Most differences in perceived nurse leaders\' cultural humility in nursing practice came from nurses who worked rotating shifts when compared to those who worked day shifts.
    UNASSIGNED: Nurse leaders must practice open communication and embrace a receptive mind-set, as this will help eradicate the tendency of nurse leaders to believe they know \"know-it-all.\"
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

    求助全文

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    向医学生介绍文化谦逊的概念,我们设计了一个教学计划,让学生考虑如何通过在临床交流中使用语言来体现力量,专注于全科医学。文化谦逊是一个教学框架,由Tervalon和Murray-Garcia介绍,以解决他们认为的文化能力模型的局限性。
    我们的教学计划专门针对临床交流中的力量,口头磋商和书面说明。该课程在他们的第一个“临床”年度面向三年级医学生,他们定期见证并参与初级和二级护理实习的临床沟通。道德上的认可已经到位,以分析学生对会议的思考。
    参加的学生很好。他们对会议进行了积极的评价,因为他们提高了对临床语言在负面刻板印象和非人性化患者中的力量的认识。他们在反映通常用于医患关系的临床语言的无意伤害时表现出文化谦卑。然而,对我们来说最引人注目的是,以及我们作为教育者的学习所在,出席会议的人很少,尽管我们试图强调临床相关性和作为未来医生发展的重要性。
    本文为对文化谦逊感兴趣的教育者提供了一个框架。这一举措的含义是如何(或如何不)在这一领域发展和提供培训。作为教育工作者需要更多的考虑,包括我们自己的语言,如何让学生围绕权力这个复杂的话题进行思考。
    UNASSIGNED: Introducing medical students to the concept of Cultural Humility, we devised a teaching initiative for students to consider how power manifests through the use of language in clinical communication, with a focus on General Practice. Cultural Humility is a pedagogical framework, introduced by Tervalon and Murray-Garcia, to address what they consider as the limitations of the Cultural Competence model.
    UNASSIGNED: Our teaching initiative specifically focused on power in clinical communication, both oral consultations and written notes. The session was delivered to third-year medical students during their first \'clinical\' year, where they regularly witness and are involved in clinical communication across primary and secondary care placements. Ethical approval was in place to analyse students\' reflections on the session.
    UNASSIGNED: Students who attended engaged well. They evaluated the session positively as increasing their awareness of the power of clinical language in negatively stereotyping and dehumanising patients. They demonstrated Cultural Humility in their reflections of the unintentional harm of clinical language commonly used for the doctor-patient relationship. However, most striking for us, and where our learning as educators lies, was the low attendance at the session, despite our attempts to underline clinical relevance and importance for development as future doctors.
    UNASSIGNED: This article offers a framework for educators interested in Cultural Humility. The implications of this initiative are how (or how not) to develop and deliver training in this space. More consideration is required as educators, including around our own language, as to how to engage students to think around the complex topic of power.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

    求助全文

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    在培训和临床服务提供中解决系统性不公正和种族主义是临床科学的关键下一步。虽然APA多元文化准则和认证标准长期以来一直强调这一需求,大多数研究生课程提供关于多样性的单一课程,股本,和包容性主题,这不足以培训和维持文化上谦卑的提供者,并纠正心理学中的系统性不公正和种族主义。很少有“真实世界”的例子来指导训练模型的开发。我们提供专业诊所的发展和组成部分的背景,新墨西哥大学文化咨询中心,其使命是为不同的客户提供文化上知情的临床服务,并在整个研究生课程中注入多元文化培训。接受了心理学和批判种族理论的种族空间框架,我们描述我们的方法旨在:1)为多元文化和反种族主义培训的实施和交付提供申请;2)加强监督模式;和3)提高对结构能力的认识。我们的诊所,在学生和教师之间合作开发,作为围绕结构性不公正进行对话的安全论坛,并寻求改善对不同客户和精神保健服务不足的人的治疗。我们讨论学生和教师参与的问题,并提供教师和有色人种学生的观点,说明我们服务的案例,以及目前扩大和正规化社区合作的努力。我们提供一个集成课程的模型,非正式活动,以及对全面学生培训的多元文化监督,并促进围绕公平的对话和支持的部门文化,多样性,和正义。
    Addressing systemic injustices and racism in training and clinical service provision are key next steps in clinical science. While the APA Multicultural Guidelines and accreditation standards have long emphasized this need, most graduate programs offer a single course on diversity, equity, and inclusion topics, which is inadequate to train and sustain culturally humble providers and redress systemic injustices and racism within psychology. Few \"real-world\" examples exist to guide the development of training models. We provide background on the development and components of a specialty clinic, the University of New Mexico\'s Cultural Counseling Center, whose mission is providing culturally informed clinical services to diverse clientele, and to infuse multicultural training throughout the graduate program. Informed by the racial-spatial framework for psychology and critical race theory, we describe our approach intended to: 1) offer applications for the operationalization and delivery of multicultural and antiracist training; 2) enhance supervisory models; and 3) increase awareness of structural competence. Our clinic, developed collaboratively among students and faculty, serves as a safe forum for dialogue around structural injustices and seeks to improve treatment for diverse clients and those underserved in mental health care. We discuss issues of student and faculty engagement and offer the perspectives of faculty and students of color, case examples illustrating our services, and current efforts to expand and formalize community collaborations. We offer a model that integrates coursework, informal activities, and multicultural supervision for comprehensive student training and that promotes a departmental culture of dialogue and support around equity, diversity, and justice.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    虽然许多患者渴望精神关怀,它很少由医生提供。当采用文化谦逊和勇气的模式时,住院医师可以介绍患者的精神关怀。
    我们开发了这个90分钟,一次会议,直接与住院医师谈论医学与灵性之间的关系以及精神护理的性质。在会议中,我们促进居民反思他们目前对精神护理的态度,同时解决其证据,障碍,和时间。我们还讨论了文化谦卑和勇气的必要性,因为我们遵循精神关怀的根源:指导一个人在当前情况下寻找意义。
    我们向所有四个培训年度的35名内科住院医师展示了这个互动会议。所有居民都以四种对精神护理的态度为模型,回答了嵌入式调查前后的问题:拒绝,守卫,务实,和拥抱。在陈述调查中没有报告拥抱精神关怀的22名居民中,10人(45%)在他们的课程后调查中报告说,他们对精神护理有更积极的态度。二十七位出席的居民(百分之七十七)也提供了有关演示质量的反馈意见,5分的平均评分为4.7分,表明总体满意度。
    针对医疗居民的精神护理的一次广受好评的会议将相关的精神护理课程纳入住院医师培训。可以为任何专业或资历的医生修改所得模块,并辅以其他基于技能的精神护理课程。
    UNASSIGNED: While many patients desire spiritual care, it is infrequently provided by physicians. When a model of cultural humility and courage is employed, resident physicians can be introduced to the spiritual care of patients.
    UNASSIGNED: We developed this 90-minute, onetime session to speak directly to resident physicians about the relationships between medicine and spirituality and the nature of spiritual care. In the session, we facilitated residents in reflecting on their current posture toward spiritual care while addressing its evidence, obstacles, and timing. We also discussed the need for cultural humility and courage as we followed spiritual care to its root: guiding a person in finding meaning in their current circumstances.
    UNASSIGNED: We presented this interactive session to 35 internal medicine residents from all four training years. All residents responded to an embedded pre- and postsurvey question modeled after four attitudes towards spiritual care: rejecting, guarded, pragmatic, and embracing. Out of 22 residents who did not report embracing spiritual care in the presession survey, 10 (45%) reported a more positive attitude toward spiritual care on their postcourse surveys. Twenty-seven residents in attendance (77%) also provided feedback about presentation quality, with a mean rating of 4.7 out of 5 indicating overall satisfaction.
    UNASSIGNED: A single well-received session on spiritual care for medical residents models the integration of relevant spiritual care curricula into residency training. The resulting module can be modified for physicians of any specialty or seniority and complemented by other skill-based spiritual care curricula.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    目的:描述临床医生如何在血液透析中心为不同文化的肾衰竭患者提供文化响应性护理。
    背景:接受中心维持性血液透析的文化多样性个体具有独特的文化需求。未满足的文化需求会损害并深刻影响他们的经历。鉴于文化敏感的护理有可能增强文化多样性人群的体验,了解临床医生如何提供符合文化的护理至关重要.
    方法:使用Arksey和OMalleys框架进行范围审查。五个数据库:Medline和CINAHLComplete(EBSCO),PsycINFO,搜索Embase(OVID)和ProQuest论文和论文数据库,以获取1990年至2023年之间以英语发表的研究文献。叙事合成用于合成数据。
    结果:从筛选的17,271条记录中,报告14项研究的17篇论文符合纳入标准。叙事综合揭示了两个主题:(i)交流促进因素和障碍,包括语言差异,专业和外行口译员使用;以及(Ii)文化的重要性,其中包括承认文化优先事项,适应文化饮食偏好和获得文化培训。
    结论:虽然与血液透析相关的竞争优先事项对临床医生来说可能是一个挑战,认识到文化护理需求的重要性并将其纳入护理中很重要。必须通过促进血液透析中肾衰竭患者的独特文化需求来表现出对文化多样性的尊重并提供以人为本的护理。
    结论:文化反应性护理是复杂和多维的。应该承认个人的文化关怀需求,尊敬的,并被照顾。
    没有患者或公众捐款。研究方案在开放科学框架中注册。https://osf.io/uv8g3.
    OBJECTIVE: To describe how clinicians provide culturally responsive care to culturally diverse people with kidney failure in haemodialysis centres.
    BACKGROUND: Culturally diverse individuals receiving in-centre maintenance haemodialysis have unique cultural needs. Unmet cultural needs can impair and profoundly affect their experiences. Given culturally responsive care has the potential to enhance the experiences of culturally diverse people, it is vital to understand how clinicians provide culturally responsive care.
    METHODS: A scoping review was undertaken using Arksey and OMalleys framework. Five databases: Medline and CINAHL Complete (EBSCO), PsycINFO, Embase (OVID) and ProQuest Theses and Dissertation databases were searched for research literature published in English between 1990 and 2023. Narrative synthesis was used to synthesise the data.
    RESULTS: From the 17,271 records screened, 17 papers reporting 14 studies met the inclusion criteria. Narrative synthesis revealed two themes: (i) communication enablers and barriers including linguistic differences, professional and lay interpreter use; and (ii) the importance of culture, which encompassed acknowledging cultural priorities, accommodating cultural food preferences and access to cultural training.
    CONCLUSIONS: While competing priorities associated with haemodialysis may be a challenge for clinicians, recognising the significance of cultural care needs and accommodating them in care is important. Demonstrating respect towards cultural diversity and providing person-centred care by facilitating the unique cultural needs of people with kidney failure in haemodialysis is imperative.
    CONCLUSIONS: Culturally responsive care is complex and multidimensional. Individuals\' cultural care needs should be acknowledged, respected, and accommodated in care.
    UNASSIGNED: No patient or public contribution. The study protocol was registered in the Open Science Framework. https://osf.io/uv8g3.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

    求助全文

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    目的:探索种族化家庭对如何,如果,医生应该在临床环境中解决儿童的种族身份和种族主义概念。
    方法:种族化儿童的父母,5至18岁的人接受了采访,以探索种族身份形成的经验,歧视,以及他们希望儿科医生解决这些问题的程度。儿童由父母自行决定。采访被转录,编码,并通过基于建构主义扎根理论的批判种族理论镜头进行了分析。
    结果:父母鼓励孩子接受他们的种族身份,但也想保护他们免受种族主义的负面经历,以保护身份安全。父母认为儿科医生应该以特定于孩子情况的方式解决种族问题。周到地包含与种族有关的问题,无论是在讨论中还是在问卷调查中,对于防止治疗关系中的紧张至关重要。关于临床前筛查的使用尚无共识。相反,家庭强调了拥抱谦逊的重要性,信任,和尊重。
    结论:参与者家庭对解决种族主义对其子女健康影响的方法有偏好。儿科医生应该理解身份安全的重要性,并以文化谦卑的态度对待他们的讨论,其中包括自我反省,同理心,积极倾听,灵活的谈判。最重要的是,儿科医生需要为适当讨论这些问题创造一个安全的环境。
    OBJECTIVE: To explore racially minoritized families\' perceptions on how, and if, physicians should address children\'s racial identity and concepts of racism within clinical settings.
    METHODS: Parents of racially minoritized children, ages 5 through 18, were interviewed to explore experiences with racial identity formation, discrimination, and the extent to which they wanted pediatricians to address these topics. Children were included at the discretion of their parents. Interviews were transcribed, coded, and analyzed through a critical race theory lens based in constructivist grounded theory.
    RESULTS: Parents encouraged their children to embrace their racial identities but also wanted to shield them from negative experiences of racism to preserve identity safety. Parents felt pediatricians should address racial issues in a manner specific to their child\'s situation. Thoughtful inclusion of race-related questions, whether in discussion or on questionnaires, is essential to prevent tension in a therapeutic relationship. There was no consensus on the use of preclinical screening. Instead, families highlighted the importance of embracing humility, trust, and respect.
    CONCLUSIONS: Participant families have preferences for approaches to address the effects of racism on their children\'s health. Pediatricians should understand the importance of identity safety and approach their discussions with cultural humility, which includes self-reflection, empathy, active listening, and flexible negotiation. Above all, pediatricians need to create a safe environment for appropriate discussion of these issues.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

    求助全文

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    健康科学和医学教育的最新发现强调了培训医疗保健专业人员以文化谦卑的方式与患者互动的重要性(Nadal等人。,“咨询与发展杂志”92:57-66,2014;Pascoe&SmartRichman,“心理学通报”135:531,2009;Sirois&Burg,“行为修正”杂志27:83-102,2003;威廉姆斯和穆罕默德,“行为医学杂志”32:20-47,2009)。我们应对培训挑战的能力发展中的一个重要部分是对文化谦逊的评估。作为先前研究的延伸(Lombardero等人。,在医学环境中的临床心理学杂志上,30:261-273,2023年),这项研究实施了基于证据的文化谦逊干预(基于接受和承诺培训),以改善医学生与标准化患者(SP)的互动,并通过直接行为观察进行评估.具体来说,观察性测量系统的重点是对向医学专业人员报告微侵袭的患者的文化上不起眼的反应.对结果进行的事后比较表明,对于使用的一种测量量表,参与者对SP的文化上谦逊的反应具有统计学上的显着改善(即,ARISE),但不是另一个(即,对种族挑战的反应量表)。进一步分析,在表演者的底部四分位数上,进行评估,以评估没有显示显着变化的规模可能的上限效应。将讨论这些结果和对未来研究的启示。
    Recent findings in health sciences and medical education highlight the importance of training healthcare professionals to interact with their patients in a culturally humble manner (Nadal et al., in Journal of Counseling and Development 92: 57-66, 2014; Pascoe & Smart Richman, in Psychological Bulletin 135: 531, 2009; Sirois & Burg, in Behavior Modification 27: 83-102, 2003; Williams & Mohammed, in Journal of Behavioral Medicine 32: 20-47, 2009). An important piece in the progression of our ability to address training challenges is the assessment of cultural humility. As an extension of previous research (Lombardero et al., in Journal of Clinical Psychology in Medical Settings, 30: 261-273, 2023), this study implemented an evidence-based cultural humility intervention (based on Acceptance and Commitment Training) to improve medical students\' interactions with standardized patients (SPs) which was assessed via direct behavioral observation. Specifically, the observational measurement system was focused on culturally humble responses to patients reporting microaggressions to the medical professional. A pre-post comparison of the results demonstrated statistically significant improvements pertaining to participants\' culturally humble responses to SPs\' reports of microaggressions for one of the measurement scales used (i.e., ARISE), but not the other (i.e., Responsiveness to Racial Challenges Scale). Further analyses, on the bottom quartile of performers, were conducted to assess a possible ceiling effect of the scale that did not demonstrate significant change. These results and implications for future research will be discussed.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

    求助全文

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    文化谦逊是对自我评价的终身承诺,纠正医患关系中的权力失衡,发展相互信任的有益伙伴关系。
    本研究的目的是确定文化谦卑训练的可行性和有效性。
    从2020年7月到2021年3月,有133名医学生参加的90分钟教育研讨会,住院医师和医学教育教师包括1)干预前和干预后的调查;2)关于公平和文化谦逊原则的互动演示;3)参与者探索社会文化身份和权力;和4)反思小组讨论。
    从干预前到干预后的感知分数评估显着增加(3.89[SEM=0.04]对4.22[0.08],p<0.001)和知识分数(0.52[0.02]对0.67[0.02],p<0.001)。被认为随时间变化的最常见的身份参与者是个性=40%,外观=36%,年龄=35%。遭受压迫/征服的最常见身份是种族/民族=54%,性别=40%,宗教=28%;而经历特权的最常见身份是性别=49%,种族/民族=42%,外貌=25%。男性参与者的性别认同平均功率得分为73%,而女性参与者的平均功率得分为-8%(P<0.001)。非西班牙裔白人的种族认同感平均功率评分为62%,而非白人参与者为13%(p<0.001)。英语作为第二语言仅被美国以外出生的人视为受压迫/征服的身份(p<0.001)。
    互动教育研讨会可以增加参与者关于文化谦逊的知识和看法。参与者可以自我反思,以识别被压迫/征服或特权的社会文化身份。
    UNASSIGNED: Cultural humility is a lifelong commitment to self-evaluation, redressing power imbalances in patient-physician relationships and developing mutually trusting beneficial partnerships.
    UNASSIGNED: The objective of this study was to determine the feasibility and efficacy of cultural humility training.
    UNASSIGNED: From July 2020-March 2021, 90-minute educational workshops attended by 133 medical students, resident physicians and medical education faculty included 1) pre- and post- intervention surveys; 2) interactive presentation on equity and cultural humility principles; 3) participants explored sociocultural identities and power; and 4) reflective group discussions.
    UNASSIGNED: There were significant increases from pre to post intervention assessments for perception scores (3.89 [SEM= 0.04] versus 4.22 [0.08], p<0.001) and knowledge scores (0.52 [0.02] versus 0.67 [0.02], p<0.001). Commonest identities participants recognized as changing over time were personality = 40%, appearance = 36%, and age =35%. Commonest identities experienced as oppressed/subjugated were race/ethnicity = 54%, gender = 40% and religion = 28%; whilst commonest identities experienced as privileged were gender= 49%, race/ethnicity = 42% and appearance= 25%. Male participants assigned mean power score of 73% to gender identity compared to mean power score of -8% by female participants (P<0.001). Non-Hispanic Whites had mean power score for race identity of 62% compared to 13% for non-white participants (p<0.001). English as a second language was only acknowledged as an oppressed/subjugated identity by those born outside the United States (p<0.001).
    UNASSIGNED: An interactive educational workshop can increase participants\' knowledge and perceptions regarding cultural humility. Participants can self-reflect to recognize sociocultural identities that are oppressed/subjugated or privileged.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    黑人和女性使用腕管松解术(CTR)的差异有据可查,但关于患者-提供者一致性对治疗建议的影响知之甚少.为了调查这一点,我们使用假设情景调查了手外科医师,以评估基于患者相关因素和患者-提供者一致性的腕管综合征治疗建议的差异.
    3对(共6种)具有腕管综合征临床症状的假设情景被创建为不同性别,种族,和职业。我们用名字来代表性别和种族。职业包括体力劳动者,秘书,运动员,退休人员。美国手外科协会成员通过电子邮件发送了一个匿名的基于网络的链接来参与。我们使用描述性统计来分析基于情景的治疗建议。
    我们确定了3,067名符合条件的参与成员;770名外科医生(25%)做出了回应,并为3,742种情况提供了建议。对于没有电诊断研究(EDS)的症状患者,正常EDS,和异常的EDS,根据患者种族,外科医生的治疗建议没有差异,性别,和职业。在黑人女性和白人男性患者的情况下,外科医生推荐了31%和32.8%的EDS,分别,在EDS正常的白人女性和黑人男性中,有32.3%和33%的CTR没有EDS,分别。在80岁以上的退休黑人女性和白人男性患者中,EDS异常,其中89.9%和89.3%的外科医生推荐CTR,分别。对于患者提供者种族一致的配对,白人外科医生向相似比例的黑人和白人假设患者推荐CTR;然而,黑人外科医生向更大比例的黑人名字患者推荐CTR。
    我们发现外科医生的治疗建议与患者种族无关,性别,或职业;然而,基于患者与提供者的种族一致性,确实出现了差异,提示患者和提供者身份的一致性可能会影响治疗建议.
    预后III.
    UNASSIGNED: Differences in the utilization of carpal tunnel release (CTR) by Blacks and women are well documented, but less is known regarding the impact of patient-provider concordance on treatment recommendations. To investigate this, we surveyed hand surgeons using hypothetical scenarios to evaluate variations in treatment recommendations for carpal tunnel syndrome based on patient-related factors and patient-provider concordance.
    UNASSIGNED: Three pairs (six total) of hypothetical scenarios with clinical symptoms of carpal tunnel syndrome were created varying sex, race, and occupation. We used names as a proxy for sex and race. Occupation included manual laborers, secretaries, athletes, and retirees. American Society for Surgery of the Hand members were emailed an anonymous web-based link to participate. We used descriptive statistics to analyze the scenario-based treatment recommendations.
    UNASSIGNED: We identified 3,067 eligible members for participation; 770 surgeons responded (25%) and provided recommendations for 3,742 scenarios. For scenarios involving symptomatic patients without electrodiagnostic studies (EDS), with normal EDS, and with abnormal EDS, no difference was noted in surgeon treatment recommendations based on patients\' race, sex, and occupation. Surgeons recommended EDS for 31% and 32.8% of the scenarios with Black female and White male patients, respectively, who did not have EDS at presentation and CTR for 32.3% and 33% of White females and Black males with normal EDS, respectively. Among retired Black female and White male patients older than 80 years of age with abnormal EDS, surgeons recommended CTR in 89.9% and 89.3% of them, respectively. For patient-provider racially concordant pairs, White surgeons recommended CTR to a similar proportion of Black and White hypothetical patients; however, Black surgeons recommended CTR to a greater proportion of patients with Black-sounding names.
    UNASSIGNED: We found that surgeon treatment recommendation was not associated with patient race, sex, or occupation; however, differences did emerge based on patient-provider racial concordance, suggesting that alignment of patient and provider identities may influence treatment recommendations.
    UNASSIGNED: Prognostic III.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

公众号