In clinical trials testing abemaciclib in patients with hormone-receptor-positive (HR+), HER2-negative (HER2-) advanced breast cancer, diarrhea is a very common adverse event (occurring in approximately 85% of patients, any grade). Nonetheless, this toxicity leads to abemaciclib discontinuation in a small proportion of patients (approximately 2%) thanks to the use of effective loperamide-based supportive therapy. We aimed to determine whether the incidence of abemaciclib-induced diarrhea in real-world trials was higher than the one reported in clinical trials, where patients are highly selected, and to evaluate the success rate of standard supportive care in this setting. We conducted a retrospective, observational, monocentric study including 39 consecutive patients with HR+/HER2- advanced breast cancer treated with abemaciclib and endocrine therapy at our institution from July 2019 to May 2021. Overall, diarrhea of any grade occurred in 36 patients (92%), of whom 6 (17%) had diarrhea of grade ≥3. In 30 patients (77%), diarrhea was associated with other adverse events, including fatigue (33%), neutropenia (33%), emesis (28%), abdominal pain (20%), and hepatotoxicity (13%). Loperamide-based supportive therapy was administered to 26 patients (72%). Abemaciclib dose was reduced in 12 patients (31%) due to diarrhea, and treatment was permanently discontinued in 4 patients (10%). In 58% of patients (15/26), diarrhea was effectively managed with supportive care and did not require abemaciclib dose reduction and/or discontinuation. In our real-world analysis, we observed a higher incidence of diarrhea related to abemaciclib compared to data from clinical trials, and a higher rate of permanent treatment discontinuation due to gastrointestinal toxicity. Better implementation of guideline-based supportive care could help to manage this toxicity.