■已经开发了用于治疗狼疮性肾炎(LN)的各种免疫抑制方案。本研究旨在比较免疫抑制方案在成人LN患者中的疗效和安全性。
■我们系统地搜索了PubMed,Embase,和Cochrane中央对照试验注册数据库,包括会议记录,审判登记处,和参考列表,从成立到2022年7月10日。使用累积排序曲线(SUCRA)下的表面对处理的效果进行比较和排序。主要终点是完全缓解。次要终点是完全缓解,系统性红斑狼疮疾病活动指数(SLEDAI),复发,全因死亡率,终末期肾病(ESRD),感染,带状疱疹,卵巢衰竭,骨髓抑制,和癌症。
■在172项研究中报告的62项试验,涉及6,936名患者,纳入网络荟萃分析。他克莫司(TAC)的组合,霉酚酸酯(MMF),和糖皮质激素(GC)提供了总缓解率的最佳结果(SUCRA,86.63%)和SLEDAI(SUCRA,91.00%),而voclosorin(VCS)的组合,MMF和GC在完全缓解率方面得到了最好的改善(SUCRA,90.71%)。环磷酰胺(CYC)的组合,MMF和GC与最低的复发风险相关(SUCRA,85.57%)和癌症(SUCRA,85.14%),而奥比努珠单抗(OTB)的组合,MMF和GC与全因死亡率的最低风险相关(SUCRA,84.07%)。利妥昔单抗(RTX)加MMF加GC与ESRD的风险最低(SUCRA,83.11%),而硫唑嘌呤(AZA)加CYC加GC(SUCRA,68.59%)。TAC加GC与带状疱疹的风险最低(SUCRA,87.67%)和卵巢功能衰竭(SUCRA,73.60%)。环孢菌素(CsA)加GC与骨髓抑制的风险最低(SUCRA,79.50%),而AZA加GC与骨髓抑制的风险最高(SUCRA,16.25%)。
■这项研究表明,TAC的组合,MMF和GC是提高总缓解率的最佳方案。对于高危患者,应强调特定结局的最佳方案。
Various immunosuppressive regimens have been developed for the treatment of lupus nephritis (LN). This study aimed to compare the efficacy and safety of immunosuppressive regimens in adults with LN.
We systematically searched the PubMed, Embase, and Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials databases, including conference proceedings, trial registries, and reference lists, from inception until July 10, 2022. The effects of treatment were compared and ranked using the surface under the cumulative ranking curve (SUCRA). The primary endpoint was total remission. The secondary endpoints were complete remission, systemic lupus erythematosus disease activity index (SLEDAI), relapse, all-cause mortality, end-stage renal disease (ESRD), infection, herpes zoster, ovarian failure, myelosuppression, and cancer.
Sixty-two trials reported in 172 studies involving 6,936 patients were included in the network meta-analysis. The combination of tacrolimus (TAC), mycophenolate mofetil (MMF), and glucocorticoid (GC) provided the best result for the total remission rate (SUCRA, 86.63%) and SLEDAI (SUCRA, 91.00%), while the combination of voclosporin (VCS) , MMF and GC gave the best improvement in the complete remission rate (SUCRA, 90.71%). The combination of cyclophosphamide (CYC), MMF and GC was associated with the lowest risk of relapse (SUCRA, 85.57%) and cancer (SUCRA, 85.14%), while the combination of obinutuzumab (OTB), MMF and GC was associated with the lowest risk of all-cause mortality (SUCRA, 84.07%). Rituximab (RTX) plus MMF plus GC was associated with the lowest risk of ESRD (SUCRA, 83.11%), while the risk of infection was lowest in patients treated with azathioprine (AZA) plus CYC plus GC (SUCRA, 68.59%). TAC plus GC was associated with the lowest risk of herpes zoster (SUCRA, 87.67%) and ovarian failure (SUCRA, 73.60%). Cyclosporine (CsA) plus GC was associated with the lowest risk of myelosuppression (SUCRA, 79.50%), while AZA plus GC was associated with the highest risk of myelosuppression (SUCRA, 16.25%).
This study showed that a combination of TAC, MMF and GC was the best regimen for improving the total remission rate. The optimal regimen for specific outcomes should be highlighted for high-risk patients.