目的:确定降低妊娠肝内胆汁淤积症(ICP)相关新生儿和产妇发病率的策略。
方法:按照GRADE方法评估文献的证据质量,并以PICO格式(患者,干预,比较,结果)和结果先验定义,并根据其重要性进行分类。在PubMed上进行了广泛的书目搜索,科克伦,EMBASE和谷歌学者数据库。评估了证据的质量(高,中度,低,非常低)和(i)强或(ii)弱建议或(iii)没有提出建议。与外部审稿人(Delphi调查)在两轮中对建议进行了审查,以选择共识建议。
结果:在14个问题中(来自PICO格式之外的12个PICO问题和一个定义问题),工作组和外部审稿人就14人(100%)达成协议。文献的证据水平不足以就两个问题提出建议。ICP的定义为暗示性瘙痒的发生(掌足底,排除鉴别诊断后,夜间)与总胆汁酸水平>10μmol/L或丙氨酸转氨酶水平高于2N相关。在没有鉴别诊断的暗示症状的情况下,建议不要进行额外的生物或超声检查。在有CIP的女性中,建议使用熊去氧胆酸来减轻母体瘙痒的强度(强烈推荐。证据质量适中)并降低总胆汁酸和丙氨酸转氨酶的水平。(强烈推荐。证据质量适中)。S-腺苷蛋氨酸,地塞米松,瓜尔胶或活性炭不应用于减少母体瘙痒的强度(强烈推荐。证据质量低),并且没有足够的数据推荐使用抗组胺药(无推荐。证据质量低)。利福平(弱推荐。证据质量很低)或血浆置换(强烈推荐。证据质量很低)不应用于减少产妇瘙痒和围产期发病率。血清胆汁酸监测建议降低围产期发病率和死亡率(死胎,早产)(低推荐。证据质量低)。证据水平不足以确定胎儿心率或胎儿超声监测是否有助于降低围产期发病率(无推荐)。建议从妊娠36周起胆汁酸水平高于99μmol/L时出生,以降低围产期发病率,特别是死产。当胆汁酸水平高于99μmol/L时,低于100μmol/L时,应告知女性引产可考虑妊娠37周和39周,以降低围产期发病率.(强烈推荐。证据质量低)。在产后,总胆汁酸和丙氨酸转氨酶水平应在处方雌激素-孕激素避孕之前检查并正常化,理想情况下使用低雌激素剂量(瘙痒和细胞溶解复发的风险)(低推荐。证据质量非常低)。
结论:尽管关于ICP妊娠期胆汁淤积的证据质量仍然很低,法国有强烈的共识,正如我们的德尔福研究所示,关于如何用ICP管理女性。参考一线治疗是熊去氧胆酸。
OBJECTIVE: To identify strategies for reducing neonatal and maternal morbidity associated with intrahepatic cholestasis pregnancy (ICP).
METHODS: The quality of evidence of the literature was assessed following the GRADE methodology with questions formulated in the PICO format (Patients, Intervention, Comparison, Outcome) and outcomes defined a priori and classified according to their importance. An extensive bibliographic search was performed on PubMed, Cochrane, EMBASE and Google Scholar databases. The quality of the evidence was assessed (high, moderate, low, very low) and a (i) strong or (ii) weak recommendations or (iii) no recommendation were formulated. The recommendations were reviewed in two rounds with external reviewers (Delphi survey) to select the
consensus recommendations.
RESULTS: Of the 14 questions (from 12 PICO questions and one definition question outside the PICO format), there was agreement between the working group and the external reviewers on 14 (100%). The level of evidence of the literature was insufficient to provide a recommendation on two questions. ICP is defined by the occurrence of suggestive pruritus (palmoplantar, nocturnal) associated with a total bile acid level>10μmol/L or an
alanine transaminase level above 2N after ruling out differential diagnoses. In the absence of suggestive symptoms of a differential diagnosis, it is recommended not to carry out additional biological or ultrasound tests. In women with CIP, ursodeoxycholic acid is recommended to reduce the intensity of maternal pruritus (Strong recommendation. Quality of the evidence moderate) and to decrease the level of total bile acids and
alanine transaminases. (Strong recommendation. Quality of the evidence moderate). S-adenosyl-methionine, dexamethasone, guar gum or activated charcoal should not be used to reduce the intensity of maternal pruritus (Strong recommendation. Quality of evidence low), and there is insufficient data to recommend the use of antihistamines (No recommendation. Quality of evidence low). Rifampicin (Weak recommendation. Very low quality of evidence) or plasma exchange (Strong recommendation. Very low quality of evidence) should not be used to reduce maternal pruritus and perinatal morbidity. Serum monitoring of bile acids is recommended to reduce perinatal morbidity and mortality (stillbirth, prematurity) (Low recommendation. Quality of the evidence low). The level of evidence is insufficient to determine whether fetal heart rate or fetal ultrasound monitoring are useful to reduce perinatal morbidity (No recommendation). Birth is recommended when bile acid level is above 99μmol/L from 36 weeks gestation to reduce perinatal morbidity, in particular stillbirth. When bile acid level is above 99μmol/L is below 100μmol/L, women should be informed that induction of labor could be considered 37 and 39 weeks gestation to reduce perinatal morbidity. (Strong recommendation. Quality of evidence low). In postpartum, total bile acids and
alanine transaminases level should be checked and normalized before prescribing estrogen-progestin contraception, ideally with a low estrogen dose (risk of recurrence of pruritus and cytolysis) (Low recommendation. Quality of evidence very low).
CONCLUSIONS: Although the quality of evidence regarding ICP gestational cholestasis remains low, there is a strong
consensus in France, as shown by our Delphi study, on how to manage women with ICP. The reference first-line treatment is ursodeoxycholic acid.