背景:人们对标准化成像标准(SIC)的开发和应用越来越感兴趣,以最大程度地减少变异性并提高头颈部鳞状细胞癌(HNSCC)图像解释的可重复性。
方法:使用PubMed和GoogleScholar搜索了\"鳞状细胞癌\"和\"标准化解释标准\"或\"放射学反应评估\"2009年至2024年发表的文章,返回56篇出版物。经过抽象审查,选择18人进行进一步评估,和6个不同的SICs(即,专家,Porceddu,霍普金斯,NI-RADS,修改过的多维尔,和Cuneo)被纳入这篇综述。在标准化报告系统的8个期望特征的背景下评估每个SIC。
结果:两个SIC具有社会认可(即,专家,NI-RADS);四个可用于评估局部和全身性疾病(即,专家,霍普金斯,NI-RADS,Cuneo),四个对模棱两可的成像结果有特定的类别(即,Porceddu,NI-RADS,修改过的多维尔,和Cuneo)。在8个期望性状的背景下,所有都证明了未来改进的领域。
结论:已经开发了多个SIC,并证明了其在HNSCC后处理成像中的价值;但是,这些系统仍未得到充分利用。选择具有最符合个人实践需求的功能的SIC有望最大限度地提高成功实施的可能性。
BACKGROUND: There is growing interest in the development and application of standardized imaging criteria (SIC), to minimize variability and improve the reproducibility of image interpretation in head and neck squamous cell carcinoma (HNSCC).
METHODS: \"Squamous cell carcinoma\" AND \"standardized interpretation criteria\" OR \"radiographic response assessment\" were searched using PubMed and Google Scholar for articles published between 2009 and 2024, returning 56 publications. After abstract review, 18 were selected for further evaluation, and 6 different SICs (i.e., PERCIST, Porceddu, Hopkins, NI-RADS, modified Deauville, and Cuneo) were included in this review. Each SIC is evaluated in the context of 8 desired traits of a standardized reporting system.
RESULTS: Two SICs have societal endorsements (i.e., PERCIST, NI-RADS); four can be used in the evaluation of locoregional and systemic disease (i.e., PERCIST, Hopkins, NI-RADS, Cuneo), and four have specific categories for equivocal imaging results (i.e., Porceddu, NI-RADS, modified Deauville, and Cuneo). All demonstrated areas for future improvement in the context of the 8 desired traits.
CONCLUSIONS: Multiple SICs have been developed for and demonstrated value in HNSCC post-treatment imaging; however, these systems remain underutilized. Selecting an SIC with features that best match the needs of one\'s practice is expected to maximize the likelihood of successful implementation.