目的:比较桡骨远端骨折非手术治疗与手术治疗的临床疗效。
方法:我们使用多个数据库进行了系统的文献检索,包括Medline,PubMed,还有Cochrane.所有数据库都是从最早的记录中搜索到2023年2月。该研究比较了桡骨远端骨折的非手术和手术治疗,仅包括随机对照试验(RCTS)。
结果:检索到17项随机对照试验。总共包括1730例患者:非手术组862例,手术组868例。结果显示DASH评分随着手术治疗显著降低(WMD3.98,95%CI(2.00,5.95),P<0.001)。在握力(%)中,结果显示,与非手术治疗相比,手术治疗显着改善(WMD-6.60,95%CI(-11.61,-1.60),P=0.01)。径向倾角有显著差异,径向长度,掌管标题,手腕内旋的范围,手腕旋光的范围。然而,径向偏差无差异,尺位偏差,尺骨方差,观察腕关节伸展范围和腕关节屈曲范围。
结论:这项荟萃分析的结果表明,一些手术治疗桡骨远端骨折的患者不仅提高了握力(%),降低了DASH得分,与非手术治疗相比,还改善了手腕内旋的范围和手腕外旋的范围。根据目前的荟萃分析,我们认为,一些手术治疗的患者可能更有效的桡骨远端骨折患者。
OBJECTIVE: To compare the clinical outcomes between
nonsurgical and surgical treatment of distal radius fracture.
METHODS: We performed a systematic literature search by using multiple databases, including Medline, PubMed, and Cochrane. All databases were searched from the earliest records through February 2023. The study compared
nonsurgical versus surgical treatment of distal radius fractures and included only randomized controlled trials (RCTS).
RESULTS: There were seventeen randomized controlled trials retrieved. A total of 1730 patients were included: 862 in the
nonsurgical group and 868 in the surgical group. The results showed a significant reduction in DASH score with surgical treatment (WMD 3.98, 95% CI (2.00, 5.95), P < 0.001). And in grip strength (%), the results showed a significant improvement in surgical treatment compared with non-surgical treatment (WMD - 6.60, 95% CI (-11.61, -1.60), P = 0.01). There was significant difference in radial inclination, radial length, volar title, range of wrist pronation, range of wrist supination. However, no difference in radial deviation, ulnar deviation, ulnar variance, range of wrist extension and range of wrist flexion was observed.
CONCLUSIONS: The results of this meta-analysis suggest that some patients with surgical treatment of distal radius fractures not only improved the grip strength (%), decreased the DASH score, but also improved the range of wrist pronation and the range of wrist supination compared with
nonsurgical treatment. Based on the present meta-analysis, we suggest that some patients with surgical treatment might be more effective in patients with distal radius fracture.