The immune response to inactivated influenza vaccines (IIV) is influenced by multiple factors, including hemagglutinin content and egg-based manufacturing. Only two US-licensed vaccines are manufactured without egg passage: cell culture-based inactivated vaccine (ccIIV) and recombinant vaccine (RIV). We conducted a randomized open-label trial in central Wisconsin during the 2018-19 and 2019-20 seasons to compare immunogenicity of sequential vaccination. Participants 18-64 years old were randomized 1:1:1 to receive RIV, ccIIV or IIV in strata defined by number of influenza vaccine doses in the prior 3 years. They were revaccinated with the same product in year two. Paired serum samples were tested by hemagglutination inhibition against egg-adapted and cell-grown vaccine viruses. Serologic endpoints included geometric mean titer (GMT), mean fold rise, and percent seroconversion. There were 373 participants randomized and vaccinated in 2018-19; 332 were revaccinated in 2019-20. In 2018-19, RIV and ccIIV were not more immunogenic than IIV against A/H1N1. The post-vaccination GMT against the cell-grown 3C.2a A/H3N2 vaccine virus was higher for RIV vs IIV (p = .001) and RIV vs ccIIV (p = .001). The antibody response to influenza B viruses was similar across study arms. In 2019-20, GMT against the cell-grown 3C.3a A/H3N2 vaccine virus was higher for RIV vs IIV (p = .03) and for RIV vs ccIIV (p = .001). RIV revaccination generated significantly greater backboosting to the antigenically distinct 3C.2a A/H3N2 virus (2018-19 vaccine strain) compared to ccIIV or IIV. This study adds to the evidence that RIV elicits a superior immunologic response against A/H3N2 viruses compared to other licensed influenza vaccine products.

UNASSIGNED: Seasonal influenza poses a significant burden of disease, affecting not only older adults but also individuals under the age of 60. It carries a high economic burden, mainly driven by influenza-associated productivity losses in the working population. Conventional egg-based influenza vaccines may have reduced effectiveness due to antigen adaptation in eggs. In contrast, cell-based influenza vaccines are less likely to be affected by such antigen adaptation. This review aims to present real-world data (RWD) comparing the effectiveness of quadrivalent cell-based (QIVc) and egg-based (QIVe) influenza vaccines over three consecutive seasons.
UNASSIGNED: A comprehensive review was conducted, analyzing RWD from retrospective cohort and case-control studies on the relative vaccine effectiveness (rVE) of QIVc versus QIVe during the 2017/18-2019/20 seasons.
UNASSIGNED: This study included six retrospective cohort studies and one case-control study, with a combined total of approximately 29 million participants. A cohort study involving people aged ≥4 years during the 2017/18 season showed a statistically significant rVE of QIVc compared to QIVe in preventing influenza-like illness, with a value of 36.2%. QIVc demonstrated statistically significant superiority over QIVe in preventing outpatient and inpatient medical encounters as observed in two cohort studies conducted during the 2018/19 and 2019/20 seasons. The rVE of QIVc compared to QIVe was found to be 7.6% in individuals aged ≥4 years and 9.5% in individuals aged ≥18 years. Three additional cohort studies conducted between 2017/18-2019/20 reported a statistically significant improvement in rVE (5.3-14.4%) of QIVc compared to QIVe in preventing influenza-related hospitalizations and emergency department visits due to influenza in individuals aged 4-64 years. In a case-control study across all three seasons, QIVc showed statistically significantly higher effectiveness compared to QIVe in preventing test-confirmed influenza, with rVEs of 10.0-14.8%.
UNASSIGNED: RWD from the 2017/18-2019/20 seasons demonstrated that QIVc is more effective than QIVe in preventing influenza-related outcomes in individuals aged 4-64 years. Preferential use of cell-based influenza vaccines, as opposed to conventional egg-based vaccines, could reduce the burden of influenza-related symptoms on individuals and alleviate the economic impact on the German population under 60 years of age.
UNASSIGNED: Die saisonale Influenza verursacht nicht nur bei älteren Erwachsenen, sondern auch in der Bevölkerung <60 Jahre eine signifikante Krankheitslast. Diese geht mit einer hohen wirtschaftlichen Belastung einher, insbesondere bedingt durch Influenza-assoziierte Produktivitätsverluste der arbeitenden Gesellschaft. Konventionelle eibasierte Influenzaimpfstoffe können aufgrund von Ei-Adaptation eine beeinträchtigte Impfeffektivität aufweisen, während zellkulturbasierte Influenzaimpfstoffe seltener von Antigenanpassungen betroffen sind. Ziel dieses Reviews war die Darstellung von „Real-World“-Daten (RWD) zur Effektivität von quadrivalenten zellkulturbasierten (QIVc) vs. eibasierten (QIVe) Influenzaimpfstoffen über drei konsekutive Saisons.
UNASSIGNED: Es wurde ein narrativer Review von RWD aus retrospektiven Kohorten- und Fall-Kontroll-Studien zur relativen Impfeffektivität (rVE) von QIVc vs. QIVe in den Saisons 2017/18–2019/20 durchgeführt.
UNASSIGNED: Es wurden sechs retrospektive Kohortenstudien und eine Fall-Kontroll-Studie eingeschlossen, die rund 29 Mio. Teilnehmer umfassten. Eine Kohortenstudie der Saison 2017/18 bei Personen ≥4 Jahre ergab eine statistisch signifikante rVE von QIVc vs. QIVe von 36,2% bei der Prävention Influenza-ähnlicher Erkrankung. QIVc war statistisch signifikant effektiver vs. QIVe bei der Prävention ambulanter und stationärer medizinischer Behandlungen in zwei Kohortenstudien der Saisons 2018/19 bzw. 2019/20 mit rVEs von 7,6% bei ≥4-Jährigen bzw. 9,5% bei ≥18-Jährigen. Drei weitere Kohortenstudien der Saisons 2017/18–2019/20 ergaben eine statistisch signifikant höhere rVE von QIVc vs. QIVe bei der Prävention Influenza-bedingter Hospitalisierungen/Besuchen der Notaufnahme bei 4–64-Jährigen (5,3–14,4%). Auch bei der Prävention testbestätigter Influenza war QIVc in einer Fall-Kontroll-Studie über alle drei Saisons statistisch signifikant effektiver mit rVEs von 10,0–14,8%.
UNASSIGNED: RWD der Saisons 2017/18–2019/20 zeigten eine bessere Impfeffektivität von QIVc vs. QIVe bei der Prävention Influenza-bedingter Endpunkte bei Personen im Alter von 4–64 Jahren. Der präferenzielle Einsatz von zellkulturbasierten vs. konventionellen Influenzaimpfstoffen könnte zu einer Verringerung der Influenza-bedingten Krankheitslast und wirtschaftlichen Belastung in der deutschen Bevölkerung <60 Jahre führen.

UNASSIGNED: Influenza vaccine viruses grown in eggs may acquire egg-adaptive mutations that may reduce antigenic similarity between vaccine and circulating influenza viruses and decrease vaccine effectiveness. We compared cell- and egg-based quadrivalent influenza vaccines (QIVc and QIVe, respectively) for preventing test-confirmed influenza over 3 US influenza seasons (2017-2020).
UNASSIGNED: Using a retrospective test-negative design, we estimated the relative vaccine effectiveness (rVE) of QIVc vs QIVe among individuals aged 4 to 64 years who had an acute respiratory or febrile illness and were tested for influenza in routine outpatient care. Exposure, outcome, and covariate data were obtained from electronic health records linked to pharmacy and medical claims. Season-specific rVE was estimated by comparing the odds of testing positive for influenza among QIVc vs QIVe recipients. Models were adjusted for age, sex, geographic region, influenza test date, and additional unbalanced covariates. A doubly robust approach was used combining inverse probability of treatment weights with multivariable regression.
UNASSIGNED: The study included 31 824, 33 388, and 34 398 patients in the 2017-2018, 2018-2019, and 2019-2020 seasons, respectively; ∼10% received QIVc and ∼90% received QIVe. QIVc demonstrated superior effectiveness vs QIVe in prevention of test-confirmed influenza: rVEs were 14.8% (95% CI, 7.0%-22.0%) in 2017-2018, 12.5% (95% CI, 4.7%-19.6%) in 2018-2019, and 10.0% (95% CI, 2.7%-16.7%) in 2019-2020.
UNASSIGNED: This study demonstrated consistently superior effectiveness of QIVc vs QIVe in preventing test-confirmed influenza over 3 seasons characterized by different circulating viruses and degrees of egg adaptation.

The population < 60 years of age is also affected by a significant disease burden from seasonal influenza. It carries a high economic burden, mainly driven by influenza-associated productivity losses in the working population. Conventional egg-based influenza vaccines may experience reduced effectiveness due to antigen adaptation in eggs. In contrast, cell-based influenza vaccines are less likely to be affected by antigenic adaptations to the host system and showed better effectiveness in individuals 4-64 years old over several seasons compared to conventional egg-based influenza vaccines under real-world conditions. Preferential use of cell-based influenza vaccines, as opposed to conventional egg-based vaccines, could reduce the burden of influenza-related symptoms on individuals and alleviate the economic impact on the German population < 60 years of age.
UNASSIGNED: Auch die Bevölkerung < 60 Jahre ist von einer signifikanten Krankheitslast durch die saisonale Influenza betroffen, einhergehend mit einer hohen wirtschaftlichen Belastung, insbesondere bedingt durch Influenza-assoziierte Produktivitätsverluste der arbeitenden Gesellschaft. Konventionelle eibasierte Influenzaimpfstoffe können aufgrund von Eiadaptation eine beeinträchtigte Impfeffektivität aufweisen. Zellkulturbasierte Influenzaimpfstoffe weisen seltener Antigenanpassungen an das Wirtssystem auf und zeigten über mehrere Saisons eine bessere Effektivität bei 4‑ bis 64-Jährigen gegenüber konventionellen eibasierten Influenzaimpfstoffen unter realen Bedingungen. Der präferenzielle Einsatz von zellkulturbasierten vs. konventionelle Influenzaimpfstoffe könnte zu einer Verringerung der Influenza-bedingten Krankheitslast und wirtschaftlichen Belastung in der deutschen Bevölkerung < 60 Jahre führen.

To ensure that vaccination offers the best protection against an infectious disease, sequence identity between the vaccine and the circulating strain is paramount. During replication of nucleic acid, random mutations occur due to the level of polymerase fidelity. In traditional influenza vaccine manufacture, vaccine viruses are propagated in fertilized chicken eggs, which can result in egg-adaptive mutations in the antigen-encoding genes. Whilst this improves infection and replication in eggs, mutations may reduce the effectiveness of egg-based influenza vaccines against circulating human viruses. In contrast, egg-adaptive mutations are avoided when vaccine viruses are propagated in Madin-Darby canine kidney (MDCK) cell lines during manufacture of cell-based inactivated influenza vaccines. The first mammalian cell-only strain was included in Flucelvax® Quadrivalent in 2017. A sequence analysis of the viruses selected for inclusion in this vaccine (n = 15 vaccine strains, containing both hemagglutinin and neuraminidase) demonstrated that no mutations occur in the antigenic sites of either hemagglutinin or neuraminidase, indicating that cell adaptation does not occur during production of this cell-based vaccine. The development of this now entirely mammalian-based vaccine system, which incorporates both hemagglutinin and neuraminidase, ensures that the significant protective antigens are equivalent to the strains recommended by the World Health Organization (WHO) in both amino acid sequence and glycosylation pattern. The inclusion of both proteins in a vaccine may provide an advantage over recombinant vaccines containing hemagglutinin alone. Findings from real world effectiveness studies support the use of cell-based influenza vaccines.

An antigenic mismatch between the vaccine and circulating H3N2 strains was hypothesized to contribute to the severity of the 2017-2018 season in North America.
Serum and nasal washes were collected from influenza positive and negative patients during the 2017-2018 season to determine neutralizing antibody (nAb) titers and for influenza virus sequencing, respectively.
The circulating and vaccine H3N2 virus strains were different clades, with the vaccine strain being clade 3C.2a and the circulating viruses being 3C.2a2 or 3C.3a. At enrollment, both the H3N2 negative and positive patients had greater nAb titers to the egg-adapted vaccine virus compared to the cell-grown vaccine but the H3N2-negative population had significantly greater titers to the circulating 3C.2a2. Among H3N2-positive patients, vaccination, younger age, and female sex were associated with greater nAb responses to the egg-adapted vaccine H3N2 virus but not to the cell-grown vaccine or circulating viruses.
For the 2017-2018 circulating viruses, mutations introduced by egg adaptation decreased vaccine efficacy. No increased protection was afforded by vaccination, younger age, or female sex against 2017-2018 circulating H3N2 viruses.

Seasonal influenza vaccines prevent influenza-related illnesses, hospitalizations, and deaths. However, these vaccines are not as effective as other viral vaccines, and there is clearly room for improvement. Here, we review the history of seasonal influenza vaccines, describe challenges associated with producing influenza vaccine antigens, and discuss the inherent difficulties of updating influenza vaccine strains each influenza season. We argue that seasonal influenza vaccines can be dramatically improved by modernizing antigen production processes and developing models that are better at predicting viral evolution. Resources should be specifically dedicated to improving seasonal influenza vaccines while developing entirely new vaccine platforms.

OBJECTIVE: When influenza viruses are cultured in eggs, amino acid mutations of the hemagglutinin may occur through egg adaptation. On the other hand, when influenza viruses are cultured in animal cells, no antigenic mutation occurs unlike in eggs. Therefore, we examined whether the antigenic mutations actually occurred after passage of H3N2 (A/Texas/50/2012) virus up to 15 times in eggs and MDCK-Sky3851 cells.
METHODS: Prototype A/Texas/50/2012 (H3N2) influenza virus which was isolated from clinical patient, not passaged in egg, was obtained and propagated using the specific pathogen free egg and the MDCK-Sky3851 cell line up to 15 passage, and the changes in the antigen sequence of the influenza viruses were confirmed by gene sequencing and protein structure analysis.
RESULTS: In term of the hemagglutination titer of influenza virus, the reactivity to chicken and guinea pig red blood cell showed different results between egg propagated and cell propagated viruses. In the sequence analysis results for hemagglutinin and neuraminidase, no antigenic mutation was observed throughout all passages when cultured in MDCK-Sky3851 cells. On the other hand, mutations occurred in three amino acid sequences (H156R, G186S, S219F) in hemagglutinin up to 15 passages when cultured in eggs.
CONCLUSIONS: H3N2 influenza virus cultured in eggs could lead mutations in amino acid sequence of hemagglutinin, distinct from the corresponding virus cultured in cells for which no antigenic mutation was observed. These findings suggest that cell culture is a more stable and effective way of production with lower risk of antigenic mutations for the manufacture of influenza vaccines.

Influenza vaccine effectiveness was low in 2017-2018, yet circulating influenza A(H3N2) viruses were antigenically similar to cell-grown vaccine strains. Notably, most influenza vaccines are egg propagated.
Serum specimens were collected shortly after illness onset from 15 influenza A(H3N2) virus-infected cases and 15 uninfected hospitalized adults. Geometric mean titers against egg- and cell-grown influenza A/Hong Kong/4801/2014(H3N2) virus vaccine strains and representative circulating viruses (including A/Washington/16/2017) were determined by a microneutralization (MN) assay. Independent effects of strain-specific titers on susceptibility were estimated by logistic regression.
MN titers against egg-grown influenza A/Hong Kong virus were significantly higher among vaccinated individuals (173 vs 41; P = 0.01). In unadjusted models, a 2-fold increase in titers against egg-grown influenza A/Hong Kong virus was not significantly protective (29% reduction; P = .09), but a similar increase in the cell-grown influenza A/Washington virus antibody titer (3C.2a2) was protective (60% reduction; P = .02). Higher egg-grown influenza A/Hong Kong virus titers were not significantly associated with infection, when adjusted for antibody titers against influenza A/Washington virus (15% reduction; P = .61). A 54% reduction in the odds of infection was observed with a 2-fold increase in titer against influenza A/Washington virus (P = not significant), adjusted for the titer against egg-grown influenza A/Hong Kong virus titer.
Individuals vaccinated in 2017-2018 had high antibody titers against the egg-adapted vaccine strain and lower titers against circulating viruses. Titers against circulating but not egg-adapted strains were correlated with protection.

An H9N2 avian influenza A virus (AIV), A/chicken/Korea/01310/2001 (01310-CE20), was established after 20 passages of influenza A/chicken/Korea/01310/2001 (01310-CE2) virus through embryonated chicken eggs (ECEs). As a result of this process, the virus developed highly replicative and pathogenic traits within the ECEs through adaptive mutations in hemagglutinin (HA: T133N, V216G, and E439D) and neuraminidase (NA: 18-amino acid deletion and E54D). Here, we also established that 01310-CE20 acquired resistance to innate inhibitors present in the egg white during these passages. To investigate the role of egg-adapted mutations in resistance to innate inhibitors, we generated four PR8-derived recombinant viruses using various gene combinations of HA and NA from 01310-CE2 and 01310-CE20 (rH2N2, rH2N20, rH20N2, and rH20N20). As expected, rH20N20 showed significantly higher replication efficiency in MDCK cells and mouse lungs, and demonstrated greater pathogenicity in mice. In addition, rH20N20 showed higher resistance to innate inhibitors than the other viruses. By using a loss-of-function mutant and receptor-binding assay, we demonstrated that a T133N site directed mutation created an additional N-glycosite at position 133 in rH20N20. Further, this mutation played a crucial role in viral replication and resistance to innate inhibitors by modulating the binding affinities to avian-like and mammalian-like receptors on the host cells and inhibitors. Thus, egg-adapted HA and NA may exacerbate the mammalian pathogenicity of AIVs by defying host innate inhibitors as well as by increasing replication efficiency in mammalian cells.