User-Centred Design

以用户为中心的设计
  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    眼动追踪被认为是医疗保健可用性评估研究的一种有前途的方法,然而,仍然缺乏明确的理论指导和实践。在2019年至2024年期间,对眼动追踪作为数字健康技术可用性评估方法的当前使用进行了快速回顾。当他们描述应用眼动追踪技术的数字健康技术干预措施时,包括了可用性评估研究。为了深入了解眼动追踪技术如何有助于测量数字健康技术的可用性,为了可用性和关键研究结果,我们提取了使用眼动追踪的数据.审查中包括17篇论文。研究结果表明,眼动追踪经常与其他可用性评估方法相结合,具有高度的方法多样性,测试DHT的可用性。当与其他可用性评估方法结合使用时,需要未来的研究来增强对DHT可用性测试中眼动追踪结果的有效性的理解,以便为(可用性)研究人员提供有关其应用的理论指导。
    Eye-tracking is deemed a promising methodology for usability evaluation studies in healthcare, however clear theoretical guidance and practice remains lacking. A rapid review was performed on current use of eye tracking as a usability evaluation method on digital health technologies in the period of 2019 to 2024. Usability evaluation studies were included when they described a digital health technology intervention in which eye-tracking technologies were applied. To gain insight into how eye-tracking technologies contributed to measuring digital health technologies\' usability, data was extracted on the use of eye-tracking for usability and key study findings. Seventeen papers were included in the review. Findings show that eye-tracking is frequently combined with other usability evaluation methods, with high methodological diversity, to test the usability of DHT. Future research is needed to enhance understanding of the effectiveness of eye-tracking outcomes in DHT usability testing when combined with other usability evaluation methods in order to provide (usability) researchers theoretical guidance on its application.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

    求助全文

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    很少听到的群体是指声音经常被边缘化的个人,代表性不足,或者在数字设计过程中没有充分考虑。本案例研究旨在证明采取以用户为中心的设计(UCD)方法来实现威尔士产妇服务的数字解决方案的好处。进行了半结构化访谈,以了解妇女的需求,并从很少听到的群体中分娩。研究见解用于为设计服务模式提供信息,该服务模式可以在每次产妇预约之前和之后提供。研究表明,有机会改善女性和分娩者的体验,并通过创建可靠的,可访问的数字产妇记录,这将使他们能够做出基于证据的决定。通过采取以用户为中心的设计方法,并以面临最大健康差异的人的独特需求为中心,孕产妇服务数字化转型旨在积极影响威尔士妇女和分娩人员的健康和福祉。
    Seldom-heard groups refer to individuals whose voices are often marginalised, underrepresented, or not adequately considered in the digital design process. This case study aims to demonstrate the benefits of taking a user-centred design (UCD) approach to implementing a digital solution for Maternity Services in Wales. Semi-structured interviews were conducted to understand the needs of women and birthing people from seldom-heard groups. The research insights were used to inform the design of a service pattern that could be delivered before and after each maternity appointment. The research shows opportunities to improve the experience for women and birthing people and reduce their anxieties by creating a reliable, accessible digital maternity record that will empower them to make evidence-based decisions. By taking a user-centred design approach and centering the unique needs of those facing the greatest health disparities, Maternity Services\' digital transformation aims to positively impact the health and well-being of women and birthing people in Wales.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

    求助全文

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    电子健康记录系统在促进护理方面的积极转变方面的全部潜力,随着质量和安全的提高,尚未实现。仍然需要重新概念化结构,电子健康记录系统护理组件的内容和用途。这项研究的目的是让不同的利益相关者参与进来,包括护士和电子健康记录系统开发人员,在共同探索更符合实践的问题和可能的新文件方法时,这有助于记录数据的最佳使用。在英国和美国举行了三个焦点小组,使用半结构化面试指南,和一种常见的反身分析方法。研究结果被合成为主题,这些主题被进一步发展为一组开发原则,这些原则可用于为新的电子健康记录系统规范提供信息,以支持护理实践。
    The full potential for electronic health record systems in facilitating a positive transformation in care, with improvements in quality and safety, has yet to be realised. There remains a need to reconceptualise the structure, content and use of the nursing component of electronic health record systems. The aim of this study was to engage and involve a diverse group of stakeholders, including nurses and electronic health record system developers, in exploring together both issues and possible new approaches to documentation that better fit with practice, and that facilitate the optimal use of recorded data. Three focus groups were held in the UK and USA, using a semi-structured interview guide, and a common reflexive approach to analysis. The findings were synthesised into themes that were further developed into a set of development principles that might be used to inform a novel electronic health record system specification to support nursing practice.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

    求助全文

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    背景:不良事件(AE)通常在临床研究中使用医学规范活动词典(MedDRA)报告,药物安全监测的国际标准。然而,MedDRA的技术语言使得患者和临床医生分享理解并因此就医疗干预做出共同决策具有挑战性.在这个项目中,有抑郁症和抗抑郁治疗经验的人与临床医生和研究人员合作,共同设计了与抗抑郁药相关的AEs在线词典,考虑到它的易用性和对现实世界设置的适用性。
    方法:通过预定义的文献检索,我们从抗抑郁药治疗抑郁症的随机对照试验中发现了MedDRA编码的AE.与McPin基金会合作,与现场经验咨询小组(LEAP)和一个独立焦点小组(FG)进行了四个共同设计研讨会,以制作用户友好的AE术语翻译。翻译的指导原则是与McPin/LEAP成员共同设计的,并在临床规范(CC,或非技术术语来代表特定的AE概念)。使用框架方法对FG结果进行主题分析。
    结果:从搜索确定的522项试验开始,736个MedDRA编码的AE术语被翻译成187个CC,哪些平衡了被确定为对LEAP和FG重要的关键因素(即,广度,特异性,概括性,患者的可理解性和可接受性)。与LEAP的合作表明,用户友好的AE语言应旨在减轻污名,承认语言中的多个理解层次,并平衡对语义准确性和用户友好性的需求。在这些原则的指导下,在线AE词典是共同设计并免费提供的(https://thesymptomglossary.com)。LEAP和FG认为数字工具是一种资源,可以通过促进准确,通过共同的决策过程,有意义地表达对潜在危害的偏好。
    结论:这本词典是围绕抑郁症抗抑郁药的AEs用英语开发的,但它可以适应不同的语言和文化背景,也可以成为其他干预措施和疾病的模型(即,精神分裂症中的抗精神病药)。共同设计的数字资源可以通过帮助提供基于证据的潜在益处和危害的个性化信息来改善患者体验,偏好敏感的方式。
    BACKGROUND: Adverse events (AEs) are commonly reported in clinical studies using the Medical Dictionary for Regulatory Activities (MedDRA), an international standard for drug safety monitoring. However, the technical language of MedDRA makes it challenging for patients and clinicians to share understanding and therefore to make shared decisions about medical interventions. In this project, people with lived experience of depression and antidepressant treatment worked with clinicians and researchers to co-design an online dictionary of AEs associated with antidepressants, taking into account its ease of use and applicability to real-world settings.
    METHODS: Through a pre-defined literature search, we identified MedDRA-coded AEs from randomised controlled trials of antidepressants used in the treatment of depression. In collaboration with the McPin Foundation, four co-design workshops with a lived experience advisory panel (LEAP) and one independent focus group (FG) were conducted to produce user-friendly translations of AE terms. Guiding principles for translation were co-designed with McPin/LEAP members and defined before the finalisation of Clinical Codes (CCs, or non-technical terms to represent specific AE concepts). FG results were thematically analysed using the Framework Method.
    RESULTS: Starting from 522 trials identified by the search, 736 MedDRA-coded AE terms were translated into 187 CCs, which balanced key factors identified as important to the LEAP and FG (namely, breadth, specificity, generalisability, patient-understandability and acceptability). Work with the LEAP showed that a user-friendly language of AEs should aim to mitigate stigma, acknowledge the multiple levels of comprehension in \'lay\' language and balance the need for semantic accuracy with user-friendliness. Guided by these principles, an online dictionary of AEs was co-designed and made freely available ( https://thesymptomglossary.com ). The digital tool was perceived by the LEAP and FG as a resource which could feasibly improve antidepressant treatment by facilitating the accurate, meaningful expression of preferences about potential harms through a shared decision-making process.
    CONCLUSIONS: This dictionary was developed in English around AEs from antidepressants in depression but it can be adapted to different languages and cultural contexts, and can also become a model for other interventions and disorders (i.e., antipsychotics in schizophrenia). Co-designed digital resources may improve the patient experience by helping to deliver personalised information on potential benefits and harms in an evidence-based, preference-sensitive way.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    背景:药物遗传学可以通过个性化选择药物来影响患者的护理和结果,从而提高疗效和减少有害的副作用。尽管有令人信服的临床证据和国际指南强调药物遗传学在临床实践中的益处,在英国国家卫生局内的实施是有限的。需要克服的一个重要障碍是开发支持将药物遗传学数据集成到医疗保健系统中的IT解决方案。这需要更好地了解电子健康记录(EHR)的作用以及临床医生可以接受的临床决策支持系统的设计。特别是那些在初级保健。
    目的:从初级保健临床医生的角度探讨药物遗传学服务的需求和要求,以期共同设计原型解决方案。
    方法:我们使用了人种学和大声思考的观察,用户研究研讨会,和原型。这项研究的参与者包括全科医生和药剂师。总的来说,我们进行了5次人种学观察,以了解当前的实践和工作流程。随后是3个用户研究研讨会,每个人都有自己的主题指南,从人物角色和早期想法开始,通过探索临床决策支持系统和原型设计的潜力。随后,我们使用亲和力图表分析了车间数据,并作为多学科项目团队协作完善了解决方案的关键要求。
    结果:用户研究结果表明,必须将药物遗传学数据纳入现有的EHR中,而不是通过独立的门户。通过临床决策支持系统提供的信息必须清晰,可访问,并且用户友好,因为该服务将被一系列最终用户使用。严重的,信息应显示在处方工作流程中,而不是静态存储在EHR中的离散结果。最后,处方建议应具有权威性,以使人们对结果的有效性充满信心。基于这些发现,我们共同设计了一个交互式原型,证明药物遗传学临床决策支持整合在EHR的处方工作流程中。
    结论:这项研究标志着在初级保健机构中设计支持药物遗传学指导处方的系统方面迈出了重要的一步。临床决策支持系统有可能增强药物的个性化,只要它们在EHR中有效实施,并以用户友好的方式呈现药物遗传学数据,可操作,标准化格式。实现这一点需要开发一个解耦的,基于标准的体系结构,允许将数据与应用程序分离,通过使用应用程序编程接口(API)促进跨各种EHR的集成。更全球,这项研究证明了健康信息学和以用户为中心的设计在大规模实现个性化医疗的潜力并确保基因组创新的益处有效地惠及患者和人群方面的作用.
    BACKGROUND: Pharmacogenetics can impact patient care and outcomes through personalizing the selection of medicines, resulting in improved efficacy and a reduction in harmful side effects. Despite the existence of compelling clinical evidence and international guidelines highlighting the benefits of pharmacogenetics in clinical practice, implementation within the National Health Service in the United Kingdom is limited. An important barrier to overcome is the development of IT solutions that support the integration of pharmacogenetic data into health care systems. This necessitates a better understanding of the role of electronic health records (EHRs) and the design of clinical decision support systems that are acceptable to clinicians, particularly those in primary care.
    OBJECTIVE: Explore the needs and requirements of a pharmacogenetic service from the perspective of primary care clinicians with a view to co-design a prototype solution.
    METHODS: We used ethnographic and think-aloud observations, user research workshops, and prototyping. The participants for this study included general practitioners and pharmacists. In total, we undertook 5 sessions of ethnographic observation to understand current practices and workflows. This was followed by 3 user research workshops, each with its own topic guide starting with personas and early ideation, through to exploring the potential of clinical decision support systems and prototype design. We subsequently analyzed workshop data using affinity diagramming and refined the key requirements for the solution collaboratively as a multidisciplinary project team.
    RESULTS: User research results identified that pharmacogenetic data must be incorporated within existing EHRs rather than through a stand-alone portal. The information presented through clinical decision support systems must be clear, accessible, and user-friendly as the service will be used by a range of end users. Critically, the information should be displayed within the prescribing workflow, rather than discrete results stored statically in the EHR. Finally, the prescribing recommendations should be authoritative to provide confidence in the validity of the results. Based on these findings we co-designed an interactive prototype, demonstrating pharmacogenetic clinical decision support integrated within the prescribing workflow of an EHR.
    CONCLUSIONS: This study marks a significant step forward in the design of systems that support pharmacogenetic-guided prescribing in primary care settings. Clinical decision support systems have the potential to enhance the personalization of medicines, provided they are effectively implemented within EHRs and present pharmacogenetic data in a user-friendly, actionable, and standardized format. Achieving this requires the development of a decoupled, standards-based architecture that allows for the separation of data from application, facilitating integration across various EHRs through the use of application programming interfaces (APIs). More globally, this study demonstrates the role of health informatics and user-centered design in realizing the potential of personalized medicine at scale and ensuring that the benefits of genomic innovation reach patients and populations effectively.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    育儿实践对儿童的幸福感有着深远的影响,是几种儿童心理健康心理干预措施的核心目标。然而,到目前为止,HCI对如何设计能够支持亲子社会实践积极转变的社会技术系统的理解有限。本文着重于父母对情感的社会化,以此作为探讨这一问题的范例。我们提出了一个两步研究,将理论驱动的合理设计方向识别与22名6-10岁儿童父母的共同设计研讨会相结合。我们的数据表明,技术驱动系统的潜力,旨在促进亲子社会实践的积极变化,并强调了一些合理的设计方向,以在未来的工作中探索。
    Parenting practices have a profound effect on children\'s well-being and are a core target of several psychological interventions for child mental health. However, there is only limited understanding in HCI so far about how to design socio-technical systems that could support positive shifts in parent-child social practices in situ. This paper focuses on parental socialisation of emotion as an exemplar context in which to explore this question. We present a two-step study, combining theory-driven identification of plausible design directions with co-design workshops with 22 parents of children aged 6-10 years. Our data suggest the potential for technology-enabled systems that aim to facilitate positive changes in parent-child social practices in situ, and highlight a number of plausible design directions to explore in future work.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    本报告总结了SMARTCLAP研究项目,它采用以用户为中心的设计方法来开发革命性的智能产品服务系统。该系统提供个性化的动机,以鼓励脑瘫儿童在职业治疗期间积极参与更多,同时为儿科职业治疗师提供最佳工具来监测儿童从一个疗程到另一个疗程的进展。开发的产品服务系统包括一个名为DigiClap的智能可穿戴设备,用于在增强现实环境中与严肃的游戏进行交互。该报告强调了用于将技术准备水平从4提高到6的研究方法,并承认了财团团队和资金来源的贡献。作为技术成熟过程的一部分,与目标用户一起评估了DigiClap和各自的严肃游戏,为了确定系统在支持儿童整体参与和手功能方面的影响,并收集职业治疗师和护理人员对这项新技术的反馈。讨论了这项研究的结果,强调局限性和经验教训。该报告还概述了未来的工作和进一步的资金,以实现该项目的可持续性,并覆盖其他有上肢限制的个人。最终,讨论了DigiClap的潜力和该项目的总体成就。
    This report summarises the SMARTCLAP research project, which employs a user-centred design approach to develop a revolutionary smart product service system. The system offers personalised motivation to encourage children with cerebral palsy to actively participate more during their occupational therapy sessions, while providing paediatric occupational therapists with an optimal tool to monitor children\'s progress from one session to another. The product service system developed includes of a smart wearable device called DigiClap used to interact with a serious game in an Augmented Reality environment. The report highlights the research methodology used to advance the technology readiness level from 4 to 6, acknowledging the contribution of the consortium team and funding source. As part of the technology\'s maturity process, DigiClap and the respective serious game were evaluated with target users, to identify the system\'s impact in supporting the children\'s overall participation and hand function, and to gather feedback from occupational therapists and caregivers on this novel technology. The outcomes of this study are discussed, highlighting limitations and lessons learned. The report also outlines future work and further funding for the sustainability of the project and to reach other individuals who have upper limb limitations. Ultimately, the potential of DigiClap and the overall achievements of this project are discussed.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    背景:抗菌素耐药性的威胁引发了爱尔兰农场对抗菌素使用行为的改变。新出台的兽药法规要求在动物卫生部门限制和更谨慎地使用抗微生物剂。减少抗菌药物的需要更加强调动物健康试验的重要性,然而,当前测试实践的问题正在影响诊断和随后的药物使用。数字技术有可能解决这些问题并减少农场的抗菌药物使用,然而,为了使这些工具成功,它们需要与未来的最终用户合作开发。
    结果:使用定性方法(焦点小组),这项研究与奶农和农场兽医从业者进行合作,详细说明当前动物健康诊断面临的挑战,并探索快速,农场动物健康测试工具来应对这些挑战。时间和测试的问题,知识和经验的作用,和兽医的可用性都会影响农民和兽医诊断农场动物健康问题的能力。这些问题具有负面影响,包括增加和不必要地使用抗微生物剂。农场测试工具将通过允许兽医实现快速诊断来帮助减轻这些影响,促进动物疾病的及时和有针对性的治疗,帮助减少农场整体抗菌药物的使用。然而,与最终用户的互动强调,如果这样的工具没有正确开发,它可能会产生意想不到的负面后果,例如误诊,增加抗菌药物的使用,对农民和兽医关系的挑战,数据滥用。本研究概述了最终用户对测试工具的初始需求和要求,但建议为了成功设计和开发该工具,应应用设计思维等共同设计方法;减轻未来的负面影响,并确保像这样的测试工具专门设计用于满足爱尔兰奶农和农场兽医的价值观和需求,确保负责任和成功的吸收和使用。
    结论:数字工具可以有效减少农场的抗菌药物使用,然而,为了成功,这些工具应该以用户为中心的方式设计。
    BACKGROUND: The threat of antimicrobial resistance is triggering the need for behavioural change towards antimicrobial use on Irish farms. Newly introduced veterinary medicine regulations are mandating the restricted and more prudent use of antimicrobials in the animal health sector. The need to reduce antimicrobials has placed a greater emphasis on the importance of animal health testing, however, issues with current testing practices are affecting diagnosis and subsequent drug usage. There is potential for digital technologies to address these issues and reduce antimicrobial use on farms, however, for these tools to be successful, they would need to be developed in collaboration with future end users.
    RESULTS: Using qualitative approaches (focus groups), this study engages with dairy farmers and farm veterinary practitioners to detail current challenges with animal health diagnosis and to explore the initial development of a rapid, on-farm animal health testing tool to address these challenges. Issues with timing and testing, the role of knowledge and experience, and veterinarian availability all affect the ability of farmers and veterinarians to diagnose animal health issues on farm. These issues are having negative implications including the increased and unnecessary use of antimicrobials. An on-farm testing tool would help mitigate these effects by allowing veterinarians to achieve rapid diagnosis, facilitating the timely and targeted treatment of animal illnesses, helping to reduce overall antimicrobial use on farms. However, engagement with end users has highlighted that if a tool like this is not developed correctly, it could have unintended negative consequences such as misdiagnosis, increased antimicrobial use, challenges to farmer-veterinarian relationships, and data misuse. This study outlines initial end user needs and requirements for a testing tool but suggests that in order to successfully design and develop this tool, co-design approaches such as Design Thinking should be applied; to mitigate future negative impacts, and to ensure a testing tool like this is designed specifically to address Irish dairy farmers and farm veterinarians\' values and needs, ensuring responsible and successful uptake and use.
    CONCLUSIONS: Digital tools can be effective in reducing antimicrobial use on farms, however, to be successful, these tools should be designed in a user centred way.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    口咽吞咽困难,或开始吞咽困难,是帕金森病(PD)患者的常见问题,可导致吸入性肺炎。药理学选择的功效是有限的。姿势策略,比如喝酒时的下巴动作,已经取得了一定程度的成功,但对于患有痴呆症或颈部僵硬等其他局限性的人来说可能很难,持续繁殖。使用以用户为中心的设计方法和多学科团队,我们为PD患者开发并测试了一种防窒息杯,该杯子有助于将头部倾斜在最佳饮酒位置。该设计反映了用户需求的人体测量和人体工程学方面,其功能包括调节水流量和sip体积,一个内部斜坡,加厚的手柄和宽的底座,使用时促进了下巴向下的姿势。使用数字技术进行原型测试,以比较颈部屈曲角度(主要结果),加上使用标准工具评估的临床结果(帕金森病吞咽临床评估评分(SCAS-PD)和运动障碍协会-帕金森病统一评定量表(MDS-UPDRS)第二部分和第三部分),发现与使用防窒息杯和假杯子相比,与有效吞咽和安全饮用相关的一系列参数显着改善。
    Oropharyngeal dysphagia, or difficulty initiating swallowing, is a frequent problem in people with Parkinson\'s disease (PD) and can lead to aspiration pneumonia. The efficacy of pharmacological options is limited. Postural strategies, such as a chin-down manoeuvre when drinking, have had some degree of success but may be difficult for people who have other limitations such as dementia or neck rigidity, to reproduce consistently. Using a user-centred design approach and a multidisciplinary team, we developed and tested an anti-choking mug for people with PD that helps angle the head in the optimum position for drinking. The design reflected anthropometric and ergonomic aspects of user needs with features including regulation of water flow rate and sip volume, an inner slope, a thickened handle and a wide base, which promoted a chin-down posture when used. Prototype testing using digital technology to compare neck flexion angles (the primary outcome), plus clinical outcomes assessed using standard tools (Swallowing Clinical Assessment Score in Parkinson\'s Disease (SCAS-PD) and Movement Disorder Society-Unified Parkinson\'s Disease Rating Scale (MDS-UPDRS) Parts II and III), found significant improvements in a range of parameters related to efficient swallowing and safe drinking when using the anti-choking mug versus a sham mug.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Evaluation Study
    目的:为了评估和改进MATCH-IT-数字,交互式决策支持工具显示用于多重比较的结构化证据摘要-以帮助医师解释和应用来自网络荟萃分析(NMA)的证据用于其临床决策.
    方法:我们进行了一项定性的用户测试研究,在迭代开发过程中应用以用户为中心的设计原则。我们在挪威招募了一个方便的执业医生样本,比利时和加拿大,并要求他们解释MATCH-IT中显示的用于多重比较的结构化证据摘要-与临床指南建议相关。用户测试包括(A)介绍临床场景,(b)与参与者工具互动的大声思考会议和(c)半结构化访谈。我们录制了视频,转录,并使用定向内容分析分析用户测试。结果为MATCH-IT提供了新的更新。
    结果:分布在五个开发周期中,我们与26名医生一起测试了MATCH-IT。其中,24(94%)报告没有或很少有NMA解释的经验。医生认为MATCH-IT很容易解释,导航并赞赏其提供证据概述的能力。象形图效果的可视化和治疗负担的信息(“实际问题”)被强调为与患者互动的潜在有用特征。我们还发现了问题,包括未发现的功能(拖放),次优教程,和繁琐的导航工具。此外,医生希望定义/解释关键术语(例如,结果和“确定性”),并且有人担心来自大型NMA的压倒性证据会使临床实践的适用性复杂化。这导致了一些更新,开发新的起始页,教程,更新的用户界面,以更有效地操纵,显示关键术语定义和FAQ部分的解决方案。为了便于解释大型网络,我们使用颜色编码和增加过滤功能改进了结果分类.这些修改使医生能够专注于感兴趣的干预措施并减少信息过载。
    结论:这项研究提供了医生可以使用MATCH-IT来理解NMA证据的概念证明。MATCH-IT在临床背景下的主要特征包括提供证据的概述,效果的可视化和治疗负担信息的显示。然而,不熟悉等级概念,时间限制和护理点的可及性可能是使用的挑战。我们的结果在多大程度上可以转移到现实世界的临床环境中还有待探索。
    OBJECTIVE: To evaluate and improve \"Making Alternative Treatment Choices Intuitive and Trustworthy\" (MATCH-IT)-a digital, interactive decision support tool displaying structured evidence summaries for multiple comparisons-to help physicians interpret and apply evidence from network meta-analysis (NMA) for their clinical decision-making.
    METHODS: We conducted a qualitative user testing study, applying principles from user-centered design in an iterative development process. We recruited a convenience sample of practicing physicians in Norway, Belgium, and Canada, and asked them to interpret structured evidence summaries for multiple comparisons-linked to clinical guideline recommendations-displayed in MATCH-IT. User testing included (a) introduction of a clinical scenario, (b) a think-aloud session with participant-tool interaction, and (c) a semistructured interview. We video recorded, transcribed, and analyzed user tests using directed content analysis. The results informed new updates in MATCH-IT.
    RESULTS: Distributed across 5 development cycles we tested MATCH-IT with 26 physicians. Of these, 24 (94%) reported either no or sparse prior experience with interpretation of NMA. Physicians perceived MATCH-IT as easy to interpret and navigate, and appreciated its ability to provide an overview of the evidence. Visualization of effects in pictograms and inclusion of information on burden of treatment (\"practical issues\") were highlighted as potentially useful features in interacting with patients. We also identified problems, including undiscovered functionalities (drag and drop), suboptimal tutorial, and cumbersome navigation of the tool. In addition, physicians wanted definition/explanation of key terms (eg, outcomes and \"certainty\"), and there were concerns that overwhelming evidence from a large NMA would complicate applicability to clinical practice. This led to several updates with development of a new start page, tutorial, updated user interface for more efficient maneuvering, solutions to display definition of key terms and a \"frequently asked questions\" section. To facilitate interpretation of large networks, we improved categorization of results using color coding and added filtering functionality. These modifications allowed physicians to focus on interventions of interest and reduce information overload.
    CONCLUSIONS: This study provides proof of concept that physicians can use MATCH-IT to understand NMA evidence. Key features of MATCH-IT in a clinical context include providing an overview of the evidence, visualization of effects, and the display of information on burden of treatments. However, unfamiliarity with the Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation concepts, time constraints, and accessibility at the point of care may be challenges for use. To what extent our results are transferable to real-world clinical contexts remains to be explored.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

    求助全文

公众号