Unfit to stand Trial

不适合受审
  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    背景:在加拿大,确保公共安全,省审查委员会管辖下的被告的安全和福祉非常重要。虽然先前的研究报告了在法医精神病学环境中自我伤害行为(非自杀性自我伤害和自杀未遂)的重大风险,没有大规模人群研究评估法医系统相关因素与自残行为之间的任何关系.更好地了解这些因素可以帮助临床医生实施保护措施,以减轻自我伤害的行为或行动。
    方法:使用安大略省审查委员会(ORB)数据库涵盖2014-2015年期间(n=1211,平均年龄=42.5±13.37岁,男性=86.1%),我们分析了与自我伤害行为相关的患病率和因素,强调法医系统相关因素的表征(ORB状态,法律地位,类型的进攻,以前的犯罪史,和受害者关系)。使用五个独立的逻辑回归模型探讨了法医系统相关因素与自残行为之间的关系,控制临床和社会人口统计学特征。
    结果:在研究期间,法医系统中约有4%的人从事自我伤害行为。被确定为不适合接受试验的个体和住院患者更有可能出现自残行为.犯罪类型之间没有重大关系,受害者关系,和以前有自残行为的犯罪史。
    结论:法医精神科住院患者应密切观察,筛选,监测,以及针对自我伤害行为的个性化管理策略。这项研究的结果表明,法医系统相关因素,尤其是那些与法医系统中个人地位有关的人(即,不适合受审和住院)对安大略省法医患者的自残行为负有更大的责任。
    In Canada, ensuring public safety, and the safety and well-being of accused individuals under the jurisdiction of the provincial review board are very important. While previous studies have reported a significant risk of self-harming behaviors (non-suicidal self-injury and suicide attempt) in forensic psychiatric settings, no large population study has assessed any relationship between forensic system-related factors and self-harming behaviors. A better understanding of these factors can help clinicians implement protective measures to mitigate self-harming behaviors or actions.
    Using the Ontario Review Board (ORB) database covering 2014-2015 period (n = 1211, mean age = 42.5 ± 13.37 years, males = 86.1%), we analyzed the prevalence and factors associated with self-harming behaviors, emphasizing the characterization of the forensic system-related factors (ORB status, legal status, type of offense, previous criminal history, and victim relationship). The relationships between the forensic system-related factors and self-harming behaviors were explored using five separate logistic regression models, controlling for clinical and sociodemographic characteristics.
    Approximately 4% of the individuals in the forensic system over the study period engaged in self-harming behaviors Among the studied patients, individuals determined to be unfit to stand trial and inpatients were significantly more likely to have self-harming behaviors. There was no significant relationship between the type of offence, victim relationship, and previous criminal history with self-harming behavior.
    Forensic psychiatry inpatients should have close observation, screening, monitoring, and individual tailored management strategies for self-harming behaviors. The findings of this study indicate that forensic system-related factors, especially those that pertain to the status of individuals in the forensic system (i.e., unfit to stand trial and being an inpatient) are more responsible for self-harming behaviors among forensic patients in Ontario.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    澳大利亚刑法假定被告适合接受审判,直到在概率平衡上得到证明。法医心理健康专家经常向法院提供关于被告健康的意见,这要求他们了解法院决定被告的健康状态的法律背景。本文概述了澳大利亚健康状况评估的重要判例法考虑因素,包括当存在“真实和实质性的问题”时必须评估健康状况的概念,评估应该是“合理和常识”,当容量明显受损时,应该考虑调整。妄想的影响基本上可以忽略不计,无益的辩护,还考虑了无法控制的行为和不良的被告-律师关系。最后,审查了在新西兰和其他太平洋司法管辖区使用Presser标准的先例。
    Australian criminal law presumes that defendants are fit to stand trial until proven otherwise on the balance of probabilities. Forensic mental health experts often provide opinions to the court about defendants\' fitness, which requires them to understand the legal context within which the court decides the defendant\'s fitness status. This article outlines important case law considerations to the assessment of fitness in Australia, including the notions that fitness must be evaluated when there is a \'real and substantial question\', assessments should be \'reasonable and common sense\' and accommodations should be considered when impairments in capacity are evident. The essentially negligible impact of delusions, an unhelpful defence, unmanageable behaviour and poor defendant-lawyer relationship are also considered. Finally, precedent is reviewed for the use of the Presser standards in New Zealand and other pacific jurisdictions.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    关于努纳武特法医精神病患者的研究很少,包括没有发表的有关该地区患者患病率和特征的数据。缺乏基本信息阻碍了对服务的评估和建立最佳做法。本文旨在描述努纳武特地区的法医精神病学患者的特征,并进一步了解在努纳武特地区组织法医精神病学医疗保健方面的挑战。回顾性图表审查设计用于检查来自Nunavut的参与安大略省法医精神病学系统的个人。样本包括Nunavut审查委员会在一年内管辖的所有不适合接受审判(26.7%)和无刑事责任(73.3%)的患者(N=15)。患者在努纳武特的居住地与安大略省设施之间的平均距离为2,517公里。总的来说,26.7%的人居住在努纳武特,60.0%留在安大略省,13.3%居住在艾伯塔省。结果是针对社会人口统计学,法医状态,个人和家族史,精神病和犯罪史,诊断,指数进攻特征,治疗,评估工具,和侵略。来自努纳武特地区的法医精神病学患者的患病率和许多特征与加拿大其他地区不同,对提供服务具有重要意义。
    There is a paucity of research on forensic psychiatry patients from Nunavut, including no published data concerning the prevalence and characterisation of patients in this territory. The lack of basic information hinders the evaluation of services and establishing best practices. The current paper aims to characterise forensic psychiatry patients from Nunavut and further the understanding of the challenges in organising forensic psychiatry healthcare in Nunavut. A retrospective chart review design was used to examine individuals from Nunavut who are engaged with the Ontario forensic psychiatry system. The sample included all Unfit to Stand Trial (26.7%) and Not Criminally Responsible (73.3%) patients (N = 15) under the jurisdiction of the Nunavut Review Board in a one-year period. The average distance between the patient\'s place of residence in Nunavut and the Ontario facilities was 2,517 km. Overall, 26.7% were living in Nunavut, 60.0% remained in Ontario, and 13.3% resided in Alberta. Results are presented for sociodemographics, forensic status, personal and familial history, psychiatric and criminal history, diagnoses, index offence characteristics, treatment, assessment tools, and aggression. The prevalence and many characteristics of forensic psychiatry patients from Nunavut differ from the rest of Canada and have important implications for the delivery of services.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Sci-hub)

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    这项研究的目的是通过提供安大略省法医精神卫生系统的基于人群的概述来增加对加拿大法医精神病学系统的了解。
    收集了2014年至2015年间受安大略省审查委员会(ORB)管辖的1,240名被告成年人的数据。档案数据是从每年的ORB听证会医院报告中检索的,这些报告由安大略省所有9个成人法医精神病学机构监督。
    样本包括不承担刑事责任(NCR;91.6%)和不适合受审(UST;8.4%)。大多数样本是男性(85.7%),单(70.1%),失业者(63.6%),高中学历(48.8%)。报告时,大多数人被拘留(78.5%),几乎一半人居住在社区(48.8%)。大多数人在进入法医系统之前曾与精神病服务部门(83.1%)和/或刑事司法系统(70.6%)有过接触。私奔史(31.5%)和住院侵略史很高(60.6%)。在报告年度,大多数人患有精神病谱系障碍(81.6%),超过一半的人患有药物使用障碍(57.2%)。观察到一系列指数犯罪(69.9%暴力,一般20.3%,9.8%性),大多数样本(61.0%)的指数犯罪没有导致受害者受伤或受到轻伤。
    加拿大法医精神病学系统由一个独特的涉及司法的个体子集组成。这项研究提供了对受ORB管辖的被告的详细检查,并提供了对该人群中与犯罪行为相关的风险因素的关键见解。这项研究的结果将为将来的研究提供一个框架,以检查精神障碍与暴力之间的关联以及法医精神病学系统中那些人的治疗轨迹。
    The purpose of this study was to increase the understanding of the Canadian forensic psychiatry system by providing a population-based overview of the Ontario forensic mental health system.
    Data were collected on 1,240 accused adults who were subject to the jurisdiction of the Ontario Review Board (ORB) between 2014 and 2015. Archival data were retrieved from annual ORB hearing hospital reports for accused supervised by all nine adult forensic psychiatry facilities across Ontario.
    The sample included not criminally responsible (NCR; 91.6%) and unfit to stand trial (UST; 8.4%) accused. The majority of the sample was male (85.7%), single (70.1%), unemployed (63.6%), with a high school education (48.8%). Most were on a detention order (78.5%) and almost half were living in the community at the time of the report (48.8%). The majority had prior contact with psychiatric services (83.1%) and/or the criminal justice system (70.6%) before entering the forensic system. A history of elopement (31.5%) and inpatient aggression was high (60.6%). Most had a psychotic spectrum disorder (81.6%) and over half had a substance use disorder (57.2%) in the reporting year. A range of index offences was observed (69.9% violent, 20.3% general, 9.8% sexual), and the majority of the sample (61.0%) had an index offence that resulted in no injury or a minor injury to the victim.
    The Canadian forensic psychiatry system is comprised of a unique subset of justice-involved individuals. This study provides a detailed examination of accused who are subject to the jurisdiction of the ORB and provides key insight into risk factors associated with offending behaviour in this population. The results of this study will provide a framework for future studies examining the association between mental disorder and violence and the treatment trajectories for those in the forensic psychiatry system.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Sci-hub)

       PDF(Pubmed)

公众号