SWAT

特警
  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    全球变暖正在深刻影响季节性冻融区的融雪径流过程,从而改变雨雪(ROS)洪水的风险。这些变化不仅影响洪水的发生频率,而且改变了水资源的配置,这对农业和其他关键经济部门都有影响。虽然这些风险对我们的生活和经济构成重大威胁,气候变化引发的ROS洪水风险尚未得到应有的重视。因此,我们选择了长白山,高纬度寒冷地区的水塔,作为一个典型的研究领域。半分布式水文模型SWAT与CMIP6气象数据耦合,并在偏差校正后选择四个共享的社会经济途径(SSP126、SSP245、SSP370和SSP585),从而量化气候变化对长白山地区水文过程的影响以及ROS洪水风险的未来演变。结果表明:(1)在未来气候变化情景下,长白山大部分地区的融雪减少。SSP126,SSP245,SSP370和SSP585下的年平均融雪量预计为148.65毫米,135.63毫米,123.44mm,和116.5毫米,分别。预计融雪的开始将在未来推进。具体来说,在松花江(SR)和鸭绿江(YR)地区,融雪的开始预计将提前1-11天。空间上,在SSP585情景下,流域中部和河流下游的融雪量均显着减少。(2)2021-2060年,不同场景下ROS洪泛频率依次下降,SSP126>SSP245>SSP370>SSP585。四种情况下,源区ROS洪水的频率增量为0.12天/年,0.1d/yr,0.13天/年,和0.15天/年,分别。在低排放情景下,YR中高海拔ROS事件的频率增加。相反,在高排放场景中,YR高海拔ROS事件只会在2061-2100年增加。这种现象在图们江(TR)更为明显,随着海拔的增加,洪水变得更加频繁。
    Global warming is profoundly impacting snowmelt runoff processes in seasonal freeze-thaw zones, thereby altering the risk of rain-on-snow (ROS) floods. These changes not only affect the frequency of floods but also alter the allocation of water resources, which has implications for agriculture and other key economic sectors. While these risks present a significant threat to our lives and economies, the risk of ROS floods triggered by climate change has not received the attention it deserves. Therefore, we chose Changbai Mountain, a water tower in a high-latitude cold zone, as a typical study area. The semi-distributed hydrological model SWAT is coupled with CMIP6 meteorological data, and four shared socioeconomic pathways (SSP126, SSP245, SSP370, and SSP585) are selected after bias correction, thus quantifying the impacts of climate change on hydrological processes in the Changbai Mountain region as well as future evolution of the ROS flood risk. The results indicate that: (1) Under future climate change scenarios, snowmelt in most areas of the Changbai Mountains decreases. The annual average snowmelt under SSP126, SSP245, SSP370, and SSP585 is projected to be 148.65 mm, 135.63 mm, 123.44 mm, and 116.5 mm, respectively. The onset of snowmelt is projected to advance in the future. Specifically, in the Songhua River (SR) and Yalu River (YR) regions, the start of snowmelt is expected to advance by 1-11 days. Spatially, significant reductions in snowmelt were observed in both the central part of the watershed and the lower reaches of the river under SSP585 scenario. (2) In 2021-2060, the frequency of ROS floods decreases sequentially for different scenarios, with SSP 126 > SSP 245 > SSP 370 > SSP 585. The frequency increments of ROS floods in the source area for the four scenarios were 0.12 days/year, 0.1 d/yr, 0.13 days/year, and 0.15 days/year, respectively. The frequency of high-elevation ROS events increases in the YR in the low emission scenario. Conversely, in high emission scenarios, YR high-elevation ROS events will only increase in 2061-2100. This phenomenon is more pronounced in the Tumen River (TR), where floods become more frequent with increasing elevation.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

    求助全文

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    这项研究的目的是通过考虑时间序列分析的SWAT和HEC-RAS关联模拟来模拟水动力和水质因素,从而评估鱼类栖息地的适宜性。选择了2.9公里的Bokha溪流进行Zaccoplatypus的栖息地评估,使用SWAT和HEC-RAS链接方法进行的水动力和水质模拟。根据模拟的10年数据,使用加权可用面积(WUA)评估水生生境,通过连续高于阈值(CAT)分析,提出了最小生态流量。高水温被确定为最具影响力的栖息地指标,在炎热的夏季,其影响在浅水流地区尤为明显。时间序列分析确定了WUA/WUAmax的28%阈值,相当于0.48m3/s的流量,作为缓解水温上升影响所需的最小生态流量。提出的生境建模方法,连接流域-河流模型,可以作为生态流管理的有用工具。
    The objective of this study was to evaluate fish habitat suitability by simulating hydrodynamic and water quality factors using SWAT and HEC-RAS linked simulation considering time-series analysis. A 2.9 km reach of the Bokha stream was selected for the habitat evaluation of Zacco platypus, with hydrodynamic and water quality simulations performed using the SWAT and HEC-RAS linked approach. Based on simulated 10-year data, the aquatic habitat was assessed using the weighted usable area (WUA), and minimum ecological streamflow was proposed from continuous above threshold (CAT) analysis. High water temperature was identified as the most influential habitat indicator, with its impact being particularly pronounced in shallow streamflow areas during hot summer seasons. The time-series analysis identified a 28% threshold of WUA/WUAmax, equivalent to a streamflow of 0.48 m3/s, as the minimum ecological streamflow necessary to mitigate the impact of rising water temperatures. The proposed habitat modeling method, linking watershed-stream models, could serve as a useful tool for ecological stream management.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    目前,从河流到海洋的污染通量是近岸地区污染物的主要来源。基于流域-河口-沿海水域系统的源-汇过程,估计了入海的污染通量及其时空异质性。建立了基于深度学习的模型,以简化入海污染通量的估计,以社会经济驱动因素和气象数据为输入变量。提出了一种估算不同空间梯度污染通量贡献率的方法。研究发现:(1)1980、1990、2000、2010和2020年环渤海地区总氮(TN)和总磷(TP)入海污染通量分别为25.38×104、26.12×104、27.27×104、29.82×104、25.31×104和1.32×104、2.14×104、2.09×104、1.87×104、1.68×104吨,分别。(2)农村生畜占TN的比例最高,占39.18%和21.19%,分别。家畜占TP的比例最高,占39.20%,其次是农村生活,占24.72%。结果表明,BSRB中的污染通量与人类经济活动和相关的环境保护措施有关。(3)建立的基于深度学习的入海径流污染通量估算模型的准确率超过90%。(4)至于缴费率,在海拔方面,0-100米的范围比例最高,占39.65%。距海岸线50-100公里的范围所占比例最高,占18.11%。就地区而言,沿海地区所占比例最高,占38.00%。这项研究揭示了过去40年污染通量入海的变化趋势和驱动机制,并建立了一个简化的基于深度学习的模型来估算入海污染通量。然后,我们确定了高污染贡献率的地区。研究结果可为基于生态系统的近岸地区适应性管理提供科学依据。
    Pollution fluxes from rivers into the sea are currently the main source of pollutants in nearshore areas. Based on the source-sink process of the basin-estuary-coastal waters system, the pollution fluxes into the sea and their spatiotemporal heterogeneity were estimated. A deep learning-based model was established to simplify the estimation of pollution fluxes into the sea, with socio-economic drivers and meteorological data as input variables. A method for estimating the contribution rate of pollution fluxes from different spatial gradient was proposed. In this study, we found that (1) the pollution fluxes into the sea of total nitrogen (TN) and total phosphorus (TP) from the Bohai Sea Rim Basin (BSRB) in 1980, 1990, 2000, 2010, and 2020 were 25.38 × 104, 26.12 × 104, 27.27 × 104, 29.82 × 104, 25.31 × 104 and 1.32 × 104, 2.14 × 104, 2.09 × 104, 1.87 × 104, 1.68 × 104 tons, respectively. (2) The proportion of rural life and livestock to the TN was the highest, accounting for 39.18 % and 21.19 %, respectively. The proportion of livestock to the TP was the highest, accounting for 39.20 %, followed by rural life, accounting for 24.72 %. The results indicated that the pollution fluxes in the BSRB were related to human economic activities and relevant environmental protection measures. (3) The deep learning-based model established to estimate runoff pollution fluxes into the sea had the accuracy of over 90 %. (4) As for contribution rate, in terms of the elevation, the range of 0-100 m had the highest proportion, accounting for 39.65 %. The range of 50-100 km from the coastline had the highest proportion, accounting for 18.11 %. In terms of the district, coastal area has the highest proportion, accounting for 38.00 %. This study revealed the changing trends and driving mechanisms of pollution fluxes into the sea over the past 40 years and established a simplified deep learning-based model for estimating pollution fluxes into the sea. Then, we identified regions with high pollution contribution rate. The results can provide scientific references for the adaptive management of the nearshore areas based on the ecosystem.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

    求助全文

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    人类活动不断影响流域的水分平衡和循环,准确识别径流对土地利用类型动态变化的响应至关重要。尽管机器学习模型在捕捉水文因素之间复杂的相互作用方面表现出了希望,他们的“黑匣子”性质使得识别径流的动态驱动因素具有挑战性。为了克服这一挑战,我们采用了一种可解释的机器学习方法来反向推导水文过程中的动态决定因素。在这项研究中,我们分析了黄河中游宁夏段四个时期的土地利用变化,为揭示这些变化如何影响径流奠定基础。利用水土评估工具(SWAT)模型生成的子流域属性和气象特征作为极端梯度提升(XGBoost)模型的输入变量,模拟区域内大量子流域降雨径流。XGBoost是使用SHapley加法扩张(SHAP)进行解释的,以确定径流对不同时期土地利用变化的动态响应。结果表明,研究区土地利用类型之间的互换日益频繁。XGBoost有效地捕获了SWAT衍生的子流域中水文过程的特征。SHAP分析结果表明,农业用地(AGRL)对径流的促进作用逐渐减弱,而森林(FRST)对径流的抑制作用不断加强。相关土地利用政策为这些发现提供了经验支持。此外,气象变量与土地利用之间的相互作用会影响径流产生机制,并表现出阈值效应,与相对湿度(RH)的阈值,最高温度(MaxT),和最低温度(Mint)确定为0.8,25°C,15°C,分别。这种反推方法可以揭示水文模式和变量之间的相互作用机制,帮助有效应对不断变化的人类活动和气象条件。
    Human activities continuously impact water balances and cycling in watersheds, making it essential to accurately identify the responses of runoff to dynamic changes in land use types. Although machine learning models demonstrate promise in capturing the intricate interplay between hydrological factors, their \"black box\" nature makes it challenging to identify the dynamic drivers of runoff. To overcome this challenge, we employed an interpretable machine learning method to inversely deduce the dynamic determinants within hydrological processes. In this study, we analyzed land use changes in the Ningxia section of the middle Yellow River across four periods, laying the foundation for revealing how these changes affect runoff. The sub-watershed attributes and meteorological characteristics generated by the Soil and Water Assessment Tool (SWAT) model were used as input variables of the Extreme Gradient Boosting (XGBoost) model to simulate substantial sub-watershed rainfall runoff in the region. The XGBoost was interpreted using the SHapley Additive exPlanations (SHAP) to identify the dynamic responses of runoff to the land use changes over different periods. The results revealed increasingly frequent interchanges between the land use types in the study area. The XGBoost effectively captured the characteristics of the hydrological processes in the SWAT-derived sub-watersheds. The SHAP analysis results demonstrated that the promoting effect of agricultural land (AGRL) on runoff gradually weakens, while forests (FRST) continuously strengthen their restraining effect on runoff. Relevant land use policies provide empirical support for these findings. Furthermore, the interaction between meteorological variables and land use impacts the runoff generation mechanism and exhibits a threshold effect, with the thresholds for relative humidity (RH), maximum temperature (MaxT), and minimum temperature (MinT) determined to be 0.8, 25 °C, and 15 °C, respectively. This reverse deduction method can reveal hydrological patterns and the mechanisms of interaction between variables, helping to effectively addressing constantly changing human activities and meteorological conditions.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

    求助全文

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    由于环境因素之间复杂的相互作用,了解水文过程需要使用建模技术。估算模型参数仍然是未测量流域径流建模的重大挑战。这项研究评估了土壤和水评估工具模拟ThaChin河流域水文行为的能力,重点是通过对流域水文参数的区域化进行径流预测,MaeKhlong河流域。利用1993年至2017年MaeKhlong河流域的历史数据进行校准,随后使用2018年至2022年的数据进行验证。•校准结果表明SWAT模型的合理准确性,R²=0.85,验证R²为0.64,表明观测径流与模拟径流之间的匹配令人满意。•利用机器学习(ML)技术进行参数区域化,揭示了模型性能的细微差别。随机森林(RF)模型表现出0.60的R²,人工神经网络(ANN)模型在RF上略有改进,显示0.61的R²,而支持向量机(SVM)模型显示出最高的整体性能,R²为0.63。•这项研究强调了SWAT和ML技术在预测未测量集水区径流方面的有效性,强调其提高水文建模精度的潜力。未来的研究应集中在将这些方法集成到各个盆地中,并改善数据收集以提高模型性能。
    Understanding hydrological processes necessitates the use of modeling techniques due to the intricate interactions among environmental factors. Estimating model parameters remains a significant challenge in runoff modeling for ungauged catchments. This research evaluates the Soil and Water Assessment Tool\'s capacity to simulate hydrological behaviors in the Tha Chin River Basin with an emphasis on runoff predictions from the regionalization of hydrological parameters of the gauged basin, Mae Khlong River Basin. Historical data of Mae Khlong River Basin from 1993 to 2017 were utilized for calibration, followed by validation using data from 2018 to 2022. •Calibration results showed the SWAT model\'s reasonable accuracy, with R² = 0.85, and the validation with R² of 0.64, indicating a satisfactory match between observed and simulated runoff.•Utilizing Machine Learning (ML) techniques for parameter regionalization revealed nuanced differences in model performance. The Random Forest (RF) model exhibited an R² of 0.60 and the Artificial Neural Networks (ANN) model slightly improved upon RF, showing an R² of 0.61 while the Support Vector Machine (SVM) model demonstrated the highest overall performance, with an R² of 0.63.•This study highlights the effectiveness of the SWAT and ML techniques in predicting runoff for ungauged catchments, emphasizing their potential to enhance hydrological modeling accuracy. Future research should focus on integrating these methodologies in various basins and improving data collection for better model performance.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    城市地区不透水表面的扩大导致随着地表径流排放到接收器的养分负荷增加。使用SWAT(土壤和水评估工具)模型,研究了不同密度的城市发展对卢布林市(波兰东部)总氮(TN)和磷(TP)负荷的影响。为了区分城市发展密度高和低密度的地区(UHD和ULD),提出了对水文参数的特殊分析。此外,调查气候变化的影响,考虑了四种不同的情况,结合RCP(代表性浓度途径)4.5和8.5预测以及采用的时间范围(2026-2035和2046-2055)。结果表明,与ULD相比,UHD的TN和TP的份额要高得多(86%-32022公斤/年和89%-2574公斤/年,分别)。此外,不同的情景表明,预测的降水和温度的增加将导致UHD和ULD的养分负荷增加30%。此外,目前居民人数的增加,由于乌克兰战争移民和将农业用地转换为居民区的普遍趋势,可能有助于UHD和ULD区域的进一步扩大和营养负荷的额外增加。
    An expansion of impervious surfaces in urban areas leads to increases of nutrient loads discharged with the surface runoff to receivers. A study of a different density of urban development impact on total nitrogen (TN) and phosphorus (TP) loads from the city of Lublin (eastern Poland) with the use of the SWAT (Soil & Water Assessment Tool) model was performed. To distinguish between areas with high and low density of urban development (UHD and ULD), a special analysis of hydrological parameters has been proposed. Moreover, to investigate the impact of climate change, four variant scenarios were taken into account, combining the RCP (representative concentration pathway) 4.5 and 8.5 forecasts and the adopted time horizons (2026-2035 and 2046-2055). The results showed a much higher share of TN and TP from UHD compared to ULD (86%-32 022 kg/year and 89%-2574 kg/year, respectively). In addition, the variant scenarios showed that the forecasted increase in precipitation and temperature will result in increased loads of nutrients from UHD and ULD up to 30%. Furthermore, the current increase of inhabitant number, due to the Ukrainian war migration and the common tendency to convert agricultural land to residential areas, could contribute to further expansion of UHD and ULD areas and an additional increase of nutrient loads.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    区域水循环系统日益表现为自然和社会过程的双重作用,这对全球水安全产生了深远的影响。然而,准确解释自然-社会水系统耦合的变化并确定驱动因素构成重大挑战。这里,我们试图对田纳西河东叉白杨溪(EFPC)流域的自然-社会耦合水系统进行建模,美国。该研究区具有两个社会水循环组成部分:当地的调水项目和橡树岭废水处理设施(ORWTF)。我们在开源轻量级QGIS软件中进行了土壤和水评估工具(SWAT)建模,综合了历史时期(1980-2016年)和未来时期(2017-2050年)的各种气候和土地利用变化情景。在考虑社会水循环成分时,我们实现了更准确和现实的模型模拟,表明社会水循环占观测到的流量的13-18%。气候变化/变化主导着自然径流变化。尽管土地利用和覆盖变化(LUCC)对自然径流的影响很小,它已经对径流产生过程产生了深远的影响:LUCC对其组成部分产生了显着影响,即,地表径流(RS)和地下径流(RSS)。具体来说,LUCC将负责RS和RSS的152%和45%的变化,分别,在未来的时期。这项研究强调了人工排水和排水对水循环的影响的重要性,并强调需要充分考虑自然社会水文过程的水资源管理措施。
    Regional water cycle systems are increasingly characterized by the dual effect of natural and social processes, which have profound impacts on global water security. However, accurately interpreting the changes in the coupled natural-social water system and identifying the driving factors pose significant challenges. Here, we attempted to model a coupled natural-social water system in the East Fork Poplar Creek (EFPC) watershed of the Tennessee River, United States. The study area features two social water cycle components: a local water transfer project and the Oak Ridge Wastewater Treatment Facility (ORWTF). We conducted the Soil and Water Assessment Tool (SWAT) modeling in the open-source light-weight QGIS software, with the synthesis of various climate and land use change scenarios in both historical periods (1980-2016) and future periods (2017-2050). We achieved more accurate and realistic model simulations when considering the social water cycle components, indicating that the social water cycle accounted for 13-18 % of the observed streamflow. Climate variation/change dominates natural runoff changes. Though land use and cover change (LUCC) had minimal effect on natural runoff, it had a profound impact on the process of runoff generation, i.e., surface runoff (RS) and subsurface runoff (RSS). Specifically, LUCC would be responsible for 152 % and 45 % of the changes in RS and RSS, respectively, in future periods. This study highlights the significance of artificial water discharge and withdrawal impacts on the water cycle and emphasizes the need for water resources management measures that fully consider natural-social hydrological processes.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

    求助全文

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    当前的研究重点是分析气候变化和土地利用/土地覆盖(LULC)变化对Puthimari盆地沉积物产量的影响,雅鲁藏布江的喜马拉雅东部分水岭,使用混合SWAT-ANN模型方法。该分析被精心分为三个不同的时间跨度:2025-2049、2050-2074和2075-2099。这种创新的方法整合了两种代表性浓度路径(RCP4.5和RCP8.5)下的多种气候模型的见解,以及通过元胞自动机马尔可夫模型生成的LULC投影。通过结合土壤和水评估工具(SWAT)和人工神经网络(ANN)技术的优势,这项研究旨在提高沉积物产量模拟的准确性,以应对不断变化的环境条件。混合模型的ANN分量采用具有外部输入的非线性自回归(NARX)方法。与单独使用SWAT模型相比,采用混合SWAT-ANN方法似乎在提高沉积物产量模拟的准确性方面特别有效,与独立SWAT模型的0.35相比,混合模型的确定系数较高,为0.74。在RCP4.5情景的背景下,在2075-99年间,研究发现沉积物产量增加了29.34%,伴随着印度季风季节流量和降雨量同时上升42.74%和27.43%,从六月到九月。相比之下,在RCP8.5场景下,在同一时期,沉积物产量的增加,放电,季风季节的降雨量为116.56%,103.28%,和64.72%,分别。本研究对Puthimari河流域泥沙供应影响因素的综合分析填补了一个重要的知识空白,并为设计主动洪水和侵蚀管理策略提供了宝贵的见解。这项研究的结果对于了解Puthimari盆地对气候和土地利用变化的脆弱性至关重要,并将这些发现纳入政策和决策过程,面对未来的水文和环境挑战,利益相关者可以努力增强韧性和可持续性。
    The current study focuses on analyzing the impacts of climate change and land use/land cover (LULC) changes on sediment yield in the Puthimari basin, an Eastern Himalayan sub-watershed of the Brahmaputra, using a hybrid SWAT-ANN model approach. The analysis was meticulously segmented into three distinct time spans: 2025-2049, 2050-2074, and 2075-2099. This innovative method integrates insights from multiple climate models under two Representative Concentration Pathways (RCP4.5 and RCP8.5), along with LULC projections generated through the Cellular Automata Markov model. By combining the strengths of the Soil and Water Assessment Tool (SWAT) and artificial neural network (ANN) techniques, the study aims to improve the accuracy of sediment yield simulations in response to changing environmental conditions. The non-linear autoregressive with external input (NARX) method was adopted for the ANN component of the hybrid model. The adoption of the hybrid SWAT-ANN approach appears to be particularly effective in improving the accuracy of sediment yield simulation compared to using the SWAT model alone, as evidenced by the higher coefficient of determination value of 0.74 for the hybrid model compared to 0.35 for the standalone SWAT model. In the context of the RCP4.5 scenario, during 2075-99, the study noted a 29.34% increase in sediment yield, accompanied by simultaneous rises of 42.74% in discharge and 27.43% in rainfall during the Indian monsoon season, spanning from June to September. In contrast, under the RCP8.5 scenario, for the same period, the increases in sediment yield, discharge, and rainfall for the monsoon season were determined to be 116.56%, 103.28%, and 64.72%, respectively. The present study\'s comprehensive analysis of the factors influencing sediment supply in the Puthimari River basin fills an important knowledge gap and provides valuable insights for designing proactive flood and erosion management strategies. The findings from this research are crucial for understanding the vulnerability of the Puthimari basin to climate and land use changes, and by incorporating these findings into policy and decision-making processes, stakeholders can work towards enhancing resilience and sustainability in the face of future hydrological and environmental challenges.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

    求助全文

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    由于气候和环境条件不同,对亚湿润地区的水供应进行评估非常重要。在这项研究中,在模拟喀拉拉邦亚湿润热带卡比尼盆地的水流时,已经评估了土壤和水评估工具(SWAT)和水文工程中心-水文建模系统(HEC-HMS)模型,印度,跨越1260km2。校准和验证利用了Muthankera计量站1997年至2015年的每日天气数据。这项研究调查了路由方法对ArcSWAT中径流模拟的影响,探索Muskingum和变量存储方法。评估指标包括纳什-萨克利夫效率(NSE),确定系数(R2),百分比偏差(PBIAS),RMSE-观测值标准偏差比(RSR),和高流量值的峰值百分比阈值统计(PPTS)方法。结果表明,在日常校准和验证过程中,HEC-HMS在R2和NSE值方面优于SWAT。每月模拟显示HEC-HMS与SWAT(可变存储)紧密对齐,表现优于特警(Muskingum)。事实证明,PPTS方法可有效模拟高流量值。两种模型都表现出在研究区域内的流量分析的熟练程度,对未来亚湿润地区水文研究具有很好的预测潜力。
    Assessment of water availability in sub-humid regions is important due to distinct climatic and environmental conditions. In this study, Soil and Water Assessment Tool (SWAT) and Hydrologic Engineering Center-Hydrologic Modeling System (HEC-HMS) models have been assessed in simulating streamflows in the sub-humid tropical Kabini basin in Kerala, India, spanning 1260 km2. Calibration and validation utilized daily weather data from 1997 to 2015 from the Muthankera gauging station. The study investigated the impact of routing methods on runoff simulation in the ArcSWAT, exploring Muskingum and Variable Storage methods. Evaluation metrics encompassed Nash-Sutcliffe Efïciency (NSE), Coefficient of Determination (R2), Percent bias (PBIAS), RMSE-observations standard deviation ratio (RSR), and Peak Percent Threshold Statistics (PPTS) approach for high-flow values. The result indicates that HEC-HMS outperforms SWAT concerning R2 and NSE values during daily calibration and validation. Monthly simulations showed HEC-HMS closely aligning with SWAT (Variable storage), outperforming SWAT (Muskingum). The PPTS approach proved effective in simulating high-flow values. Both models exhibited proficiency in streamflow analysis within the study area, promising predictive potential for future hydrological studies in sub-humid regions.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

    求助全文

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    基于物理或数据驱动的模型可用于了解整个流域的水文过程并为未来条件做出预测。基于物理的模型使用物理定律和原理来表示水文过程。相比之下,数据驱动模型侧重于投入产出关系。尽管这两种方法都在水文学中得到了应用,比较这些方法的研究对于数据稀缺仍然有限,水文状况改变的半干旱盆地。本研究旨在比较基于物理的模型(土壤和水评估工具(SWAT))和数据驱动模型(非线性自回归easious模型(NARX))的性能,以在数据稀缺的半干旱地区进行储层体积和流量预测。这项研究是在Tersakan盆地进行的,蒂尔基耶的一个半干旱农业盆地,由于为灌溉目的而建造的水库(Ladik和Yedikir水库),流域水文学发生了重大变化。针对流量和储层体积对模型进行了校准和验证。结果表明,(1)NARX在预测Ladik和Yedikir水库的水量和流域出口处的流量方面比SWAT表现更好(2)。SWAT和NARX模型在预测Ladik水库的水量时都提供了最佳性能。在预测Yedikir水库的水量时,这两种模型都提供了第二好的性能。模型性能对于预测流域出口(3)的水流是最低的。基于物理模型和数据驱动模型的比较由于其不同的特性和输入数据要求而具有挑战性。在这项研究中,数据驱动模型提供了比基于物理的模型更高的性能。然而,用于建立基于物理的模型的输入数据有几个不确定性,这可能是导致性能下降的原因。数据驱动模型可以在数据稀缺的条件下提供基于物理的模型的替代方案。
    Physically based or data-driven models can be used for understanding basinwide hydrological processes and creating predictions for future conditions. Physically based models use physical laws and principles to represent hydrological processes. In contrast, data-driven models focus on input-output relationships. Although both approaches have found applications in hydrology, studies that compare these approaches are still limited for data-scarce, semi-arid basins with altered hydrological regimes. This study aims to compare the performances of a physically based model (Soil and Water Assessment Tool (SWAT)) and a data-driven model (Nonlinear AutoRegressive eXogenous model (NARX)) for reservoir volume and streamflow prediction in a data-scarce semi-arid region. The study was conducted in the Tersakan Basin, a semi-arid agricultural basin in Türkiye, where the basin hydrology was significantly altered due to reservoirs (Ladik and Yedikir Reservoir) constructed for irrigation purposes. The models were calibrated and validated for streamflow and reservoir volumes. The results show that (1) NARX performed better in the prediction of water volumes of Ladik and Yedikir Reservoirs and streamflow at the basin outlet than SWAT (2). The SWAT and NARX models both provided the best performance when predicting water volumes at the Ladik reservoir. Both models provided the second best performance during the prediction of water volumes at the Yedikir reservoir. The model performances were the lowest for prediction of streamflow at the basin outlet (3). Comparison of physically based and data-driven models is challenging due to their different characteristics and input data requirements. In this study, the data-driven model provided higher performance than the physically based model. However, input data used for establishing the physically based model had several uncertainties, which may be responsible for the lower performance. Data-driven models can provide alternatives to physically-based models under data-scarce conditions.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

公众号