Mixed-methods review

  • 文章类型: Systematic Review
    目的:综合实证研究,调查指南制定会议审议过程中涉及的认知和社会过程,并确定审议主题的分布。
    方法:我们使用融合分离方法进行了混合方法系统综述。我们搜索了实证研究,以调查在书目数据库中索引的指南开发会议的组内动态。
    结果:在筛选的5899篇引文中,来自六个国家的12项研究证明合格。椅子,共同主席,方法学家在指南制定会议上至少贡献了三分之一的讨论时间;患者合作伙伴贡献最少.在跨学科小组中,男性性别和医生职业与贡献量呈正相关.与使用分级方法的小组相比,没有的团体,当面对不足或低质量的证据时,更依赖于他们的临床经验。在会议中,认知“是”偏见的存在是显而易见的:小组成员倾向于默许积极的陈述,而这些陈述需要比消极陈述更少的认知努力。
    结论:讨论的社会动态与每个小组成员的活动角色有关,专业背景,和性别,所有这些都影响了他们在准则制定会议上做出的贡献。
    OBJECTIVE: To synthesize empirical studies that investigate the cognitive and social processes involved in the deliberation process of guideline development meetings and determine the distribution of deliberated topics.
    METHODS: We conducted a mixed-method systematic review using a convergent segregated approach. We searched for empirical studies that investigate the intragroup dynamics of guideline development meetings indexed in bibliographic databases.
    RESULTS: Of the 5,899 citations screened, 12 studies from six countries proved eligible. Chairs, cochairs, and methodologists contributed to at least one-third of the discussion time in guideline development meetings; patient partners contributed the least. In interdisciplinary groups, male gender and occupation as a physician were positively associated with the amount of contribution. Compared to groups that used the Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation approach, for groups that did not, when faced with insufficient or low-quality evidence, relied more on their clinical experience. The presence of a cognitive \"yes\" bias was apparent in meetings: panelists tended to acquiesce with positive statements that required less cognitive effort than negative statements.
    CONCLUSIONS: The social dynamics of the discussions were linked to each panelist\'s activity role, professional background, and gender, all of which influenced the level of contributions they made in guideline development meetings.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

    求助全文

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    综合患者和临床医生的共同或不同看法,这些看法会影响对慢性肌肉骨骼(MSK)状况的在线提供的运动计划(ODEP)的吸收。
    从开始到2023年4月搜索了八个数据库的研究,包括(1)患有和/或临床医生为慢性MSK疾病提供ODEP的患者,和(2)同步ODEP,其中信息同时交换(模式A);异步ODEP,具有至少一个同步功能(模式B);或无ODEP,记录过去的经验和/或参与ODEP的可能性(模式C)。关键评估技能计划清单用于评估研究质量。提取了影响ODEP摄取的患者和临床医生的感知。对定量和定性数据进行了综合和整合。
    纳入了21项研究(12项定量研究,七个定性,和两种混合方法)调查1275名患者和534名临床医生对ODEP模式A(n=7)的看法,模式B(n=8),和模式C(n=6)。在23个确定的与满意度相关的感知中,有16个,可接受性,可用性,和有效性是常见的,70%的感知促进吸收,30%的感知阻碍吸收。
    研究结果强调需要促进针对患者和临床医生的针对性教育,以解决相互关联的观念。并制定以证据为基础的感知为中心的策略,鼓励综合护理和基于指南的慢性MSK疾病管理。
    几乎70%的感知与满意度有关,可接受性,可用性,患者和临床医生共享影响在线提供的慢性肌肉骨骼疾病运动计划的有效性。与临床医生不同并阻碍摄取的患者认知包括误诊的风险,缺乏社会支持,以及他们的诊所和/或临床医生的建议。与患者不同并阻碍摄取的临床医生的看法包括最后一刻预约取消的风险,建立的成本,和摄像机角度的限制。可以通过针对患者和临床医生的针对性教育来支持在线提供的锻炼计划的实施,以解决误解。
    UNASSIGNED: To synthesize common or differing perceptions of patients\' and clinicians\' that influence uptake of online-delivered exercise programmes (ODEPs) for chronic musculoskeletal (MSK) conditions.
    UNASSIGNED: Eight databases were searched from inception to April 2023 for studies including (1) patients with and/or clinicians delivering ODEPs for chronic MSK conditions, and (2) synchronous ODEPs, where information is exchanged simultaneously (mode A); asynchronous ODEPs, with at least one synchronous feature (mode B); or no ODEPs, documenting past experiences and/or likelihood of participating in an ODEP (mode C). Critical Appraisal Skills Programme checklists were used to assess study quality. Perceptions of patients\' and clinicians\' influencing uptake of ODEPs were extracted. Quantitative and qualitative data were synthesised and integrated.
    UNASSIGNED: Twenty-one studies were included (twelve quantitative, seven qualitative, and two mixed-methods) investigating the perceptions of 1275 patients and 534 clinicians on ODEP mode A (n = 7), mode B (n = 8), and mode C (n = 6). Sixteen of the 23 identified perceptions related to satisfaction, acceptability, usability, and effectiveness were common, with 70% of perceptions facilitating uptake and 30% hindering uptake.
    UNASSIGNED: Findings highlight the need to promote targeted education for patients and clinicians addressing interconnected perceptions, and to develop evidence-based perception-centred strategies encouraging integrated care and guideline-based management of chronic MSK conditions.
    Almost 70% of perceptions related to satisfaction, acceptability, usability, and effectiveness that influence the uptake of online-delivered exercise programmes for chronic musculoskeletal conditions are shared by patients and clinicians.Patient perceptions that differ from clinicians and that hinder uptake include the risk of misdiagnosis, lack of social support, and advice from their clinic and/or clinician.Clinician perceptions that differ from patients and that hinder uptake include risk of last-minute appointment cancellations, the cost to set-up, and limitations of camera angles.Implementation of online-delivered exercise programmes may be supported by targeted education for patients and clinicians that addresses misinformed perceptions.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

    求助全文

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    BACKGROUND: This study aimed to review diet and nutrition information and support needs of cancer patients who receive pelvic radiotherapy to inform the development of interventions to improve this area of care.
    METHODS: The systematic review followed the PRISMA guidelines. Six electronic databases were searched for peer-reviewed studies of any design that assessed diet and nutrition needs after a pelvic cancer diagnosis. Narrative synthesis was used to integrate findings.
    RESULTS: Thirty studies (12 quantitative, 15 qualitative, 3 mixed-methods) were included. Four themes, \"content of dietary information\"; \"sources of information\"; \"sustaining dietary change\"; and \"views on the role of diet post-treatment,\" summarised evidence about provision of nutritional guidance following diagnosis, but also contrasting views about the role of diet post-diagnosis. Qualitative studies contributed considerably more to the synthesis, compared to quantitative studies. Included studies were of moderate to good quality; selection bias in quantitative studies and poor evidence of credibility and dependability in qualitative studies were highlighted.
    CONCLUSIONS: There is some evidence of lack of nutrition support in pelvic cancer survivors, but methodological limitations of included studies may have had an impact on the findings. Future, prospective studies that focus on diet and nutrition needs post-diagnosis are warranted to improve care.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Sci-hub)

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    撒哈拉以南非洲(SSA)的年轻人感染艾滋病毒(YPLHIV)的生活质量很高。在艾滋病毒/艾滋病政策中明确解决福祉问题可以有助于缓解努力。然而,关于评估YPLHIV政策的福利措施的指导很少。这项混合方法审查的目的是确定:i)健康的关键维度和ii)与SSA中的YPLHIV(15-24岁)中的这些维度一致的健康措施。我们搜索了六个社会科学和医学数据库,包括灰色文学。我们纳入了研究相关因素和生活经历的研究,在SSA的YPLHIV中,从2000年1月到2019年5月。两名审稿人独立筛选了摘要和全文,并评估了所收录文章的方法学质量。我们使用描述性和元人种学方法分析了定量和定性数据,分别。此后,我们使用框架方法整合发现。我们确定了6527条引文。其中,包括10项定量研究和30项定性研究。作为男性,高等教育地位,更少的污名和更多的社会支持可能是幸福的相关因素。塑造暗示幸福的经历的主题是:1)接受和归属-污名,社会支持;2)应对;3)生活水平。我们最后的综合发现,以下维度可能表征幸福:自我接受,属于,自主性;积极的关系,掌握环境,人生的目的。YPLHIV的幸福是多维和关系的。相关措施包括个人福祉指数,Ryff的心理健康量表和心理健康连续简短形式。然而,需要在SSA的YPLHIV中对这些量表进行心理测量评估。
    Young people living with HIV (YPLHIV) in sub-Saharan Africa (SSA) are at high risk of having a poor quality of life. Addressing wellbeing explicitly within HIV/AIDS policies could assist mitigation efforts. However, guidance on wellbeing measures to evaluate policies for YPLHIV is scarce. The aims of this mixed-methods review were to identify: i) key dimensions of wellbeing and ii) wellbeing measures that align to these dimensions among YPLHIV (15-24 years) in SSA. We searched six social science and medical databases, including grey literature. We included studies that examined correlates and lived experiences of wellbeing, among YPLHIV in SSA, from January 2000 to May 2019. Two reviewers independently screened abstracts and full texts and assessed methodological quality of included articles. We analysed quantitative and qualitative data using descriptive and meta-ethnographic approaches, respectively. Thereafter, we integrated findings using a framework approach. We identified 6527 citations. Of these, 10 quantitative and 30 qualitative studies were included. Being male, higher educational status, less stigma and more social support were likely correlates of wellbeing. Themes that shaped experiences suggestive of wellbeing were: 1) acceptance and belonging- stigma, social support; 2) coping; 3) standard of living. Our final synthesis found that the following dimensions potentially characterise wellbeing: self-acceptance, belonging, autonomy; positive relations, environmental mastery, purpose in life. Wellbeing for YPLHIV is multi-dimensional and relational. Relevant measures include the Personal Wellbeing Index, Ryff\'s Psychological Wellbeing Scale and Mental Health Continuum Short Form. However, psychometric evaluations of these scales among YPLHIV in SSA are needed.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Sci-hub)

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Systematic Review
    目的:确定研究文献是否支持研究围产期心理健康(PMH)助产实践的新框架。
    背景:患有PMH问题的女性的识别和护理越来越被认为是助产实践的一部分。研究表明,许多助产士缺乏知识,技能和信心。能够确定有效临床实践的障碍和促进者将是有用的。作者提出了一个框架,包括五个可能可测量的领域,这些领域对助产士的识别能力有影响,评估和护理有PMH问题的妇女。
    方法:此混合方法综述使用了基于框架综合的创新定性融合设计。
    方法:检索了2007年1月至2016年12月期间的相关电子数据库;来自9个国家的33项研究符合纳入标准。
    方法:使用关键评估工具评估研究质量。研究结果被映射到框架的五个领域:知识,信心,态度,疾病感知和基础设施。然后对每个结构域合成结果。
    结果:所有五个领域都在文献中得到了实质性的代表,从而支持拟议的框架。鉴定了几个子域和域之间的关系。不同的知识水平,信心,发现了态度和疾病观念;证据表明,助产士从这些领域的进一步培训中受益。组织基础设施的特征是有效护理的障碍或促进者;这些需要在组织层面解决。
    结论:提议的框架得到了确认,可用于指导实践,政策和研究。
    OBJECTIVE: To ascertain whether a new framework examining midwifery practice in perinatal mental health (PMH) is supported by the research literature.
    BACKGROUND: The identification and care of women with PMH problems is increasingly considered part of midwifery practice. Research suggests that many midwives lack knowledge, skills and confidence. It would be useful to be able to determine barriers and facilitators to effective clinical practice. The authors propose a framework comprising five potentially measurable domains which have an impact on midwives\' ability to identify, assess and care for women with PMH problems.
    METHODS: This mixed-methods review uses an innovative qualitative convergent design based on framework synthesis.
    METHODS: Relevant electronic databases were searched for the period from January 2007-December 2016; 33 studies from nine countries met the inclusion criteria.
    METHODS: Study quality was assessed using critical appraisal tools. Study findings were mapped onto the five domains of the framework: knowledge, confidence, attitudes, illness perception and infrastructure. Findings were then synthesized for each domain.
    RESULTS: All five domains are substantially represented in the literature, thus supporting the proposed framework. Several sub-domains and relationships between domains were identified. Varying levels of knowledge, confidence, attitudes and illness perceptions were found; evidence suggests that midwives benefit from further training within these domains. Features of organizational infrastructure act as barriers or facilitators to effective care; these need to be addressed at organizational level.
    CONCLUSIONS: The proposed framework was confirmed and can be used to inform practice, policy and research.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Sci-hub)

公众号