Ethics/Bioethics

伦理学 / 生物伦理学
  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    全球眼科机会越来越受欢迎,和国际伙伴关系在美国的学术培训机构中变得越来越普遍。需要在复杂的关系中进行培训,动机,伦理,以及这些伙伴关系中可能出现的后勤问题。
    我们在一个虚构的国际眼科合作方案中开发了一个3小时的基于案例的会议,其中包括四个角色。主持人对四个部分中的每个部分都使用结构化的问题来促进学习者之间的互动和讨论。活动结束后,参与者完成了由Likert量表和开放式问题组成的评估/问卷。
    共有23名眼科住院医师和7名医学生在4次迭代中进行了这项活动。该活动受到好评,当被问及该会话是否值得时,100%的学习者强烈同意(90%)或同意(10%),当被问及格式是否有利于实现学习目标时,100%的学习者强烈同意(87%)或同意(13%)。关于学习者如何改变他们在居住和未来职业生涯中实践眼科的问题的答案围绕以下主题:考虑其他观点,谦卑,自我意识和情境意识,伙伴关系的复杂性,互惠和交换,沟通的重要性,以及国际和国内医疗实践之间的原则联系。
    虽然本案例研究探索了国际眼科合作方案,提出的原则和主题可以适用于其他医学领域,并可以适用于国际和国内的医学实践。
    UNASSIGNED: Global ophthalmology opportunities are becoming increasingly popular, and international partnerships are becoming more common among academic training institutions in the United States. There is need for training in the complex relational, motivational, ethical, and logistical issues that may arise in these partnerships.
    UNASSIGNED: We developed a 3-hour case-based session featuring four characters in a fictitious international ophthalmology partnership scenario. Facilitators used structured questions for each of the four parts to foster interaction and discussion among learners. After the activity, participants completed an evaluation/questionnaire consisting of Likert-scale and open-ended questions.
    UNASSIGNED: A total of 23 ophthalmology residents and seven medical students underwent the activity over four iterations. The activity was well received, with 100% of learners either strongly agreeing (90%) or agreeing (10%) when asked if the session was worthwhile and 100% of learners either strongly agreeing (87%) or agreeing (13%) when asked if the format was conducive to achieving the learning objectives. Answers to questions on how learners would change how they practice ophthalmology in their residency and in their future careers revolved around the following topics: consideration of other perspectives, humility, self- and situational awareness, complexities of partnerships, reciprocity and exchange, importance of communication, and connection of principles between international and domestic medical practice.
    UNASSIGNED: While this case study explores an international ophthalmology partnership scenario, the principles and themes presented can be applicable to other fields of medicine, and can be applicable to the practice of medicine both internationally and domestically.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    道德和专业困境是医学日常实践的一部分,包括皮肤病理学(例如,自我参照皮肤活检对病理学解释的伦理意义)。需要皮肤病学教育者可以轻松访问的教具,以帮助提供道德教育。
    我们举行了长达一个小时的会议,教师促进,互动式,关于皮肤病学伦理问题的虚拟讨论。会议遵循一个结构化的,基于案例的格式。我们在会议结束后进行了匿名在线反馈调查,并使用Wilcoxon签名等级测试来比较参与者在回答之前和之后。
    来自两个学术机构的72个人参加了会议。我们从皮肤科住院医师(n=15)收集了35份总应答(49%),皮肤科教师(n=14),医学生(n=2),以及其他提供者和学习者(n=4)。反馈基本上是积极的,21名与会者(60%)表示他们学到了一些东西,11名与会者(31%)表示他们学到了很多东西。此外,32名参与者(91%)表示,他们会向同事推荐这次会议。我们的分析表明,在会议结束后,与会者对我们的三个目标中的每一个都有更高的自我感知成就水平。
    此皮肤病伦理学会议的结构易于共享,部署,并建立在其他机构的基础上。我们希望其他机构将使用我们的材料和结果来改善这里提出的基础,并且该框架将被其他寻求在其培训计划中促进道德教育的医学专业使用。
    Ethical and professional dilemmas are part of the day-to-day practice of medicine, including within dermatopathology (e.g., ethical implications of self-referring skin biopsies for pathology interpretation). There is a need for teaching aids that dermatology educators can easily access to help provide ethics education.
    We held an hour-long, faculty-facilitated, interactive, virtual discussion about ethical issues in dermatopathology. The session followed a structured, case-based format. We administered anonymous online feedback surveys after the session and used the Wilcoxon signed rank test to compare participants\' before and after responses.
    Seventy-two individuals from two academic institutions participated in the session. We collected 35 total responses (49%) from dermatology residents (n = 15), dermatology faculty (n = 14), medical students (n = 2), and other providers and learners (n = 4). Feedback was largely positive, with 21 attendees (60%) indicating they learned a few things and 11 (31%) indicating they learned a great deal. Additionally, 32 participants (91%) indicated they would recommend the session to a colleague. Our analysis showed that attendees had a greater self-perceived level of achievement for each of our three objectives after the session.
    This dermatoethics session is structured so as to be easily shared, deployed, and built on by other institutions. We hope that other institutions will use our materials and results to improve upon the foundation presented here and that this framework will be used by other medical specialties seeking to foster ethics education in their training programs.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Review
    目的:评估对支气管肺发育不良(BPD)儿童的父母最重要的潜在未来结局,一种影响未来呼吸的疾病,medical,以及早产儿童的发育结果。
    方法:我们招募了两家儿童医院新生儿随访诊所的父母,并得出了他们对与BPD相关的20种不同的潜在未来结局的重要性评级。这些结果是通过文献回顾和与父母和临床医生利益相关者小组的讨论来确定和选择的。通过离散选择实验。
    结果:一百零五名父母参加了。总的来说,父母将“我的孩子会因为患有肺病而更容易受到其他问题的影响吗?”列为最重要的结果,与其他呼吸系统健康相关的结果也排名很高。与儿童发育和对家庭的影响有关的结果排名最低。个别地,父母对结果的评价不同,导致许多结果的重要性分数分布广泛。
    结论:总体排名表明,父母优先考虑与身体健康和安全相关的未来结局。值得注意的是,为了指导研究,传统上,在结局研究中无法衡量一些评分最高的结局.为了指导个人咨询,对于许多结局,重要性评分的广泛分布凸显了父母在结局的优先次序上的差异程度.
    To assess which potential future outcomes are most important to parents of children with bronchopulmonary dysplasia, a disease that affects future respiratory, medical, and developmental outcomes for children born preterm.
    We recruited parents from 2 children\'s hospitals\' neonatal follow-up clinics and elicited their importance rating for 20 different potential future outcomes associated with bronchopulmonary dysplasia. These outcomes were identified and selected through a literature review and discussions with panels of parents and clinician stakeholders, via a discrete choice experiment.
    One hundred and 5 parents participated. Overall, parents ranked \"Will my child be more vulnerable to other problems because of having lung disease?\" as the most important outcome, with other respiratory health related outcomes also highly ranked. Outcomes related to child development and effects on the family were among the lowest ranked. Individually, parents rated outcomes differently, resulting in a broad distribution of importance scores for many of the outcomes.
    The overall rankings suggest that parents prioritize future outcomes related to physical health and safety. Notably, for guiding research, some top-rated outcomes are not traditionally measured in outcome studies. For guiding individual counseling, the broad distribution of importance scores for many outcomes highlights the extent to which parents differ in their prioritization of outcomes.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    价值观澄清是一种结构化的,个人参与反思过程,以更好地了解自己的信仰和优先事项。我们设计了一个关于价值观澄清的研讨会,以帮助实习医学生预测和管理他们的个人价值观和职业期望之间的潜在冲突。
    我们为参与的学生分配了一个价值观澄清练习,作为准备工作。为期2小时的研讨会包括介绍性发言,两位医生关于他们面临的个人道德挑战的演讲,和教师促进的小团体。在小团体中,学生们讨论了各种医疗保健情景下的道德不适。学生被邀请完成一个可选的研讨会后调查与李克特规模和简答题。我们分析了定性数据,并制定了10个新兴主题。
    180名参与学生中有38名(21%)返回了调查。其中,30(79%)同意研讨会帮助他们意识到他们的价值观可能与专业义务相冲突,26(68%)同意他们将能够将学到的知识应用于未来的场景,30人(79%)同意研讨会帮助他们理解同事的价值观。确定的最突出的主题是,学生发现医生小组特别有意义,研讨会帮助学生检查自己的价值观,并准备他们更好地了解他们未来的病人的价值观。
    我们的研讨会是独一无二的,因为它不专注于医疗保健的单一领域,而是广泛地解决道德不适。据我们所知,这是为实习医学生开发的第一个价值观澄清课程倡议。
    Values clarification is a structured, reflective process individuals engage in to better understand their own beliefs and priorities. We designed a workshop on values clarification to help preclerkship medical students anticipate and manage potential conflicts between their personal values and professional expectations.
    We assigned participating students a values clarification exercise as prework. The 2-hour workshop included introductory remarks, a presentation by two physicians on personal ethical challenges they had faced, and faculty-facilitated small groups. In the small groups, students discussed moral discomfort in the context of various health care scenarios. Students were invited to complete an optional postworkshop survey with Likert-scale and short-answer questions. We analyzed the qualitative data and formulated 10 emerging themes.
    Thirty-eight of 180 participating students (21%) returned the survey. Of these, 30 (79%) agreed the workshop helped them appreciate that their values might come into conflict with professional obligations, 26 (68%) agreed they would be able to apply what they learned to future scenarios, and 30 (79%) agreed the workshop helped them understand their colleagues\' values. The most prominent themes identified were that students found the physician panel especially meaningful and that the workshop helped students examine their own values and prepared them to better understand their future patients\' values.
    Our workshop is unique in that it does not focus on a single area in health care but addresses moral discomfort broadly. To the best of our knowledge, it is the first values clarification curricular initiative developed for preclerkship medical students.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    阿片类药物流行影响所有年龄段,然而,很少有出版的医学教育课程来培训医生如何护理青少年阿片类药物使用障碍(OUD),保密保护是适当的发展阶段,有助于高质量的医疗保健。我们开发了一种基于模拟的教育干预措施,以增加成瘾医学和成瘾精神病学学员对管理OUD青少年的信心。
    学员完成了一项信心调查,并观看了一段教育视频,内容涉及与OUD治疗青少年有关的特定州保密法。一周后,受训者参加了一次模拟的相遇,他们向受过训练的演员描述了保密的范围,使用临床阿片类药物戒断量表评估阿片类药物戒断的症状,并解释了针对青少年的OUD药物治疗方案。紧接着,学员完成了自我反省和满意度调查,并参加了与一名教师的汇报会议,他们确定了学习目标。一个月后,他们完成了信心调查,以量化信心的变化。
    35名研究员(21名男性,14名女性)在2016年至2019年之间完成了基于模拟的教育干预。当被要求回答是或否时,96%的参与者认为这项运动是有效的,100%(n=26)会推荐给同龄人。此外,学习者确定了未来的学习目标,包括研究特定主题并寻求其他机会来评估OUD青少年。
    根据我们的参与者报告,这种基于模拟的教育干预是一种有效的教学方法,可以提高受训者管理OUD青少年的信心。
    The opioid epidemic impacts all ages, yet few published medical education curricula exist to train physicians on how to care for opioid use disorder (OUD) in adolescents, a developmental stage where confidentiality protection is appropriate and contributes to quality health care. We developed a simulation-based educational intervention to increase addiction medicine and addiction psychiatry trainees\' confidence in managing adolescents with OUD.
    Trainees completed a confidence survey and viewed an educational video covering state-specific confidentiality laws pertinent to treating adolescents with OUD. One week later, trainees participated in a simulated encounter where they described the scope of confidentiality to a trained actor, used the Clinical Opiate Withdrawal Scale to assess symptoms of opioid withdrawal, and explained adolescent-specific OUD medication treatment options. Immediately afterward, trainees completed a self-reflection and satisfaction survey and participated in a debriefing session with a faculty member where they identified learning goals. One month later, they completed the confidence survey to quantify changes in confidence.
    Thirty-five fellows (21 male, 14 female) completed the simulation-based educational intervention between 2016 and 2019. When asked to answer yes or no, 96% of participants described the exercise as effective and 100% (n = 26) would recommend it to peers. In addition, learners identified future learning goals, including researching specific topics and seeking out additional opportunities to evaluate adolescents with OUD.
    Based on our participants\' report, this simulation-based educational intervention is an effective teaching method for increasing trainee confidence in managing adolescents with OUD.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    在传染病暴发的背景下了解人口健康是重要的医师能力。然而,确定有效的方法来吸引早期医学生参与这一内容仍然是一个挑战。我们利用僵尸的流行文化主题为一年级医学生设计了一种创新的大流行模拟。
    这个2.5小时的模拟是在2018年和2020年学生病毒学课程期间进行的。学生团队收集并分析数据,以制定源病原体的假设。团队完成了解释其诊断假设的报告,感染遏制建议,和资源分配建议。学习者通过在线调查完成了对模拟的评估。使用描述性统计分析回答;对主题进行定性分析。对学生报告进行了内容分析。
    二百八十四名医学生参加了这次活动。几乎所有受访者都同意小团体形式(98%,2018年和2020年)以及速度和持续时间(92%,2018年;94%,2020年)是适当的,这项活动在智力上是刺激的(97%,2018年;96%,2020)。学习者参与度高(90%-97%,2018年;83%-96%,2020)。对学生报告的分析揭示了病毒学认知整合的证据,人口健康,和生物伦理学概念,包括整合新的学习内容。
    在模拟的以僵尸为主题的大流行期间协作解决问题,为临床前医学生提供了一个整合病毒学的有趣机会,人口健康,和生物伦理学概念。实施此事件需要先进的计划,使用多个空间,学习材料准备,并招募了几名教师,工作人员,和演员。
    Understanding population health in the context of infectious disease outbreaks is an important physician competency. However, identifying effective ways to engage early medical students in this content remains a challenge. We designed an innovative pandemic simulation for first-year medical students utilizing the pop culture theme of zombies.
    This 2.5-hour simulation was conducted in 2018 and 2020 during students\' virology course. Student teams collected and analyzed data to formulate hypotheses for the source pathogen. The teams completed reports explaining their diagnostic hypotheses, infection containment recommendations, and resource allocation recommendations. Learners completed an evaluation of the simulation through an online survey. Responses were analyzed using descriptive statistics; narrative responses were analyzed qualitatively for themes. A content analysis was performed on students\' reports.
    Two hundred eighty-four medical students participated in this activity. Nearly all respondents agreed that the small-group format (98%, 2018 and 2020) and pace and duration (92%, 2018; 94%, 2020) were appropriate and that the activity was intellectually stimulating (97%, 2018; 96%, 2020). Learner engagement measures were high (90%-97%, 2018; 83%-96%, 2020). Analysis of students\' reports revealed evidence of cognitive integration of virology, population health, and bioethics concepts, including integration of new learning content.
    Collaborative problem-solving during a simulated zombie-themed pandemic provided preclinical medical students with an engaging opportunity to integrate virology, population health, and bioethics concepts. Implementing this event required advanced planning, use of multiple spaces, learning materials preparation, and recruitment of several faculty, staff, and actors.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    Medical students have limited opportunities to learn about current genetic testing. This session provided exposure to different types of testing and the complex issues that physicians may encounter when counseling patients on proper testing and interpreting results.
    We designed a 1-hour interactive lecture for second-year medical students. We presented an overview of the topic, then applied the concepts to specific disorders and cases. Students were asked to answer questions regarding cases using an audience response system, and we used their responses as the basis for our in-class discussion. This session has been held twice, with 25 students attending in 2018 and 31 students in 2019. The session was also recorded so that additional students not in attendance could watch, and was available to 151 students in 2018 and 333 students in 2019.
    Students answered questions via audience response system. There was a range of 47%-100% of students giving the correct answers in 2018, and 55%-93% in 2019. Exam questions covering genetic counseling issues were answered correctly by 66% and 77% of students in 2018, and 70% and 68% of students in 2019.
    This session provided an opportunity for medical students to be exposed to some of the complex ethical and psychosocial issues that may arise with genetic testing for liver disease and to consider how to navigate them. Using an audience response system during the lecture made the session more interactive and allowed the teacher to correct errors and teach based on the responses.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    学生在临床前教育过程中学习医学伦理学的基础知识,但需要额外的指导如何将这些原则应用于他们在临床轮换期间可能遇到的患者情况。在出院决策的背景下,自治和正义的道德原则与患者护理尤其相关。因此,三年级医学生将受益于互动教育活动,使他们能够在出院决策的背景下实践应用这些原则。
    本次课程是为完成神经病学专业要求的三年级医学生设计的。学生参加了一个小时,主持人主导,互动式,小团体,基于道德的活动旨在模拟典型的卒中后4天住院时间。该活动的学习目标是增强学生对自主性原则的理解,正义,能力,和能力。对学生进行了预先测试,以衡量对活动学习目标的先验知识;之后再次评估了他们的知识,并就这项活动的有用性和价值进行了调查。
    23名三年级医学生在三个阶段完成了这项活动。测试前和测试后评分之间的平均改善为40%。最后,在定性反馈表上,大多数学生强烈同意该活动是有用的,并提供了新的信息,23名学生中有18名给予该活动最高的优秀评级。
    绝大多数学生认为这项活动很有价值,和活动被证明是有效的,以提高学生的知识,成功的医疗实践的一个关键方面。
    Students are taught the basics of medical ethics during their pre-clinical education, but need additional instruction on how to apply these principles to patient situations they may encounter during their clinical rotations. The ethical principles of autonomy and justice become especially pertinent to patient care in the setting of discharge decision-making. Third-year medical students would therefore benefit from an interactive educational activity that allows them to practice applying these principles within the context of discharge decision-making.
    This session was designed for third-year medical students completing their required rotation in neurology. Students participated in a 1-hour, facilitator-led, interactive, small-group, ethics-based activity meant to simulate the typical 4-day post-stroke hospital stay. Learning objectives for the activity were to enhance students\' understanding of the principles of autonomy, justice, competence, and capacity. Students were given pretest to gauge prior knowledge of activity learning objectives; their knowledge was again assessed afterwards, and they were surveyed on the usefulness and value of the activity.
    Twenty-three third-year medical students completed the activity over three sessions. The average improvement between pre- and posttest score was 40%. Lastly, on the qualitative feedback form, a majority of students strongly agreed that the activity was useful and presented new information, with 18 of 23 students giving the activity the highest possible rating of excellent.
    A large majority of the students found the activity to be valuable, and the activity was shown to be effective at improving students\' knowledge of a key aspect of successful medical practice.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    尽管越来越多的州出于医疗和娱乐目的将大麻合法化,医疗保健提供者和学生报告说,关于大麻的舒适度低,知识有限,强调目前医疗培训的不足。
    我们为科罗拉多大学的普通精神病学住院医师计划开发了结构化的大麻课程。在构建我们的课程时,我们最初调查了高级精神科住院医师和大学门诊部精神科医师对使用大麻的精神病患者的态度和方法。在第二年实施第一年研究生核心课程(PGY1s)之前,预测试评估评估了PGY1对大麻使用的态度,并确定了学习期望,挑战,和信心水平。研讨会结束后,居民提供了测验后评估和一般课程评估。利用初步调查信息,我们为精神病学PGY1s构建了大麻和医学入门课程。主题包括菌株和配方,药代动力学,内源性大麻素系统,科罗拉多州当地法律,监测,关于在精神疾病中使用的证据,在怀孕中使用,和伦理问题。这些主题是通过基于案例的讨论涵盖的,互动测验,直接指示,促进了讨论。
    测试后评估表明学员的信心和知识基础有所改善,并要求对青少年使用等主题进行额外指导。
    积极的后测评估支持将大麻课程纳入精神病培训的价值。现在已经是第二年了,课程已扩展到4个小时。随着大麻被医疗化,越来越重要的是,精神科医生能够知识渊博地指导他们的病人。
    Although increasing numbers of states are legalizing cannabis for both medical and recreational purposes, health care providers and students report low comfort levels and limited knowledge regarding cannabis, highlighting current deficits in medical training.
    We developed a structured cannabis curriculum for a general psychiatry residency program at the University of Colorado. In constructing our curriculum, we initially surveyed advanced psychiatry residents and attending psychiatrists in the university outpatient clinic regarding attitudes and approaches to psychiatric patients using cannabis. Prior to implementation in the following year\'s core curriculum for first-year postgraduates (PGY 1s), pretest assessments evaluated PGY 1s\' attitudes towards cannabis use and identified learning expectations, challenges, and confidence levels. After the seminars were completed, residents provided posttest assessments and general course evaluations. Utilizing initial survey information, we constructed a Marijuana and Medicine introduction curriculum for psychiatry PGY 1s. Topics included strains and formulations, pharmacokinetics, the endocannabinoid system, local Colorado laws, monitoring, evidence regarding use in psychiatric disorders, use in pregnancy, and ethical issues. These topics were covered via case-based discussion, interactive quizzes, direct instruction, and facilitated discussion.
    Posttest assessments indicated improvement in trainees\' confidence and knowledge base and requests for additional instruction on topics such as adolescent use.
    The positive posttest assessments support the value of incorporating a cannabis curriculum into psychiatric training. Now in its second year, the course has been expanded to 4 hours. As cannabis is medicalized, it is increasingly important that psychiatrists be able to knowledgably counsel their patients.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    Pediatric residents are faced with ethical dilemmas in beginning- and end-of-life situations throughout their training. These situations are innately challenging, yet despite recommendations that residents receive training in ethics and end-of-life domains, they continue to report the need for additional training. To address these concerns, we developed an interactive and reflective palliative care and medical ethics curriculum including sessions focusing on ethical dilemmas at the beginning and end of life.
    This module includes a trio of case-based, small-group discussions on artificial nutrition and hydration, futility, and ethical considerations in neonatology. Content was developed based on a needs assessment, input from local experts, and previously published material. Trainees completed assessments of comfort and understanding before and after each session.
    The module was attended and assessed by an average of 27 trainees per session, including residents and medical students. Knowledge of ethical considerations improved after individual sessions, with 86% of trainees reporting understanding ethical considerations involved in the decision to withdraw or withhold medically provided nutrition and hydration and 67% of trainees reporting understanding the use of the term futility. Trainee comfort in providing counseling or recommendations regarding specific ethical issues demonstrated a trend toward improvement but did not reach statistical significance.
    We successfully implemented this innovative module, which increased trainees\' comfort with end-of-life care and ethical conflicts. Future studies should focus on the trainees\' ability to implement these skills in clinical practice.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Pubmed)

公众号