objective structured assessment of technical skills

对技术技能的客观结构化评估
  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    目的:评估结构模拟课程对产科肛门括约肌损伤(OASIS)修复的短期和技能保留效果。
    方法:本实验研究招募了北京协和医院31名妇产科住院医师。OASIS维修技能评估(在所有时间点)包括任务特定清单(TSC),全球评级量表(GRS),和通过/失败等级。仿真课程采用了牛舌模型。基线测试后,居民完成了一个结构化的1-h工作坊。两周后,进行了第二次测试,接着是一对一的教学研讨会,以正确完成清单为终点。三个月后,居民完成了第三次测试。
    结果:基线时的总体通过率为16.1%,老年居民的GRS评分较高(p=0.035)。此外,课前预习手术和OASIS修复观察史与较高的TSC和GRS评分相关.在第二次和第三次测试中观察到显著的技能改进,合格率分别为96.8%和93.5%。与基线相比,TSC和GRS评分均有所改善(p<0.001)。
    结论:在监督下整合刻意练习的结构模拟课程提高了OASIS修复能力,并实现了令人满意的技能保留。
    OBJECTIVE: To assess the short-term and skill-retention effects of a structural simulation curriculum for the repair of obstetrical anal sphincter injuries (OASIS).
    METHODS: This prepost experimental study recruited 31 obstetrics and gynecology residents from Peking Union Medical College Hospital. OASIS repair skill evaluations (at all timepoints) comprised a task-specific checklist (TSC), global rating scale (GRS), and pass/fail grade. A beef-tongue model was adopted in the simulation curriculum. After baseline testing, residents completed a structured 1-h workshop. Two weeks later, a second test was performed, followed by a one-to-one teaching workshop, with the proper completion of a checklist as the end-point. Three months later, residents completed a third test.
    RESULTS: The overall pass rate at baseline was 16.1%, with higher GRS scores (p = 0.035) in senior residents. Additionally, previewing the procedure before class and a history of OASIS repair observation were associated with higher TSC and GRS scores. Significant skill improvement was observed in the second and third tests, with pass rates of 96.8% and 93.5% respectively. Both TSC and GRS scores were improved compared with baseline (p < 0.001).
    CONCLUSIONS: A structural simulation curriculum integrating deliberate practice under supervision improves OASIS repair competence and achieves satisfactory skill retention.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

    求助全文

  • 文章类型: Journal Article
    The use of 3-dimensional (3D)-printed models is promising in nasal endoscopic technique training. Here, we aimed to develop postsurgical simulants for use in conjunction with 3D-printed nasal models and to assess their usefulness in helping residents transfer basic endoscopic skills acquired during simulation training to clinical situations.
    The secretion simulant was prepared via a crosslinked reaction between sodium alginate and acrylamide, whereas the packing simulant was prepared using a superabsorbent polymer. After the simulants\' fidelity and utility were evaluated by 5 rhinologists using a 5-point Likert scale, 46 novice residents were trained using the 3D-printed nasal models and postsurgical simulants for 2 weeks. A checklist and Global Rating Scale (GRS) were used to assess their performances before and after training, and the time to finish each task was also recorded. Following training, the qualified trainees operated on real patients and were reevaluated.
    The simulants\' similarity and usefulness scored ≥4.0, and the training cost was 28 CNY ($4 USD) per session. Following training, the checklist and GRS scores increased, and the operation time decreased (all p < 0.05). There were no statistical differences between the trainees\' performances on the models with the simulants and on patients (all p > 0.05).
    The low-cost simulated secretion and dressing are safe to use. The application of the simulants in conjunction with that of 3D-printed nasal models in a simulated task setting can help residents in transferring endoscopic skills acquired during simulation teaching to real patients.
    导出

    更多引用

    收藏

    翻译标题摘要

    我要上传

       PDF(Sci-hub)

公众号