背景:关于同一主题的不同网络荟萃分析(NMA)导致发现的差异。在这次审查中,我们调查了NMA,比较了阿柏西普和雷珠单抗治疗糖尿病性黄斑水肿(DME)的疗效,以期阐明结果差异的原因.
方法:在英文和中文电子数据库中搜索研究(PubMed,Embase,科克伦图书馆,WebofScience,CNKI,万方,VIP;详见正文中的详细搜索策略)。两名独立评审员系统地筛选了目标NMA,其中包括阿柏西普和雷珠单抗在DME患者中的比较。本综述感兴趣的关键结果是最佳矫正视力(BCVA)的变化,包括各种报告方式(例如在12个月时获得≥10个ETDRS字母的参与者比例;在12个月时BCVA的平均变化)。
结果:对于BCVA的二元结果,不同的NMA都同意两种治疗方法之间没有明显差异,虽然连续结局都比雷珠单抗更有利于阿柏西普.我们讨论了五个类似的NMA所说明的四个特别关注的点,包括网络差异,PICO(参与者,干预措施,比较器,结果)差异,来自相同效果度量的不同数据,以及真正重要的差异。
结论:仔细检查这些试验中的每一个,包括搜索和分析,都不同,但是发现,虽然呈现不同,有时解释不同,是相似的。
Different network meta-analyses (NMAs) on the same topic result in differences in findings. In this review, we investigated NMAs comparing aflibercept with ranibizumab for diabetic macular oedema (DME) in the hope of illuminating why the differences in findings occurred.
Studies were searched for in English and Chinese electronic databases (PubMed, Embase, Cochrane Library, Web of Science, CNKI, Wanfang, VIP; see detailed search strategy in the main body). Two independent reviewers systematically screened to identify target NMAs that included a comparison of aflibercept and ranibizumab in patients with DME. The key outcome of interest in this review is the change in best-corrected visual acuity (BCVA), including various ways of reporting (such as the proportion of participants who gain ≥ 10 ETDRS letters at 12 months; average change in BCVA at 12 months).
For the binary outcome of BCVA, different NMAs all agreed that there is no clear difference between the two treatments, while continuous outcomes all favour aflibercept over ranibizumab. We discussed four points of particular concern that are illustrated by five similar NMAs, including network differences, PICO (participants, interventions, comparators, outcomes) differences, different data from the same measures of effect, and differences in what is truly significant.
A closer inspection of each of these trials shows how the methods, including the searches and analyses, all differ, but the findings, although presented differently and sometimes interpreted differently, were similar.