目的:放射性肺炎(RP)是肺癌放疗(RT)患者的剂量限制性毒性,然而,诊断的最佳实践,管理,RP的随访仍不清楚。因此,我们试图通过德尔福共识研究建立专家共识建议。
方法:在第1轮中,开放性问题分发给31名治疗胸部恶性肿瘤的临床专家。在第2轮中,参与者使用5分李克特量表对从第1轮答案得出的陈述进行了同意/不同意评级。共识被定义为≥75%的协议。未达成共识的声明在第三轮中进行了修改和重新测试。
结果:第1轮的反应率为74%(n=23/31;17名肿瘤学家,6名肺科医师);第二轮中82%(n=19/23;15名肿瘤学家,4名肺科医师);在第3轮中占100%(n=19/19)。65个第二轮声明中有39个达成了共识;26个声明中有10个在第三轮中达成了共识。在第2轮中,一致认为风险分层/缓解包括患者因素;最佳治疗计划;RP诊断的基础;以及肿瘤学家和肺科医师应参与治疗。对于无并发症的放射性肺炎,相当于每天口服泼尼松60毫克,考虑到胃保护,是典型的初始方案。然而,在这项研究中,对于推荐给药没有达成共识.初始类固醇剂量应持续2周,随后是一个渐进的,每周锥度(相当于泼尼松每周减少10毫克)。对于严重的肺炎,建议在开始口服皮质类固醇前3天静脉注射甲基强的松龙。最后的共识声明包括RP的治疗应该是多学科的,肺炎是药物还是辐射引起的不确定性,以及风险分层的重要性,特别是在间质性肺病的情况下。
结论:本Delphi研究达成了共识建议,并为RP的诊断和治疗提供了实践指导。
OBJECTIVE: Radiation pneumonitis (RP) is a dose-limiting toxicity for patients undergoing radiotherapy (RT) for lung cancer, however, the optimal practice for diagnosis, management, and follow-up for RP remains unclear. We thus sought to establish expert
consensus recommendations through a Delphi
Consensus study.
METHODS: In Round 1, open questions were distributed to 31 expert clinicians treating thoracic malignancies. In Round 2, participants rated agreement/disagreement with statements derived from Round 1 answers using a 5-point Likert scale.
Consensus was defined as ≥ 75 % agreement. Statements that did not achieve
consensus were modified and re-tested in Round 3.
RESULTS: Response rate was 74 % in Round 1 (n = 23/31; 17 oncologists, 6 pulmonologists); 82 % in Round 2 (n = 19/23; 15 oncologists, 4 pulmonologists); and 100 % in Round 3 (n = 19/19). Thirty-nine of 65 Round 2 statements achieved
consensus; a further 10 of 26 statements achieved
consensus in Round 3. In Round 2, there was agreement that risk stratification/mitigation includes patient factors; optimal treatment planning; the basis for diagnosis of RP; and that oncologists and pulmonologists should be involved in treatment. For uncomplicated radiation pneumonitis, an equivalent to 60 mg oral prednisone per day, with consideration of gastroprotection, is a typical initial regimen. However, in this study, no
consensus was achieved for dosing recommendation. Initial steroid dose should be administered for a duration of 2 weeks, followed by a gradual, weekly taper (equivalent to 10 mg prednisone decrease per week). For severe pneumonitis, IV methylprednisolone is recommended for 3 days prior to initiating oral corticosteroids. Final consensus statements included that the treatment of RP should be multidisciplinary, the uncertainty of whether pneumonitis is drug versus radiation-induced, and the importance risk stratification, especially in the scenario of interstitial lung disease.
CONCLUSIONS: This Delphi study achieved consensus recommendations and provides practical guidance on diagnosis and management of RP.