复苏是COVID-19大流行如何长期影响社会的一个利基例子。那些受过心肺复苏(CPR)训练的人面临着试图挽救生命可能会导致自身伤害的困境。这对溺水来说是个最大的问题,缺氧是心脏骤停的原因,通气是扭转这种情况的第一步。
为水上救援组织在COVID-19大流行期间为救援人员提供安全的溺水复苏程序制定建议。
两个连续修改的德尔菲程序,涉及来自17个国家的56名参与者,他们在溺水预防研究方面具有专业知识,复苏,和编程从2020年3月28日至2021年3月29日进行。并行,搜索了PubMed和GoogleScholar,以确定与每个核心元素相关的新出现的证据,承认以前的研究与新的背景有关,并确定知识差距。
七个核心要素,每个人都有自己的具体建议,在最初的共识程序中确定,并分为4类:(1)预防和减轻感染风险,(2)COVID-19大流行期间溺水者的复苏,(3)组织责任,(4)组织无法满足建议的指导方针。减轻感染风险的常见措施,个人防护装备,疫苗接种是建议的基础。加大防溺水措施的力度减少了困境的根源。其他感染风险缓解措施包括筛查所有进入水生设施的人,定义无效复苏的标准,并避免高风险救援人员与溺水者接触。通风技术必须平衡所需的技能水平,氧气输送,感染风险,设备和培训费用。建议由2名训练有素的救援人员使用高效微粒空气过滤器进行袋式面罩通风。对这些方法的主要影响,设施,心肺复苏训练的环境已经确定,包括避免被感染或感染他人的非实用技能。最重要的是,该组织负责向其成员通报COVID-19大流行的影响,并采取措施最大限度地提高救援人员的安全。迫切需要研究来更好地理解,发展,并实施减少溺水复苏过程中感染传播的策略。
这份共识文件概述了水上救援组织在COVID-19大流行期间提高救援人员安全的建议,并平衡了潜在救生干预和救援人员风险之间的竞争利益。基于共识的建议也可以作为其他志愿者组织和可能提供复苏的利他主义外行的榜样。
Resuscitation is a niche example of how the COVID-19 pandemic has affected society in the long term. Those trained in cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) face the dilemma that attempting to save a life may result in their own harm. This is most of all a problem for drowning, where hypoxia is the cause of cardiac arrest and ventilation is the essential first step in reversing the situation.
To develop recommendations for water rescue organizations in providing their rescuers with safe drowning resuscitation procedures during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Two consecutive modified Delphi procedures involving 56 participants from 17 countries with expertise in drowning prevention research, resuscitation, and programming were performed from March 28, 2020, to March 29, 2021. In parallel, PubMed and Google Scholar were searched to identify new emerging evidence relevant to each core element, acknowledge previous studies relevant in the new context, and identify knowledge gaps.
Seven core elements, each with their own specific recommendations, were identified in the initial
consensus procedure and were grouped into 4 categories: (1) prevention and mitigation of the risks of becoming infected, (2) resuscitation of drowned persons during the COVID-19 pandemic, (3) organizational responsibilities, and (4) organizations unable to meet the recommended
guidelines. The common measures of infection risk mitigation, personal protective equipment, and vaccination are the base of the recommendations. Measures to increase drowning prevention efforts reduce the root cause of the dilemma. Additional infection risk mitigation measures include screening all people entering aquatic facilities, defining criteria for futile resuscitation, and avoiding contact with drowned persons by rescuers with a high-risk profile. Ventilation techniques must balance required skill level, oxygen delivery, infection risk, and costs of equipment and training. Bag-mask ventilation with a high-efficiency particulate air filter by 2 trained rescuers is advised. Major implications for the methods, facilities, and environment of CPR training have been identified, including nonpractical skills to avoid being infected or to infect others. Most of all, the organization is responsible for informing their members about the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic and taking measures that maximize rescuer safety. Research is urgently needed to better understand, develop, and implement strategies to reduce infection transmission during drowning resuscitation.
This
consensus document provides an overview of recommendations for water rescue organizations to improve the safety of their rescuers during the COVID-19 pandemic and balances the competing interests between a potentially lifesaving intervention and risk to the rescuer. The
consensus-based recommendations can also serve as an example for other volunteer organizations and altruistic laypeople who may provide resuscitation.