{Reference Type}: Journal Article {Title}: Image Guided Energy Ablation for Palliation of Painful Bony Metastases - A Systematic Review. {Author}: Yao PF;Hu A;Mansour F;Nadeem I;Jiang Y;Athreya S; {Journal}: J Vasc Interv Radiol {Volume}: 0 {Issue}: 0 {Year}: 2024 May 28 {Factor}: 3.682 {DOI}: 10.1016/j.jvir.2024.05.011 {Abstract}: OBJECTIVE: To analyze the effectiveness of image-guided energy ablation techniques with and without concurrent therapies in providing palliative pain relief in patients with bone metastases.
METHODS: OVID Embase, OVID Medline, and Pubmed were searched from inception to April 14th, 2023 using search terms relating to bone lesions and MeSH terms regarding ablation therapy. English peer-reviewed primary articles were included that reported pain scores following image-guided energy-based ablation of bone metastases. Exclusion criteria included 1) non-palliative treatment, 2) pain scores associated with specific treatment modalities not reported, and 3) non-metastatic bone lesions. Mean percentage reduction in pain score was calculated.
RESULTS: 1396 studies were screened and 54 were included. All but one study demonstrated decreased pain scores at final follow-up. Mean reduction in pain scores at final follow-up were 49% for radiofrequency ablation (RFA), 58% for radiofrequency ablation and adjunct (RFA-A), 54% for cryoablation (CA), 72% for cryoablation and adjunct (CA-A), 48% for microwave ablation (MWA), 81% for microwave ablation and adjunct (MWA-A), and 64% for high-intensity focused ultrasound (HIFU). Post-procedural adverse event rates were 4.9% for RFA, 34.8% for RFA-A, 9.6% for CA, 12.0% for CA-A, 48.9% for MWA, 33.5% for MWA-A and 17.0% for HIFU.
CONCLUSIONS: Image-guided energy ablation demonstrated consistently strong reduction in pain across all modalities, with variable post-procedural adverse event rates. Due to heterogeneity of included studies, quantitative analysis was not appropriate. Future primary research should focus on creating consistent prospective studies with established statistical power, explicit documentation and comparison to other techniques.