%0 Journal Article
%T Mental state decoders: game-changers or wishful thinking?
%A Vigotsky AD
%A Iannetti GD
%A Apkarian AV
%J Trends Cogn Sci
%V 0
%N 0
%D 2024 Jul 10
%M 38991876
%F 24.482
%R 10.1016/j.tics.2024.06.004
%X Decoding mental and perceptual states using fMRI has become increasingly popular over the past two decades, with numerous highly-cited studies published in high-profile journals. Nevertheless, what have we learned from these decoders? In this opinion, we argue that fMRI-based decoders are not neurophysiologically informative and are not, and likely cannot be, applicable to real-world decision-making. The former point stems from the fact that decoding models cannot disentangle neural mechanisms from their epiphenomena. The latter point stems from both logical and ethical constraints. Constructing decoders requires precious time and resources that should instead be directed toward scientific endeavors more likely to yield meaningful scientific progress.