%0 Journal Article
%T The book of Matthew 'On naval timber and arboriculture'. Its structure and development.
%A Dagg JL
%A Derry JF
%J Ann Sci
%V 0
%N 0
%D 2024 Apr 4
%M 38572665
%F 0.343
%R 10.1080/00033790.2024.2306141
%X The book of Patrick Matthew (1790-1874) 'On Naval Timber and Arboriculture' has regularly thwarted readers' attempts of interpretation. The problems seem to extend beyond analysing and interpreting its evolutionary passages. Building upon previous studies, this analysis presents evidence that the book's structure itself may have contributed significantly to its reception by sundry readers as somehow either clear or obscure, consequently leading to a diversity of interpretations. First, the book does not have a consistent literary form. Second, it presents a miscellany of juxtaposed contents. Third, its readers approach it from different contexts. Internal evidence shows that Patrick Matthew added a lot of material, while the manuscript was already in the proof-reading or press stage. This explains why it provides no consistent literary form or integrated content that would have helped interpretation. Hence readers have been left to their own devices, and their interpretation depended more strongly than usual on their own contexts.