%0 Letter %T A QALY is [still] a QALY is [still] a QALY? : Evaluating proportional shortfall as the answer to the problem of equity in healthcare allocations. %A Mahdiani H %A Münch N %A Paul NW %J BMC Med Ethics %V 25 %N 1 %D 2024 Mar 23 %M 38521941 %F 2.834 %R 10.1186/s12910-024-01036-w %X Despite clinical evidence of drug superiority, therapeutic modalities, like combination immunotherapy, are mostly considered cost-ineffective due to their high costs per life year(s) gained. This paper, taking an ethical stand, reevaluates the standard cost-effectiveness analysis with that of the more recent justice-enhanced methods and concludes by pointing out the shortcomings of the current methodologies.